well thats highly interesting. Lets read that back. 1. mafia killed valley. claim is dpp visited 2. mafia killed Beardsley. clain is dpp did it 3. claim DPP also visited more hope. what roles would a) allow musty to see all this b) what mafia role could dpp be to visit two guys at night... answers: a) parts 2 and 3 suggests musty followed DPP the second night... and valley the first? B) mafia get to kill and godfather picks who, mafia also have some roles. "Consort - same as the Town Escort, can block someone's role each night. Consigliere - same as the Town Investigator, can find out someone's role each night. Framer -can frame one player per night and that person will appear as Mafia to anyone investigating." So as ACS says he investigated night 1 on Nev then his investigation result still stands here. DPP could be a consort, consiwahzzit or framer. Have not seen a huge gaping orifice in the claims there. DPP is mafia is the claim. (but not the godfather by the look of it)
Well **** me Lots to counter it seems, or at least clarify. Luckily for me I dropped a clue early in the thread as to who I was. I need to check back on the roles though to clarify something. However, at this stage I can confirm that ACS's investigation is correct. However, I am confused as to how he has worded it as it doesn't fit with my understanding of the roles and rules. I can also conform that somebody else is not being 100% honest based on what has been said about last night. Need to work out if that is for a good or bad reason though. However, I can confirm that I am the town ESCORT (not town consort as MITO suggested).
Right I am revealing because believe I 100% know who someone is. I had guessed this on night one and went ahead with my theory. I am the VIGILANTE. I attempted to kill PENFOLD last night. I was roleblocked from doing so. The Consort could have blocked me but to do so would have had to know I was the vigilante. Therefore I believe the roleblock came in the form of the godfather being unable to die at night. So I propose we lynch PENFOLD and see which rats come out to defend him. I can say with a fair degree of certainty DPP is also mafia. I thought Nev was the final part of that team, but I couldn't say for certain. I suspected others also. Of course I can also kill tonight...so further info will be helpful.
I would agree that DPP looks like being Mafia however I will need to check the roles as to why Jurgen also visited Valley on the first night
I can conform that Get Ritchie was blocked from acting last night - by me!!! I blocked him on the first night. As we only had one death on the first night, I decided to block him again to see if we only had one death again - which we did. My thinking behind this was that he could have been an arsonist (which is why I asked people to come forward if they had been doused). On the first night I got no reply to my actions from Roalnd. Last night I got a message that said I had successfully blocked an action. This leads me to believe that Get Ritchie is telling the truth and is the Vigilante, as the Vigilante cannot act on night one.
This was me dropping the clue that I am the Escort - along the lines of "I can be whatever you want me to be" I would not have revealed a clue if I was the mafia consort.
The wording of the roles that confused me is that it says the investigator can FULLY investigate someone. This doesn't fit with getting a partial result, as Albert seems to have done. However, the same description is given of the mafia investigator. No neutral character has an investigative role. This leads me to think that this is just a quirk of the game.
I dropped in the mixed up roles to see if you'd bite on it nev. So right now: basically... Godfather Mafia2 Mafia 3 ARSONIST Nuetral 2 Medium MITO (claim) Sherrif Valley (claim) Doctor Tash known BODYGUARD Beardsley known Look out Musty (claimed and i am putting name on it) investigator ACS (claimed) vigilante Get ritchie (claimed) escort Neville (claimed) vetern (nobody has claimed this) so if we are all to be believed 1. godfather = penfold 2. Mafia 1 = DPP 3. Mafia 2.. 4. arsonist 5. Other neutrals for those 3 bad guy roles and one good guy role we have IBWT, Jurgen, mikey, chaos ........................................ speculation: jurgen visited: is he the arsonist? I was visited night two
its not a nice fit is it? Are you claiming you sucked off someone night one and this is what may have confused poor ACS
I said last night that I thought DPP (yes that's a vote) ****ed up by taking somebody out of the tie and was then told immediately to change it as it looked too obvious - which is why he immediately edited his post. I thought this pointed to Albert as Penfold highlighted my post. However, I now believe that ACS is an investigator (though don't know if this is town or mafia - but would be risky to reveal if not town as it could easily be countered).
I'll try and find the post. It basically was a vote for Tash that put Tash clear for lynching. It was immediately changed to "Blue something"
This was the post at 8.58pm. It doesn't show up as edited due to being edited immediately. (I can see the edit history as a toon mod). Albert will also be able to see this. Will be interesting to see if he supports me.
I see it. As a non mod her ei can't see the edit. it says blue paint and you right after interesting at 9:01 theres penfold saying night? PENFOLD there are a number of reason why he might have not dies i na kill but he could be godfather. If we as town decied on one or other to kill I will do with it (DPP does have far more evidence) we need more than 3 votes to secure this!
Penfold, DPP IBWT, Jurgen, mikey, chaos 6 for 5 bad guys. chaos never gave role he kept claiming was not important and wanted to be lynched. (when i asked him before he went to bed) Lets see lads... who swings, and who dies... one of these is a veteran hoping to be visited.. rest are stone cold evil.
