Although the numbers look a lot more skewed in favour of the bad guys in this game, the medium could be very helpful. Lots of investigation results could be posted on the dead board even if someone died before revealing their results.
There's a lot of stuff going on here. I think theres a few things we do know. 1. Valley was sheriff 2. 5 bad out of 12 for me to pick from. If i go random i have nearly 50% chance now of voting for a bad guy. (cos i'm a good guy) 3. we dont know what town towns there are in game nor the neutral roles, nor the mafia roles par se.. but we know how many people there are. 4. Valley got killed. Now.... what does that tell me? someone else made one comment but for me the best thing to say is someone who knew what went on in prior games selected him as perfect first mafia kill. it points fingers at Nev and at newkie fans valley loves to wind up.... but anyone who's played prior games would know this and could select him. I am open minded on who killed him. Obviously i would not say that if i were mafia as saying it was nev or newcastle fan who did it would be cover for me. 5. Were are possible roles so... can we match actions to those roles? people have said stuff. they could be all bullshitting or not. For example Chaos said he's invincible.. that could mean he's got a role where he can't be killed... thats pure speculations. Equally some people are pushing one or two for votes. There's an executioner role that fits... is there one?
We also have to be more careful about throwing votes around this time too. Voting for the wrong person could get us killed. Going to read back through the possible roles and see what fits.
I am going to do an totally random vote anyway. theres one team of 3 out there and everyone else is on thier own so the team of three are only ones who might be trying to guide vote.
Unless there is an executioner. Looking at the possible roles, I don't think their will be an executioner and a jester (as the executioner becomes a jester). I do think there will be either a vampire or werewolf with the ability to create a team.
Don't forget it's Town Lynch tonight; get your votes in, as it stands it looks like this: 1 - ACS (Penfold) 1 - Mikey (Musty) 1 - MoreHope (ACS)
As I understand it if there is amn executor he will be trying to get someone lynched. I get your point about it being unlikely there is both an executor and a jester. That makes sense. I thought there would be a werewolf so I get your assumption there. There was no action I can see by either yet so... it could be either or another. Does 14 player game need two bad Teams? Dunno.
So turns out having a set of night actions initially doesn't make day 1 any less of a crapshoot then! Probably just actually random.org my vote at this rate to be honest. Shame that there are apparently so many people who could be accused of targeting Valley haha.
Not by me unless they get picked up in the Daily Squib. The Squib really only reports on deaths, so anything else would be at the discretion of the villager to reveal.
Ok. So there are certain actions that people wouldn't reveal - such as being turned to vampire. However, if anyone is doused in petrol, then that would be helpful information to share (without giving away your role). I think people should share anything that does not give away their own role. Info sharing will be very important in this game with the way the numbers are set up.
I'd have left Valery alive. He was always target no.1 for a lot of players in this game, had he survived he'd have become the top Mafia suspect imo.
