The #LUFC Breakfast Debate (Thursday 30th October)

Good Morning. It's Thursday 30th October, and here are the latest headlines from Elland Road

Jonny Howson: Coming Home to Leeds United

Jonny Howson has been been speaking to Beren Cross from the New York Times, about life back at Leeds Utd, albeit head coach of the Under U21's. It marks a full-circle moment steeped in pride, purpose, and continuity. Thirteen years after leaving Elland Road, the boy from Morley has stepped back through the gates not as the midfield general who once captained Leeds to promotion, but as a mentor guiding the next generation of Whites through their own footballing journeys. After nearly two decades as a professional and 754 senior appearances across Leeds, Norwich, and Middlesbrough, Howson is beginning a new chapter as a player-coach for the club’s under-21s.

Leeds supporters remember him as one of their own: a hard‑working local lad who wore his heart on his sleeve. The image of Howson leading Leeds out, three miles from where he grew up, remains etched into club folklore. Now 37, the same sense of belonging draws him back to West Yorkshire, but this time with a whistle around his neck rather than the captain’s armband. His return was first hinted at in a simple but symbolic gesture: his brother Daniel’s Facebook post showing a training top marked “JH.” For Leeds fans, that was enough to spark waves of nostalgia and excitement.

Howson’s transition into coaching isn’t a leap in the dark. Whilst at Boro, he quietly earned his UEFA B Licence, and his mind was already turning toward life after playing. When Leeds' under‑21s head coach Scott Gardner mentioned a potential opportunity, it felt like fate calling him home. “When you’re going into something new, it’s a bit daunting,” Howson admitted in his recent interview, “but there was excitement because it’s Leeds, what the club means to me.” That blend of apprehension and pride captures exactly what this new role represents: a challenge embraced out of love.

Though coaching now takes up his days, Howson’s approach remains grounded in the values that defined his career, work ethic, humility, and commitment. He knows that his playing reputation can open doors, but respect in coaching must be earned anew. “Past playing experiences take me so far,” he says, emphasizing that the real task lies in proving himself as a mentor. He wants his players to see not only the former Leeds captain but a coach who genuinely cares about their growth, who stays late to talk through a tactical detail or a bit of career advice.

In shaping his coaching philosophy, Howson draws from those who influenced him: Alex Neil’s clarity and tactical precision at Norwich, and Michael Carrick’s analytical calm at Middlesbrough. Those experiences have molded him into someone who values simplicity, clear communication, and connection. Still, beneath the tactical frameworks and training schedules, his core motivation is emotional, a desire to give back to the club that gave him everything.

Leeds have always prided themselves on their academy, a pipeline of talent rooted in Yorkshire grit. With Howson now helping to shape its next wave, the story feels right. The lad from Morley, who guided Leeds out of the third tier, has returned to help make new dreams possible. For the ER faithful, it isn’t just about nostalgia, it’s about legacy.

please log in to view this image

Italian giants preparing Gnonto bids

With the January transfer window looming, Leeds United find themselves at a crossroads, with Italian giants Juventus and Inter Milan reportedly circling young winger Wilfried Gnonto. The promising Italy international, once regarded as one of Leeds’ brightest attacking prospects, now faces an uncertain future in West Yorkshire. While his raw ability and fearless style of play have endeared him to fans, a combination of injuries and fierce competition has limited him to just 194 minutes of league football this season. For a player eager to secure regular minutes ahead of next year’s World Cup, the lure of returning to Serie A, and perhaps a more consistent role, could prove difficult to resist.

For Leeds, however, the situation is as much about financial strategy as footballing ambition. The club’s hierarchy is well aware that reinforcements are needed if they are to stay clear of the relegation battle and preserve their Premier League status. At the same time, the reality of Financial Fair Play regulations means that room must be made, both in the squad and on the balance sheet, before significant new signings can be pursued. Selling Gnonto could provide such an opportunity. With his market value hovering around £25 million, a transfer deal of that magnitude could go a long way toward funding two or three crucial additions to Daniel Farke’s squad.

