I'm happy with both being in the starting line up. SWP needs a goal that isn't wrongly disallowed. He did get swamped and lost possession a bit yesterday but worked hard enough. Overall I'm happy with him. Mackie was superb yesterday and made Evra look ordinary. His workrate is excellent, his skill isn't world class but is good and often overlooked. I assume the question comes in light of Adel's very tidy cameo but, as well as he did, likely as he looked to make something happen and for all the extra effort he put in, he didn't look match fit and so should play 30 mins ATM. So pleased to see him in hoops again.
How can you say Adel didn't look match fit? He's never exactly been Mr skinny!! He looked sharp to me!
Why the poll choice between Mackie and SWP ? Surely we should be playing both ? SWP right, Traore left, Mackie up top with HH Bring Adel and DJ on earlier 2nd half if we're chasing the game
Someone said that I should do a poll on SWP, as they said they would choose Mackie over SWP anyday and here it is.
Lots of handbags on here today. Maybe someone should do a poll: Mulberry or Burberry, which handbag is best
I thought some said what about a Pole over Mackie or SWP. Personally, both SWP and Mackie both need a goal to kick start their season off and once off the duck I reckon both will get double figures this season.
SWP all day long, without question. Ninj, both to get double figures, are you living in cloud cuckoo land or what?
I voted for Jamie because he's playing better at the moment but I think SWP is more valuable overall.
We should play both of them v Sunderland. The Mackems have no real left sided players, especially in defence. Double-up SWP and Mackie on the right wing, and that will cause them huge problems. They played R/B Bardsley at left back on Sunday and Richardson there v Stoke. If Warnock gets his tactics right for this one we should get a win, as long as he goes for it.
Boys - i am an optomist.......I have supported QPR for too long. Both players have the talent, both need a goal. If Mackie can get one, he will go on a run like he did when he first came.....and no-one expected that! SWP just needs to get his shooting boots on, someone metioned earlier that we don't sore from distance, SWP has done that with previous clubs. If we had a "fox-in-the-box" to get the goal keeper fumbles from long shots then maybe we would climb the table. Sing your hearts out tomorrow - I feel a home win coming on
SWP everytime for me. would like to see on the right more ( like his first two games vs newcastle and wolves ). Would not have mackie in there at the moment , i get the feeling he has been rushed back in and looks nowhere near like scoring. Maybe time to give dj a run out from the start tonight. I can see Helgusson getting joy out of bramble and Brown , need someone to pick up the pieces. If DJ starts tonigh i reckon he will score. Have a feeling that bendtner will give our centre halfs a torrid time tonight, we struggle badly against big forwards.
