Remaining Players: Afcftw - innocent ACS - my current vote, feel he has had several moments which could be construed as scum actions as listed in my post above. Bobby - still undecided, hasn't been involved enough yet to get a proper read, but leaning towards innocent based on the content/tone of his limited posts Bodanki - Mason (albeit a terrible one) Chaos - Mason (but a massive wind up) Danilo - no idea, hasn't been involved much, could be a wrong-un but hasn't posted enough for me to have any idea Lucaaas - started off with no idea but the way he has posted over the last day has come across as innocent to me RHC - think he has a role, possibly a SK, has seemed more interested than usual despite his votes seeming his usual clueless self which originally made me think he was town, could go either way with him Rolando - had a town read and feel I have followed his breadcrumbs, was very much thinking innocent and specifically thought I'd worked him out but his questioning of the masons, whilst they are clearly ******s has confused me as to whether he is who I thought he was Sir Tennis - him and Mito have been my strongest town reads, constructive, constantly involved, figured out the direction thing which has guaranteed us the good outcome each day, and seems to have shared my frustration in Bodanki and chaos and for that alone I think he is town Style - still have a niggling feeling he is the other SK based on his activity but it's difficult to tell, undecided, leaning towards scum Suckmy - seems to not really know what is going on, he is another one who hasn't been involved enough or when he has hasn't had anything to add to the conversation. Undecided, could be a wrong-un, like with Danilo I don't know how we would be able to tell one way or the other based on the lack of activity. Too many people still not contributing enough - would be good if everyone did a list like this for the remaining players. Might give us a smaller pool of suspects to interrogate, or at least some kind of collective town direction. The Mafia have enough votes between them to swing the vote if we don't have at least some kind of consensus on who we lynch. We still have the numbers over them...just.
Right lads... at best I've skim read.... I've been in meetings all day so only just out and I never gogt the chance to trawl back. I'm getting in my car in Cheltenham and driving to Consett now. This **** is a 4.5 hour drive. If you wanna photo of Tibshelf services part way home then so be it..lol In short I won't be on now until about 10-11pm unless I stop on the way.. It's very interesting who has come out of the woodwork since I started talking about the quiet ones. And interesting who is trying to lead the spotlight elsewhere. I'm VT end of. Chaos- I'm going for Bobby D on the vote bro as he came out of the woodwork right on cue like any mafia would when there's a threat. He's nailed on Mafioso. I have a horrible feeling that I'm getting lynched today and the Mafia will have pretty much won if that is the case (9pm will of course prove this). Hope the vigilante (who I think I know the ID of) is looking very closely at the quiet chaps here. See you later chaps. Mito- My Eulogy is.... 'told you boys.... you should listen to uncle ACS.... now look at the whisperers in the shadows - god speed and viva la Town!'
Further to this, for the reasons given, if I had to narrow it down to a handful of people to be searching for scum amongst I'd look at: ACS (my number 1 suspicion currently), Danilo, RHC, Style and Suckmy If people can't be bothered to write a full list then at least put your handful of people to narrow it down to... Anyone?
Afcftw - unsure - why is Chaos after you so much, surely Bod would mitigate his craziness?! ACS - slightly unsure - seems helpful enough, but he's a helluva liar from a couple of previous games; the eulogy is a bit too "ooh, I'm deffo innocent" Bobby - seems uninvolved but I feel from the other game that there was a clear ploy to be more quiet. Based on nothing more than gut feel could actually be SK instead of Mafia Bodanki - Still allegedly a mason, but..... Chaos - nothing more to add Danilo - had a few moments where he vaguely but directly pointed a finger at both Chaos and myself - Mafia read Lucaaas - seems innocent, however has come on more towards the latter stages - maybe a novice on the Mafia team, has kept out of it; when I got a mafia role in the LOTR game I didn't know much how to do it and avoided suspicion for a little while; he reminds me of me. Possible Mafia. RHC - Almost certainly SK. Rolando - Town and I think you're smart enough to work that out, AFC. Sir Tennis - If he's not town I'm never playing again. Style - Agree on the SK2 theory here - followed a pattern that matched the SK kills. Suckmy - I think just VT - seems to be unconcerned and dips in and out infrequently. The lack of contribution and the perceived silent game plan has killed townies - public votes are essential when mafia play silently. That is all.
Let's not castigate him for being inactive, there's probably a good reason for his inactivity that he just hasn't told us yet. AFC - do you want to try Danilo? Oh, and I'm out from 7ish with work and won't be back til the morning. At which point I'll have died, which is unfortunate.
Afcftw - innocent, unless he's faked his oscar worthy meltdown to hide amongst the mafia shadows ACS - If he's not guilty then i shouldn't be playing mafia with these skills Bobby - Innocent of course Bodanki - Mason but doing it the Jose way winding everyone up and scoring a massive OG Chaos - Mason , he's actually upped his chaos levels this game, is that cause hes onto the 4th day? Danilo - no idea, from his limited posts a townie Lucaaas - started off with no idea but i've too many townies in my list so i'm going SK RHC - No idea, probably townie Rolando - Posted a few times which i've skimmed as too many posts to cover. Someone mentioned he thought the park might be a good idea and he is questions the masons. I reckon he's a bad-un Sir Tennis - Helping the town a lot and also had a meltdown. I actually think Tennis could be a sneaky SK Style - No idea but i will put him down as the 3rd scummer Suckmy - First time player, no idea, townie
I didn't ever say park as a good idea. I said that the bar in DC universe is almost always owned by criminal underworld. That was it. Logic since dictates home was a good idea, but we don't know for certain, so why would you specifically mention park unless you knew - as mafia - that park was a BAD choice?
Because ACS is the most dangerous criminal known to man. Anyone who sees ACS and his Chinos are automatically under ACS's hypnosis so we must take him out at the earliest opportunity
I'd go with Danilo if that's what town is going with (he's on my list of targets after all!), we need to be going for the same person rather than splitting our vote too much or the Mafia will just choose who to kill each night. We need to be working together at this point or we will end up losing.
oh i thought i read someone (i read the theory but can't remember who posted and i thought i read someone say it was you) said you mentioned that going to the park could give you superpowers
My current vote is Danilo. I am VERY concerned by Bobby's comments regarding the park and the attempt to point a finger at me, though.
