bobby was brave earlier. we could run a voting table publicly and then all could change their minds in private but it might stimulate debate.
Yeah tbh I expect most of the active people will be dead by the end of day 2 But it'd be nice if those with kills didn't go down the "kill the active/helpful townies" route and spice things up by killing off some different people! It makes it far more interesting if the games end up with different groups of people when it comes to end game rather than the usual ones who survive and usual ones who die.
The way i see this is that mafia are as in the dark as the town in some ways. They cannot know if one of them is going to be lynched. therefore I think they will be worried about the mayor seeing them line up on someone but also worried about dying. therefore they'd love for us to pile all one one guy so they could hide from mayor and top someone else In short mafia won't care who gets lynched as long as its not one of them. so how do we make it work in town's favour? Can we force a vote where they must to line up day 1? hard to do i think.
BobbyD quickly suggested a possible option choice without much reason as to why and then the ****er accused me of being too quiet before I'd had a chance to make a single post! And he accused me of the same thing in the last game at a similar time of day while I was at work, you'd think he would learn! Last time I went for him and this time he is my target number one as well Though I may go for an inactive instead.
Not without knowing who one of them is or by chance choosing one who is and all going for that person. Might be an idea to go for a few targets and try to sort a split vote? Hope to figure something out from that? Or we can all just randomly vote and hope they don't pile on someone.
well they are bad guys so bad guys will kill good guys. All i'd like is the vigilante doesn't pull a tobes and shoots me cos frankly thats what tobes did last time but we had protection As there is none in this game I'm saying at least the investigators know who's likely to get hit. plus they all assume i'm helpful and know stuff but the reality is (whispers) I might be total **** at this game. I might be as bad as tennis was as cop... however... its not about surviving til end its about helping town win. So...i'm ready to go. it'll be one less person for mafia to hide as.
Yeah, but we don't know ho's already voted and for whom. I'm off here at 5 pm and there's unlikely yo be anything formative happening before then, so I'm just going to have to take pot luck.
Tbh if vigilante is going to kill early with no idea of who to kill (which lots of people seem to do when they are vigilante as they are scared they won't get a chance to kill, even though I think this is **** vigilante play), I'd advise said Vigilante goes for one of the inactive people to at least not cause the town to lose the discussion which helps flush people out. And also as we inevitably hit a point in every game where we don't know what to do with the inactive people and end up going for them on day 3/4, we can hurry that process along by getting rid of them early. I do think the bad guys will probably still kill the normal helpful/active townies though. But whoever you are, despite this probably being the easiest route to winning (and I know several people get quite competitive and really want to win) it is fun if the game goes a different route to normal so maybe be kind and kill off the inactive people
