Off Topic Mafia game: The island

TBH, I actually had you written down as first choice recruit

I had no involvement in the first or second nights death.

 

Not sure how fake it was though

 

I saw that on the dead board. Some good calls in there

 

Yeah we had a great exchange and after that no-one was thinking me and chaos were together lol

 

Reason I went to kill you first was because last time was on a team worked well and as dead had a chance of winning wanted you on my team... plus you complimented me so thought id return the favour

 

I saw that. Good call on me but for the wrong reasons. I genuinely was busy

 

It wasn't 100% fake

But yes, that was brilliant for me and Astro to hide in.

 

On the dead thing.

I felt after milks game which was last is played the dead didn't get a fair crack at it.

They were seeing the full story in vision and how the deaths were laid out and the scene dressing by guards

In milks he said the dead never really had a hope and I just felt I wanted there to be some way to stay in game properly.

If the living made it to sea the idea was no 19 would be a part of choice and the poor idiot could be used to drown the town on their raft.

If te town as living chose right in a 50/50 then they could win but chose wrong and then the dead vote could win.

I felt milks game only needed medium say hey don't kill me guys and the dead had no chance after 5 days.

I added the avenging angel role in to counter warden power.

It was warden v serial killer v dead with a blundering town hoping to get out.

If Bobby lived he was meant to get a gun if he chose right and have nev with his protection and +1 shard protection to be powerful town


None of those happened and a **** load of town just died.

 

If you read our board you'll see at times chaos wondered if it was fake or if I was being a dick to him lol, was genuinely for show and nothing personal from me

Though I do admit I sort of tried to get him lynched on the first day

 

I think in a normal mafia game your tactics would have been picked up more.. but because there were so many people trying to work out other things they ignored usual rules..

If someone is accusing others and putting big theories out there and then suddenly get killed... you'd normally look right at the people they were acusing. However town seemed to get distracted with so many other things just ignored that.

 

You've got 'Mafia team' competition now, AFC and I have won two (AFC's first was a honorary victory, we couldn't both win as surfers)

 

Me and Tobes can match that as a team - though only when we're bad guys

 

Go on then, what was my tell tale sign?

 

This is the thing (and maybe because I wasn't really paying attention after I died) I still don't know who was on what team?! I thought Astro/AFC/Chaos were one team... you were on their team as well then?

This is nothing personal against MITO (and certainly not because I died first because sometimes dying early and then seeing who everyone is is very fun!) but didn't enjoy this one as much.

Prefer the old school "standard" mafia games where we know what roles to look for etc... problem I find with the hidden game is you have no idea what you're looking for. You can't link peoples posts and actions to a role in a hidden game as you have no idea what kind of roles there are

But like I say, personal preference that's all.

 

Ignoring town teams, I've not been on Tobes team yet.

I was surprised no one picked up on me and Tobes not arguing this time. It's almost tradition

Same for me with Astro and AFC, we always argue

 

And that's why I think it was hard for town, beucase not only did they need to work out who the bad guys were, not knowing what they were looking for, they also had to work out where to go etc as well... plus had the dead board killing random people just for fun from night 2 onwards...

 

I was the warden and Astro, Chaos and AFC were my guards. I recruited Nev to win the game Potentially five (and was in the end) in a eighteen player game (27.7%) is quite high.

I think you didn't prefer it because you died early. I've felt exactly the same when I've gone out early

 

Not at all... doesn't bother me too much as like I say, sometimes it's just as fun knowing who is what and watching it with that knowledge (much like how I enjoyed running a couple of games which is just like dying early).

I didn't enjoy Milk's one as much either... just prefer games where you know what you're looking for and aren't too complicated. I think sometimes making it too complicated makes it much harder for the town as the bad guys at least know half the roles.

 

I know I've said it a few times now but I may host the next one. It wouldn't be a massively complicated game if I did it #lazyfatbaldbatard

Nightfall would be earlier (6pm) or later (10pm) though

 

6pm too early.. still getting home from work at that point!