Adel was amazing but SWP was great too.... Adel 1, SWP2...but the whole team played well Ir was a great great performance....even Rob Green......absolutely nothing to do....saved brilliantly in 90th minute No change my ratings////10 out of 10 for everyone....but Adel gets 11
I didnt think he was very good and we would have been improved by having Hoilett play there instead, same goes for Green, his kicking was terrible and wed have been better off with Cesar but its just picking holes in Redknapps selection. He did the most important thing which was play an AM in the hole and not 3 of Granero/Mbia/Faurlin/Derry/Diakite.
Have you seen our points ratio with SWP in the team and him out of the team? The difference is massive.
He's been sh.it for half of season now. And one good performance wont make him world class in my eyes. If he can keep up this way then I'll have no problems admitting I was wrong.
Hes had 3 or 4 out of 10 performances this season and one 6/10 performance today doesnt mean I want to see any more of him. What did he do today? Did he create anything, did he have any chances or doing someone notable? Id love to know because I didnt see anything.
Only watching it on stream (but a good fluent one) SWP was okay. Sure he didn't do a great deal but occupy a wing spot - but when he got possession he released a lot more simple ball, rather than engage in those endless aimless runs of his into cul de sacs. 'Arry's obviously 'ad a word.
Can't see why anyone would ask for SWP to be dropped on that performance. I know he ain't been very good for the last couple of seasons but under HR seems to be improving game by game and personally I think he had a very good game today and gave his all for the team. Any of the SWP knockers tell me why he should be dropped ?? (Seriously just curious and not knocking anyone's opinions)
Hoilett is better, you say he is getting better but he is still poor, hes gone from abysmal to poor while Hoilett has ranged from poor to good. But still nowhere near as good as Hoilett.
I can't say Hoilett has been setting the world on fire TBH....It's all about opinions and it seems HR sees more in SWP than a lot on here do. And I think it's unfair to say SWP was 'poor' today......but your entitled to your opinion mate.
He is an attacking winger, tell me what he did attacking wise? He didnt have a good game just because he wasnt comical like he was earlier in the season. Hughes saw a lot in him too and we only started winning last season when he was finally dropped. Hes given another chance this season and we start losing again.
As I said Flyer, it's your opinion and whatever I say ain't gonna change it....like you ain't gonna change mine. I think he played better than he has in ages, ran his heart out, and had a good game. Thanks for answering my question anyway, most appreciated (**** that sounds sarcastic but truly isn't meant to....honest )
Flyer your love takes me higher with desire ..i'm on fire but christ mate you talk worse **** than me... respect your opinion but its wrong have faith in SWP he is a very good player and cut him some slack let him play with a bit of confidence then you may have to rethink it Harold will play him because he knows this as well. SWP will be one of the first names of the sheet mate move on
I agree with you that hes played better than recently but thats only because hes been embarrassing for most of the season. Ill agree with you that hes a headless chicken but he doesnt score and doesnt create chances and that is what an attacking player should do.
Would you count Jamie Mackie in the 'Headless Chicken' camp and drop him as well ?? He missed a howler today but he would still be one of the first on my team sheet for effort alone
Mackie got about 8 goals last season. At least he gets in the position, SWP doesnt even get the chances so he will never score or miss them. Call me stupid but Id rather a player get a lot of chances and misses some than one who doesnt get chances at all.
SWP was one of the players who played with heart and passion today. When he had the ball he swept forward, he even won a header at the back post. But must say he was hindered by a lot of Rob Green's clearances coming to him , but when he got a ball on the floor he took players on and went past them, he tackled back and harassed,.....all round good performanve. Did you see the way Taarbs congratulated him when he went off...Taarbs appreciated his effort. It was a very good TEAM performance
Last season counts for **** all I'm afraid mate. It's all about now. And I definately wouldn't call you stupid mate and as always I respect your opinion even though I don't particularly agree with it.
