Off Topic Official DC Mafia Game

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
on the destination and vanillas.

Astro posted something quite useful, actually several useful things last night.


there are 5 vanillas left.

there are several claimants but only 6 left alive on his list

Style
Bobby
RHC
Tennis
ACS
MITO

Penfold
Chaos
Tobes
all dead on astro's vanilla list

So clearly theres one guy in here in the list who's not kosher if not more.

there no point ignoring the list as its out there o the thread. Mafia will be using it so us town need to be looking at it too. If for example one is mafia? well that narrows the list doesn't it!

Again great help this was... to everyone good or bad.

Masons are out... 10 town left, its not to hard unless more than one bad guy hiding in this list for bad guys to pick off non claimants is it..

next the vote pattern option:

Astro finihsed up with

All vanillas and only vanillas on ACS
Masons on Chaos
Vigilante on Valley
Journo on Lucaaaas

Do we want to continue this option?

If so what do we go for? Anyone want to volunteer who 5 people vote for and get lynched? I have made my vote clear so far.

Masons have revealed and not so far challenged
 
Red Hadron Collider said:
I'm defo vanilla. Out of the rest of that list, I haven't a scoob who the baddie is. Poss ACS or Bobby?
Click to expand...

Hmm, the timing of this post and the double attempt to sway people towards ACS makes me think that perhaps you and MITO are in collaboration? I'm not sure ACS is a bad guy, certainly he's not SK because he would have killed twice.

I'm still most sorely tempted by a vote for DPP but this has altered my thinking a touch. I mean, DPP seems like a logical choice as SK, but if he's inactive I'd rather take out mafia than a sleeping SK!!
 
I have a bad feeling about afc

He's gone very quiet and he was determined to see me a known town swing yesterday

 
Captainchaos. said:
I have a bad feeling about afc

He's gone very quiet and he was determined to see me a known town swing yesterday
Click to expand...

But was he still after you post-mason-reveal? I don't think he was. I think we should take a look at RHC - if he is Mafia, we can be fairly confident MITO is as well, so we get a two-for-one!

I'm certain DPP is Captain Cold (SK) and that we have a couple of suspects for the other SK role as per MITO's posts. Now, if RHC is innocent we can carry on letting MITO write his essays, but I have a feeling one of the VERY vocal players is Mafia.
 
ive been trying to keep up with this thread and game in general, i did post yesterday who i was voting for if you missed it it was dpp, cos the name reminded me of a song and i saw everyone else was voting for him too.

im just kinda trying to work out how you investigate or work out whos who, (astro and mito have helped with their posts a bit) but im basically playing blind here.
 
Just to throw another curveball, why did CaptainChaos post TWICE intimating he was the serial killer?

Posts [HASHTAG]#883[/HASHTAG] and [HASHTAG]#899[/HASHTAG]. Page 45.
 
Rolando said:
But was he still after you post-mason-reveal? I don't think he was. I think we should take a look at RHC - if he is Mafia, we can be fairly confident MITO is as well, so we get a two-for-one!

I'm certain DPP is Captain Cold (SK) and that we have a couple of suspects for the other SK role as per MITO's posts. Now, if RHC is innocent we can carry on letting MITO write his essays, but I have a feeling one of the VERY vocal players is Mafia.
Click to expand...

You don't know me well enough <laugh> I'm incapable of keeping a role like mafia under wraps <laugh> I'd have given myself away ages ago <ok>
 
moreinjuredthanowen said:
ok guys here is what i noted for an hours bullshit

1. 4 people only gave vote after 9pm. ACS, Danilo, Bobby, Rolando just now


2. my attempt at table:

Chaos: 3 votes: AFC, Lucaaas, Danilo
DPP: 3 votes: Tennis, Astro, rolando
Astro: 3 votes: Chaos, Valley, Bod
ACS 2 votes: MITO, bobby
Bobby 1 vote: ACS

3. no info: ? votes: 6. DPP, Style, mikey, RHC, penfold, suck myklopp

So there are 4 guys to question

Style
Mikey
RHC
Suckmy klopp

you did not say who you voted for yesterday

3. TODAY's Votes:

ACS 1 vote: Bobby
DPP: 4 votes: Tennis, mito, suckymy, AFC
Danilo 1 vote: Chaos
AFC: 1 vote by: Bod


4 I also noted that penfold might have been hot to follow astros plan yesterday, that he was sure astro was innocent and put a big bold headline so i think he might have been picked by someone... unfortunately that someone was mafia who killed him (zoom result)
Click to expand...
RHC said he went for Astro (can't remember if before or after the vote)
Sucky said he went for DPP yesterday before vote.
Mikey and Style are the only blanks now imo.
 