Yet, as is often the case in football, the deal is not straightforward. Leeds are reportedly hampered by a substantial sell-on clause; believed to be as high as 40%, owed to FC Zürich, Gnonto’s former club. Former player-turned-journalist Kay Voser told the Breakfast Debate that the Swiss club’s president personally describing it as “extraordinarily high.” If accurate, such terms could make the financial benefits of selling Gnonto considerably less appealing for Leeds, forcing the club to weigh immediate reinvestment needs against long-term potential.

For the ER faithful, the situation stirs mixed emotions. Gnonto’s flashes of brilliance have offered glimpses of what could have been; a fearless young forward capable of changing games in an instant. But as the January market looms, Leeds must consider the bigger picture. Balancing ambition, financial responsibility, and the dream of stability in England’s top flight, the club faces a pivotal decision. Whether Gnonto remains part of that journey or becomes a stepping stone toward its continuation, the coming weeks promise to test both Leeds United’s resolve and their vision for the future.

please log in to view this image

Joffy playing massive part in Hull's play off push

Joe  Gelhardt’s resurgence at Hull City has been one of the Championship’s most captivating storylines this season, and one that Leeds United fans will watch with mixed emotions. Once heralded as one of the brightest young forwards at Elland Road, Gelhardt’s opportunities dried up and left on the bench to rot. A loan move was the natural next step, and as it turns out, Hull has proven to be the perfect platform for the 23‑year‑old to rediscover his spark.

Last season, Gelhardt made an instant impression at the MKM Stadium, scoring five goals in 20 appearances and helping the Tigers maintain stability in a turbulent campaign. His return on a second loan spell this summer has only underlined his progression; sharper, more confident, and with a clearer sense of identity on the pitch, he has become central to Sergej Jakirovic’s attacking system. Deployed predominantly on the right flank, Gelhardt’s blend of direct running, sharp interplay, and clinical finishing has lifted Hull to the cusp of the play‑off places. With five goals and an assist in just a dozen league appearances, his productivity has made him one of the division’s standout performers.

Yet, as his goals continue to flow, Whites fans can’t help but ponder what his form means for both clubs. While Leeds hold his contract until the summer of 2027, his performances have inevitably drawn fresh attention from potential suitors. Should his value continue to rise, the Yorkshire club could be tempted to recall and sell while his stock is high, a move that would benefit Leeds financially but could derail Hull’s momentum. For the Tigers, restricted by financial fair play constraints, the prospect of losing their in‑form winger mid‑season represents a genuine concern.

Joffy's success is a reminder of the talent nurtured at Elland Road, even if circumstances forced his opportunities elsewhere. Whether his future lies back in West Yorkshire or beyond, his performances in Hull’s amber and black show a player reborn; a confident, mature forward proving he still has a bright career ahead.

please log in to view this image

 

Morning all,

Keep Gnonto for the season. Better than trying to replace him with a player at least as good for what would effectively be around £12m after deductions.

And if he misses out on Italy’s WC squad as a result, so be it. **** happens. It’s not the club’s problem.

He tried to force a move away. And although he’s redeemed himself somewhat, the club owes him nothing.

 

Hard for Gnonto to get his place anywhere if he’s gonna be injured all the time

 

Is he even in the senior squad, I thought that he’d been playing for their U21s?

 

He's got 13 caps for the full international team. Scored one goal.

 

Greetings all

The Gnonto situation is an interesting one and I think the transfer will happen...

We already know that the 49ers will sell for profit we saw that when we sold the likes of Gray, Rutter, Summerville and Kamara. Now we only spent £5 million and his current value is £22 million according to Transfer Market.com. We know that Gnonto wants to go back to Italy and I think the lure of Jive or Inter might be too much.

