Off Topic Mafia Game 14th November Mafia V vamps

Just looked at the order and the arsonist action isn't listed in the order of things?? do we know when he acts?

 

No one has come forward to counter claim so opinion seems to be moving towards leaving him alone for now.

 

Danilo

 

I killed him yesterday

Zingy

 

From what I can gather, only the doused can tell us. Why would the doused keep it a secret? Has no one been doused due to inactivity? If so, is there someone fairly inactive that we've missed?

Also, @astro @Tobes you both voted for me. Interesting that you two seem to be working together. I'd have suspected you as Mafia if I didn't know Astro was the Vet. What's your reasonings?

 

Oh dear

 

Or maybe he was locked up?

Bu fat Obi never left a will the lazy ****

 

I've written mine already, so I suggest all town players do

 

Working together? He voted for me day 1, and I was in the tie, some mafia buddy

You voted for me yesterday for no reason whatsoever, and are one of my 6 possibles.

 

work beckons. will catch you later guys.

 

For what it's worth I have a gut feel (nothing more) that Tennis is a goody and is on our side.

 

In that case......




Tennis

 

At least the vampire can't bite tonight

Hey vampire

**** you

Suck my dick

 

It's waaay past your bedtime now.

 

Vote withdrawn from Tobes.

I'm no longer voting for anyone without true belief that they are suspect.

 

The rules are pretty clear and have been discussed by others.

The role in question wins with thatever other people also wins.

I.e. town or mafia or vamps can all win even if the role in question achieves their objective.

 

OK. I withdraw my Zingy vote

 

Ok, so first thing I've noticed upon catching up is that people are making some daft assumptions.

1) if musty is the executioner and needed to get Beardsley lynched then he has already achieved his objective and will be on the winning team regardless of living or not. The executioner gets a target he must get Lynched, Beardsley got lynched. He only has to get himself lynched if he fails to get his target lynched. So if he is genuinely the executioner and needs to get himself lynched then Beardsley wasn't his target. He has claimed that Beardsley was his target and has claimed he needs to get himself lynched. So he is lying one way or the other. It would have been easier to get himself lynched by acting suspicious rather than saying he is the executioner, it makes literally no sense. Why the **** is everyone just accepting this all without questioning any of the glaring holes in the story? Isn't it just as likely he is Mafia bluffing, or that he is the arsonist and trying to use the executioner role as a way of surviving as he knows the actual executioner won't counter claim as the executioner could well still be trying to achieve there ain't? Also it's clear from the rules that the executioner managing to win makes no difference to whether we get to win so why are we all worried about him ending up dead? Are any of you actually reading the rules?

2) assumptions are being made that anyone who voted for people who we now know to be Mafia can't be Mafia themselves. Again, this is rubbish, Mafia constantly vote for themselves, particularly early on, as a way of distancing themselves. If they end up in a position where changing that vote would look suspicious they'd rather take there chances in a tied vote, particularly when there are 5 or 6 people in the coin flip. Huge bit of flawed logic being thrown around there.

3) why are some people still suggesting the Mafia may have recruited? They've acted each night so we know they haven't recruited. Again, either people aren't reading the rules (or haven't played before) or are being will fully ignorant to try and create uncertainty.

4) why are we ignoring the actual information we have and randomly throwing votes around? Anyone who has been reading the thread should have picked up that ME had a town role, yet two people voted for him and almost had him in the tied lynch vote. We also had a late vote that minimised the chances of two people being lynched.

We are at the stage where people need to be coming up with theories and actually looking back at the information we have!!!

 

Read my earlier post, it lists the remaining roles.

There are 5 VT's left, 2 Mafia, 1 Vamp, 2 neutrals. And this mystery role MITO just introduced, we don't know who has that.

 

Yes, he doused someone first night, but we haven't heard anyone claim they were doused last night though.

Yes, it will be one of the guys who did the Valley thing. I was one of them, there were at least 4 others as far as I can remember. Afc was one of them too