Rolando said:
Tennis has voted DPP two nights running. I voted nobody night one, DPP last night so that took the count for DPP to at least three. Seemed to me that more than three were agreeing to vote for him, so what changed? I need to find out who intimated they would go DPP and then who changed their minds, and why. Even then, do we really know DPP is guilty? I think we do because one SK has made NO kills, so surely is assigned to an inactive player? Question - who else is inactive, can we get a shortlist??

For the first night there's not a lot to be read from the votes for Tobes, as Astro - known town - was one of those who voted for him.
Click to expand...
Only DPP has not been active at all.
Some guys were inactive for one day (yesterday)...
 
My count of votes for Day 2:

AFC (Voted for: Chaos)
ACS (Voted for: BobbyD)
BobbyD (Voted for: ACS)
Bodanki (Voted for: Astro)
Chaos (Voted for: Astro)
Danilo (Voted for: Chaos)
DPP (Voted for: ? Not Astro)
Lucaaas (Voted for: Chaos)
Mikey (Voted for: ?)
MITO (Voted for: ACS)
RHC (Voted for: Astro)
Rolando (Voted for: DPP)
Sir Tennis (Voted for: DPP)
Style (Voted for: ?)
Suckmyklopp (Voted for: DPP)
Valley (Voted for: Astro)
Penfold (Voted for: ? Not Astro)
Astro (Voted for: ? Not Astro)
 
Rolando said:
Hmm, the timing of this post and the double attempt to sway people towards ACS makes me think that perhaps you and MITO are in collaboration? I'm not sure ACS is a bad guy, certainly he's not SK because he would have killed twice.

I'm still most sorely tempted by a vote for DPP but this has altered my thinking a touch. I mean, DPP seems like a logical choice as SK, but if he's inactive I'd rather take out mafia than a sleeping SK!!
Click to expand...

got anyone to suggest?

The logic for me i have no idea who is mafia out of a list of 11 (as i know i'm town, assumes masons truth and dpp sk) so..... 4 bad out of 11 odds v on balance DPP is likely to be bad is a btter lynch than further damaging town

The problem is theres no more investigations so we've no way to find mafia.

the one hope i have as town is we are 10 v 5. mafia only have 2 kills and recruit left so... well if we could get both SKs over next two lynches then it would be at worst 4 mafia v 6 (one mafia kill, one recruit, 2 sk kills by deathstroke, 2 town lynches on SK)

thats bad but the 6 town should be able to have some idea. if we'd luck maybe more failures would occur.... maybe they will hit same target.

the game will be over for town if we lynch more town.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sir Tennisball
Sir Tennisball said:
My count of votes for Day 2:

AFC (Voted for: Chaos)
ACS (Voted for: BobbyD)
BobbyD (Voted for: ACS)
Bodanki (Voted for: Astro)
Chaos (Voted for: Astro)
Danilo (Voted for: Chaos)
DPP (Voted for: ? Not Astro)
Lucaaas (Voted for: Chaos)
Mikey (Voted for: ?)
MITO (Voted for: ACS)
RHC (Voted for: Astro)
Rolando (Voted for: DPP)
Sir Tennis (Voted for: DPP)
Style (Voted for: ?)
Suckmyklopp (Voted for: DPP)
Valley (Voted for: Astro)
Penfold (Voted for: ? Not Astro)
Astro (Voted for: ? Not Astro)
Click to expand...

see my table.

when did RHC say astro vote?
have i missed it this morning i've just asked him.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom
Back