Who doesnt cut the grade?

Ranger isn't fit to serve half tine cuppas

 

Exactly what I went for too. <Ok>
I've given Willo plenty of stick, but at least he is a pro and tries his best. Ranger is a waste of space.
Gosling is hasn't impressed at all and living up to the stick he got from Everton fans - either injured or looks out of sorts when occasionally playing.

 

Presumably we should vote for whoever didn't make the mustard?

 

What have the Mackems got against Overthewall?

 

Ranger has potential, but is a cancer.(Out)
Gosling spends as much time on the treatment table as Micky/Dyer, even when playing is pretty hopeless(Out)
Willo but I agree with Tash that he's a decent 4th string CB, just don't make him start every game (Keep, replacement is a luxury)
Simmo Get Out
Sammy still young, is as much of a headless chicken as Obertan, but the potential is there. If he can harness his potential he could be as good as Bale(that's too far I know, but think of the similarities...Long Lanky Fast Dribbler)

Jonas and Marveaux would ideally be squad players, but theír salaries are a bit too large for that.

 

I do not agree that

I think he has the potential to one of the best we have but he is not pushing enough. Hes having a walk in the park.

i am a long legged lanky dribble with a blistering shot and good cross. 6ft 5. Good acceleration and top speed with good power. I know how he plays i see it. And he can do better. So maybe im jealous lol. But o well i still think he is not good enough to be in the current team

 

funny how everyone seems to want ryan taylor more than guti still after chelsea lmao.

i like guti, Shame he hasnt got his old legs tho

 

He really needs a classic player to take him under his wing. Ideally, it'll be Ryan Giggs. Sammy just is clueless how to play the game at the moment... Sending crosses where there's nobody in the box, he can dribble pretty well considering his height, but he needs to be a more effective player. Has got to work on his all-round game instead of just his dribbling for sure.

So you could say that I kinda agree. He needs to realise that he can far surpass his brother , and stop looking up to him..

 

Spot on brov

Its the same as any other player trying to match there game to anyone else. It will only make you a wrose player cos your playing like someone else and not you

Sammy can surpass his brother yes, Shola could have surpassed himself but he has never had to, His involvment in the club has been secure for years, now so is sammies. I dont have this in my job neither should they..

 

It's not fair on any of the other players to be in a poll ranking poor standards alongside Nile Ranger.

That waster is in a league of his own. At least the likes of Willo etc try for the team.

 

Great minds. Look at post no. 22

 

I think Willo, Gosling, Ranger.

I have my doubts about Sammy, lacks football intelligence. But young enough to see how he fairs out on loan learning the game.

Simpson, Ameobi are not great but I can see roles for them. Simpson will leave as he wants to play. We saw the value of his defensive work again against Metalist though, people overlook it all too readily for me. Ameobi can still do the big man role for 15mins at the end of games.

Raylor, Jonas are important squad players to me, just should not be in the poll in my opinion but others see it different so fair enough.

Cisse - I am surprised by the short term outlook on him. He is a good striker. Happy to have him despite a loss of form.

Marveaux, while I understand his inclusion and he wouldn't be in my starting xi, there is obvious talent and I think he is decent back up for an advanced creator. If you take away his defensive responsibility and sit him in front of two holders, he does look canny.

 

Im very distressed at people lack of faith in cisse. It seems like last season was nothing when he scored some of the most magical goals to bless a black and white shirt since shearer was here.

He will come good, I have black and white faith in him

 

Guti 8 votes
Cisse 6 votes
Marveaux 4 votes

...really?

They don't even deserve a mention imo