I know you are not the Joker Chaos, Jester though hmmmmmmmmmmm. Chaos not getting my vote. who is No Chance?
Here's my theory on the used roles in this game The Good - There are 9 good players (sorry, there were 9 good players) so I think every role is being used The Mafia - There are 3 mafia. One is going to be the Godfather. Another has to be Mafioso so that if the GF dies there is someone to their place. It could be that the 3rd is also Mafioso but if not then I think they'll be either Consort or Consigliere . I don't think there are enough people for Framer to be a useful role. The Neutral - Not enough players for Arsonist, Executioner and Jester to be viable roles. As there was only one killing last night (by mafia) I don't think there is a serial killer either. My bet is that there is 1 Vampire and 1 Werewolf. Of course could be completely wrong though. Anyone else got any thoughts on this?
if there is an Escort (which there is) I think there will also be a Consort to provide balance therefore Godfather, Mafia and Consort. There is no Arsonist or Serial Killer I would agree. However having said that, have no idea.
Sorry, my name for More Hope. He has died first day last 3 games and Valley was winding him up about it before this game. I don't think he will have killed Valley as he's a good player and that would/should be too obvious a move and hence why I haven't voted for him. Chippy on the other hand is just the sort of player who would kill Valley first day to try and frame No Chance.
Of course to the Mafia, Valley could have been neutral. There would have been no time on day 1 for them to know for sure. Of course neutral was less likely and I get your point.
Morning all. So interesting things going on. 1. The people in game are now: IBWT Get Ritchie DPP Valley - town sheriff -DEAD ACS Mustyfrog Penfold MITO Mikey MoreHope Tash Chaos Beardsley Jurgen so 13 left, 5 bad guys. judging by that there is a fair chance of hitting a bad guy just going random on voting. I know i'm a good guy so I've a 5/12 change of picking one out. 2. Beardsley's theory on all 9 good guy roles being active. I don't know about that. iT would make the bad guy's have a can't lose by killing thing. 3. Roles: only the mafia killed. Can we conclude anything about the other other roles from this? I saw a comment saying no serial killer? and another saying chaos must be jester trying to get lynched. I suppose anything is possible but we could also have seen someone just not send in an action last night... vampire? could there be a vampire in the game. would we have heard of a bite? probably low risk of this werewolf. Rolando called this a werewolf game at the outset of sign up. there was no full moon or was there? I don't know. Arsonist... this could be possible? would we know someone is doused.. would they know? jester... certainly possible. Executioner. possible also. he wants someone lynched. is anyone pushing for someone? witch also possible serial killer. probably lower risk unless someone forgot to put in action 2 of these exist.
No, bad choice of words by me perhaps. Framer, I think, just makes someone look Mafia if investigated. Chippy could be Mafia and would get Mafia to do that. Could be Don or Mafiosa or Framer or whichever one of their 3 roles exist.
If anyone needs clarification of the rules, let me know or send me a PM. I've updated the front page just to help.
Strange comment when no-one knows who anyone is...unless they are Mafia. So why would the Mafia know you are the one to hit?
It's hard to tell how much of this would be based on previous games as there is a big changeover in the players playing. It could be down to previous games, Valley being the loudest so far, Valley being non-toon or done to try and frame someone - or even as a double bluff on that score. We have virtually nothing to go on at this stage.
They have an Investigator type... As do we. I'm a high profile investigation for Mafia so I may not last long. All I will say is sometimes your regular choice is the correct one in these games..............
