do you rate gibson ?

im not asking this as a lfc fan im asking as an irishman and gibson had a good game last night scoring a cracker just wonder wot united fans think of him

 

****. slow, immobile, passing is ok but shoots on sight when other options available. he'll score a belter for every 20 shots he takes. my only worry about trappatonis claim that he should leave united to improve is that fergie will give him more first team football

 

he's about level with anderson in my reckoning.

potential, but as yet unrealised.

 

I hate things like this. I don't judge player's until they need to be.
Gibson is a squad player at the moment, and i wouldn't big up or slag off Park in the same respect.
Who know's how good he'll be one day, i think he should have been sent out on loan by now for the manager and us to have a proper good look at him.
There's no point looking at a player 1 game in 5 and expecting them to be on fire.

 

He is ****ing **** and the sooner he ****s off out the club I support the better. Awful footballer. Im not just saying that as a utd fan who doesnt think he is good enough but as a football fan who thinks he is just utterly garbage.

Imbobile
Cant pass
Cant tackle
Bottles even attemting tackles
Is unfit
Messes up his shooting a lot more than he gets it right.

He is your average nothing player. Garbage.

 

He was, too wolves in the championship and he looked **** there aswell. Even there fans didnt rate him,.

 

Right now he doesn't look good enough. But then that's what people said about Fletcher five or six years ago,and he's turned into a solid player. So Gibson still has some potential, but right now I can't seen him being anything more than a squad player, probably sold on in a year or so to make room for someone better.

 

I don't reate him particularly highly but he's a squad player and you aren't going to have world class players who are happy to play that role. If he got himself to the gym and worked on his physique (he looks a bit heavy) then it would help but I don't see him ever being a top player. A move elsewhere may well be the best option for him if he wants regular first team football as he isn't good enough to be in our first team.

And he is not as good as Anderson.