The board has already said that they want 2 or 3 players in January but we've got 25 senior players. We know Mes will be leaving in Jan if all goes right. We've been linked with that kid in Israel and the likes of Chris Wood and Ivan Toney and let's not forget we're meant to be going back in for Harry Wilson. We have to sell this January!!!

Now there's a 22 year old in Brazil Gustavo Prado we are meant to be interested in. He could possibly be a Gnonto replacement. I've already mentioned that j think Red Bull has a say in our transfer targets now and I think that Prado fits that bill along with the kid from Israel.

 

I've yet to see anything from Gnonto to suggest he's good enough for Juve or Inter. Infact when we have a full squad to choose from he's rarely been a starter for us.

 

although in reality, we have had very few players aged 21 or under who have been regular starters in the first 11 over the last 7 or 8 years

 

True but non of the 21's we've bought through have gone on to play at the top level either, Gray and Somerville in the PL.Gray hardly getting game time now they have a fit squad. Perhaps our academy isnt as great as folk like to think.

 

oh I'm not disagreeing with your point about whether Willi is good enough for Juve or Inter, I just disagree with the general consensus that we need to get rid of him, because he's a bench warmer at present (when fit)

 

I think if we get rid of the players that keep getting mentioned then we are going to have a very small squad , no one should be sold unless we have a better replacement lined up.

 

Didnt include any details until they had made at least 10 starts in a season

 

I agree and doubt we’d get a huge haul of money for him especially with his 40% sell on clause

 

he's been injured twice since he joined us, which meant he has missed a total of 10 games in 4 years (so far) due to injury

 

It’s competitive at the top… it does happen obviously but there are surprisingly few forward players who are regularly setting the world on fire and scoring at the highest level until they reach 22/23. Look at Semenyo..the new big thing. He’s nearly 26. 3 years ago he was at Bristol city. (By the way I remember watching him then thinking he was a real handful… but you get the drift)

Gnonto will soon be 22.

There are obviously many more promising teenagers who never make that next step. Personally I think Gnonto had good match awareness and physicality at an early age and may be as good as he’ll ever be already… but it’s dangerous to write players off at this age. Still plenty of time for the likes of him, Joseph to improve.

… and on behalf of doc… joffy is scoring 1 in 2 on the champ at the moment @23.

 

Afternoon all

if we sell Gnonto in January, it will probably mean we still have Farke in charge.

If we still have Farke in charge it will mean we’re not in a relegation battle

On that basis not all bad if he’s sold although I’d consider it a mistake doing so

 

Everyone is fit according to Farke... Panic over end of debate over little willy.

 

Gnonto has alot going for him. He has decent pace, especially when carrying the ball, quick feet, low centre of gravity, is strong, has a very good first touch, has good vision and his weight of pass is usually spot on.

I wouldn't sell him.

In January we could offload the fringe lads like a Gelhardt, Meslier, Gruev, Piroe and Harrison if we can. That would give us funds to spend in January if required. If we are mid table and looking safe then leave the squad as it is and go for it next summer again.

As Gessa said, anyone that leaves needs to be replaced by better players.

 

The Gelhardt thing is more strange than you think. Everyone knows my views on Joffy and a couple of weeks ago I stated he would walk on a free at the end of the season. I was corrected by Aski (not for the first time) and others.Yet today Ger from The View said Hull could lose out as plenty of clubs thinking of buying Gelhardt in January and if Joffy stayed loyal to Hull he would walk away on a free in June? So conflicting reports on his contract.

I digress Gelhardt was coached under Bielsa and played various roles in the U23smainly sharing the No9 role with the 10 role and sometimes wide right and wide left. This season he is being used as a 10 or LW or RW and on occasions at 9. Wouldn’t we have been wiser keeping him and using on either wing when we needed someone due to injuries or even at ten. I appreciate most on here think the kid is shyte but I dont I just feel he was shafted after losing a whole season not playing football and he now catching up

 

How many games would Gelhardt have appeared in so far this season?

My answer would be none. So he'd lose another year of his career.