1. Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!

Verdit on Squad Changes

Discussion in 'Arsenal' started by RVP - The Dutcher Master, Aug 20, 2011.

  1. RVP - The Dutcher Master

    RVP - The Dutcher Master Member

    Joined:
    Jun 1, 2011
    Messages:
    52
    Likes Received:
    2
    So we ended last season very disappointing knowing reinforcements were needed and some dead weight needed to go...


    GK

    Sell/Demote - Almunia >
    Replaced with - Szczency (Obvious replacement, somewhat of a gamble at only 20 but looks real quality)
    VERDICT - MASSIVE IMPROVEMENT

    DEFENCE
    Sell - Eboue >
    Bought - Jenkinson (Eboue was always a prone to error but sometime useful sub, Jenkinson is very young and inexperienced so not sure how much that improves us?)
    VERDICT - MINIMAL IMPROVEMENT

    Sell - Clichy > Promote - Gibbs (Gibbs is VERY injury prone and doesn't look ready, Clichy wasn't great but I think he was still better)
    VERDICT - WEAKENS THE SIDE

    MIDFIELD
    Loan - Denilson >
    Promote - Frimpong (No question Frimpong is the better player but he's still raw and needs time to be eased in)
    VERDICT - MINIMAL IMPROVEMENT

    Sell - Cesc >
    ?? Promote - Ramsey (NO REPLACEMENT bought so for now looks like Ramsey will fill in, has had a very poor start to the season, look lightweight and the games can pass him...massive step backwards i hope we can buy someone who comes close to Cescs quality but that ain't happening)
    VERDICT - MASSIVE WEAKNESS

    Sell? - Nasri >
    Bought - Gervinho (Not a like for like but I think Gervinho can provide more for us, more attacking but will play in a simlair postions as part of the front 3 and i'd be shocked if he didn't get better stats than Nasri)
    VERDICT - IMPROVEMENT

    Loan - Vela >
    Promote - Ryo (Looks a real talent but tough to ask to much from him at such a young age, Vela flattered to decisive so if Ryo gets a bit part to play I'm sure he produce more
    VERDICT - IMPROVEMENT

    Bought - Chamberlain (Not sure where he fits in now, I can't believe he'd be any worse than the way Arshavin is playing now)


    FORWARDS
    Sell? - Bendtner >
    Bought - Campbell (ANOTHER YOUNGSTER!!! Real hype about him but if RVP is out for weeks/months can he lead the line if needed?? I doubt it. Bendtner had some talent but was often played out of position)
    VERDICT - ??

    So our overall squad is similar if not WEAKER than last to last year so how can we hope to improve? Still no new CB and with Chamakh's form I'd petrified if RVP gets any hint of a injury. All who finished above us improved so if we're barely
     
    #1

Share This Page