Player Rating by Sound

Yes, I didn't see anything, yet I am gonna do some ratings based on how the commentators described them.

Elliot - 5 - seemed average. Would've rather had Krul on.
Simmo - 6 - ****e in defence, but got a vital goal.
Colo - 6 - same as Simmo
Perch - 6 - better display from him.
Ferguson - 5 - got overpowered by Forest players, don't know what would happen to him if he played against B'Burn on the LB position.
Arfa - 7 - getting back into the game, and showed touches of his previous self.
Marv - 8 - MotM for me. Despite not seeing him playing, he seemed like he played well.
Abeid - 6 - was kinda invisible tbh.
Gosling - 6 - also invisible
Guthrie - 7 - better than the other two, but i won't see more of these three until the LCS.
Lover - 6 - 2 ****e goals, but who cares.

Stroller - 4
Sammy - 6
Obertan - 6

Average display but at least we are scoring again!

 

Obertan did more than Sammy, he got the assist for Colo's goal at the end, would maybe bump him up a bit.

 

Elliot-Average 5, but Ferguson overpowered and still also 5. Abeid and Gosling "invisible" yet get 6. Strange ratings

 

When you said "ratings by sound" I thought you meant like this...

Elliot - Meh
Simmo - Hmmm
Colo - WOOO!
Perch - Pffft
Ferguson - Huh?
Arfa - Mmmhhmmm
Marv - Ohh!
Abeid - Eyyyyy!
Gosling - Errrrrmmm... Hmm!
Guthrie - Ahh
Lover - Duhhh

 

I thought Guthrie sounded like he did pretty well

 

By the sounds of it mind, that is all that he did.

 

guthrie (at one point in the second half i thought he'd been taken off)/fergie and gosling hardly got a mention all match so i'd change guthries rating and abeid had a good game granted he faded in the later stages but he was miles better than the 3 mentioned

 

Wasn't impressed by Elliot, at all. Would've rather Harper played to be honest.

Marv was brilliant. Totally unmarked for a lot of it though. Very speedy, some excellent crosses, great vision.

Perch, dare I say, wasn't bad! 50/50 to be honest. Played a couple of decent balls at times.

 

Harper's rating by sound would most definitely have been "Brrrrrrriiiiiinnnnnnnggggg"... Say it with an upward inflection at the end.

 

Harsh, to be honest. His first header was actually pretty decent. Fantastic cross by Marv but Lover got that decent final touch on it. Nothing wrong with the goal. Penalty was almost saved but he scored it so that's all that matters.

haha, yes, I imagine something like that!!

 

Abeid was class, like a mini tiote, wanted the ball was confident and wasn't scared to tackle plus his range of passing, first touch etc was awesome, looks a real find!

 

Elliot - 4 - very poor mistakes, positional sense non-existent.
Simpson - 6 - Decent at times but gave the ball away and got caught out
Colo - 8 - Simply class. 3 conceded goals yes but none really his fault.
Perch - 7 - Scary start but played well I thought.
Fergie - 6 - Not bad and offered good support for Marveaux but gave the ball away a little bit too much.
Gosling - 5 - Didn't do much
Guthrie - 7 - Played well, some key passes and tackles
Abeid - 7 - Got a bit sloppy towards the end but I like what I see.
Marveaux - 8 - The skill to win the penalty was class. Really played well and has to start on Saturday.
Ben Arfa - 8 - Some moments of brilliance. Glad to have him back!
Lovenkrands - 8 - 2 goals, put himself about but still don't rate him.

Sammy - 7 - Got at them a lot but nothing to aim for in the box.
Obertan - 4 - Poor again.
Shola - 3 - Lazy, offside, ****.

 

ridiculous to give player ratings based on radio commentary, especially if its based on 5Live. They barely talked about the game.

 

I was there so I believe mine have some justification.

 

Nice one, was talking about the OP

 

Some of these rating are outrageous ! so bias towards favoured/unfavoured players

It's not match rating its just who I like ratings ...

 

Opinions are always bias.

 

I was really disappointed with Gosling to be honest. Seemed virtually non existent and made some poor passes. Not as good as I was expecting. Marveaux was simply something else though. Amazed!

And my dad was shocked at how many times Shola was getting caught offside, but I was just like yeah that's Shola!

He got caught twice in the space of a minute didn't he?

 

Twice? Think it was three times. I'm not sure he won a header either. Absolute cack.

Heard quite a few "get out of our club" chants last night, first time since mid championship season. Retaliation to the new sports direct branding at the ground?