i think you're overthinking this. just remember Chaos wrote this so use the clues to work out when he is referring to Shipman or Brown though normally Dr -Shipman Doc- Brown.
ok... i said this 5. there are 4 investigators, shipman, bishop, mafia bin ladin and shorty but short is gone? I presume shipman now knows who doc brown is and the other 2 know something as well. RHC said its wrong But theres several things i might be wrong on. 1. 4 investigators. I focused in on this. 2. shorty is gone?? He vansihed in post 1 so maybe rhc is saying this? 3. I presumed shipman knows who doc brown is... is this what RHC is referring to? so... I re-read rules. binladen is first investigator mentioned shipman is second shorty was third but he vanished didn't he? bishop is 4th. I don't see any moention of another investigator role. so.... was no 2 or no 3 wrong?
By my reckoning 3 is correct as Shipman was the only killer role left unaccounted for last night so must have been the Doc had to use his power to escape. On the investigators like you i can only see 4 & have no idea what RHC is on about though i'm less trusting of him than you though that is possibly as i've been his team mate and he tried to chuck me under a bus.
Last time I worked out who everyone was #dayone MITO had a #meltdown and cancelled the game Chaos is already on the edge so I'll go easy on him and not just blow the whole game wide open MITO is Putin BTW it would be a good idea for the good guys to protect me
I think my logic from yesterday proved decent (at least once) I'm thinking that the code should be somewhere that codes would be stored so (main office was my pick after yesterday. I think the briefing room or the life support but I'm not pushed. the options are Hanger Mess hall Main office (found a code here) Briefing room Storage area life support. (not on chaos's list... is that a clue??) IF the logic to go to main office was sound then breifing room would seem logical. We need the code chaos said Mafia have 2 of 3 codes The rest have 1 of 3 codes
I think you are right. The shorty and crunk vanishing line only makes sense if they had to be removed from game. that would be 3 live investigators. I agree on the shiman one too as the order of night tells me that
You'll find that that game was cos i completely messed up on the order of names and you noticed and we restarted the game the day after. But this time you not got it right.
I'm not sure astro. He was one of two-three people I had down as possible putins and then his posts today do seem to tell me either he is Putin or he's part of the mafia so knows who putin is. I feel I'm getting far with this too.
I think you are right. The shorty and crunk vanishing line only makes sense if they had to be removed from game. that would be 3 live investigators. I agree on the shipman one too as the order of night tells me as shipman acts later and the post about the doc came after the others it must be him. As for RHC If i kept saying roles i'm sure he'd give me the thumbs up but I don't think its a particularly good plan.
I've identified 4 including myself that RHC showed up as possible putins.... but I've cottoned onto a bit of teamwork here
Ah ha. I think your "attack is the best form of defence" gives me the final proof I needed. As for voting patterns I'm looking through them myself. I can clarify my own easily though, I was tied 2-2 with Valley for getting lynched so it was a fast choice of "who can i throw under the bus here"! Tonight will be different though as I'll clarify with Darren and Astro who to vote for in advance. ...oh nuts...
yeah that makes sense, you just voted onto same person astro was already on which is of course fair to save yourself. nice of you to confirm you are in a team of 3 there though.