About 10 years ago or so I was looking around for some swashbucking stuff. So I started to read the first Hornblower novel,
The Happy Return [1937], by C.S. Forester. I got about 10 pages in when I suddenly realised that this couldn't be the first book in chronological order. Cue for me to buy the first one in the right order of fictional time, which was
Mr. Midshipman Hornblower [1950].
9 books later, and
Lord Hornblower [1946], the 9th novel of 11, was enough for me. I'd had enough of C.S. Forester. I thought I'd had enough of fictional seafaring novels altogether. But Patrick O'Brian's first
Aubrey & Maturin adventure,
Master & Commander, had been dramatised on BBC Radio 4 in 1996, and I'd recorded it back then but never got around to listening to it [the movie is adventures from several books in the series]. So I did listen, and it was bloody fantastic. I mean really, really good. So good I didn't want it to finish, good. So about 7-8 years ago I bought the first 4 novels in a deal off ebay and devoured them. Subsequently, I've read another 3. So along with
M&C, we now have
Post Captain,
HMS Surprise,
The Mauritius Command,
Desolation Island,
The Surgeon's Mate, and
The Fortune of War. Fortunately, every time I've wanted to read another in the series, BBC Radio 4 have announced that they are about to broadcast a dramatisation or a reading [The Surgeon's Mate was read by Benedict Cumberbatch - not brilliantly IMO, but good enough] When they dramatised the Fortune of War they included The Surgeon's Mate in the first part. So I get to put voices to characters as I read - a nice bonus. That's 7 books of 21 in the series. I have a second batch of 6 books just waiting for their moments. This could be the time to start
Part 2, so to speak.
So what can I suggest from this? The Hornblower novels are well worth reading. For me, the first 5, 6, maybe 7 are absolute page-turners. The old 1950's film adventure starring Gregory Peck is buried in this first half dozen odd somewhere, IIRC. I tended to find the books getting a little bit stodgy near the end, especially Lord Hornblower, which I barely finished. Maybe I had had enough, as mentioned earlier.
Patrick O'Brian books might have a narrower appeal, to the slightly more nerdy type. So far, to me they are absolute gold. Really intelligently written, with real historical references [Hornblower did so too at times], and I love the technical speak of the era [Hornblower does this far less], which really puts you in the moment. I highly recommend you read either set in order, as if you assume you will carry on to the next book. The next in the series is made all the easier to follow, having read preceding novels. All this reference to the series is making me think about picking up the next book -
The Ionian Mission.
https://www.bookseriesinorder.com/c-s-forester/
https://www.bookseriesinorder.com/patrick-obrian/