Off Topic Mafia game: The island

Highlight of the game and i'm sure Nev agrees was the fantastic cryptic questions and secret investigations that we had to do which MITO made up

 

Lol you mean Chaos and Biscan . I couldnt have cared less

 

Yep, I thought that was brilliant.

Tennis posted a list too. He had you as innocent (more or less), me in neutral and Astro as dodgy. I was happy with that but that meant Astro was the one I wanted to go out of you two.

I didn't bother telling you guys that if I was targeted at night one of you would die. I didn't think you guys trusted the warden so figured if I told you that and you had an idea of who I was you'd try and lynch me

 

@moreinjuredthanowen

Did anyone try to investigate me?

 

Personally, I think my role was too powerful. I had three guards plus a fourth (recruit) that had to die before I did andI appeared as town for investigations. Plus I could feed info via the game host (only did it once though).

I think Chaos and Astro both died when someone was attacking me?

Had I not won it that situation it would have been a Valley type failure!

 

Yeah you were better not making us more suspicious lol

I could feel the tide may turn against Astro, I'd already happily thrown chaos to the wolves so I was ready to do the same to Astro if it meant staying as what felt like a known innocent lol so had we had some suspicion on you I can't guarantee I wouldn't have gone for you too

 

I was happy to throw all three of you tbh. I'd already had a pop and both you and Astro on day two, plus I voted for you both (although I retracted yours quickly because of the ACS and RHC link). I was setting some ground work for if I needed it

 

Saw your comments on the warden thread discussing which of us was best to discard at different times lol

I don't think a single person made a single connection between any of the four of us though did they? Think we did a great job of all seeming separate.

 

Surely the highlight was Nev revealing he stayed up all night to watch a film to look for clues

 

I know MITO was very busy with other people, not to mention work and family, but when I was posting stuff for the guards and having to wait, not only for him to post it there but also for the guards to respond and then MITO to do the transferring again, it was very bloody frustrating!

I'd have preferred to be given access to the board with my PM explaining the importance of keeping my identity private. I could have just posted as THE WARDEN

 

Nope. The only people I got linked to was ACS and RHC for my silly vote on you. However, I think you were the main one to pick up on it.

Can't believe how silly that was. Really should have looked at the voting table first

That was the only day I didn't vote for the direction we needed too

 

Games over and im still not entirely sure who or how this was won?


But I will say, I called Astro & AFC as bad guys form day 1 and none of your ****ers listened to me... AFC, Astro & Chaos knew I had it worked out so killed me day 1

 

Maybe but you still tried to kill me immediately





















...and failed





























...and cried on the dead board

 

MITO - not a complaint on your behalf as you obviously put so much effort in it was ridiuculous, and maybe because I died day 1 and didn't really get involved much after that, but I felt it was maybe a bit too complicated.

The fact that even after all that still not entirely sure how people won or what roles were and what they did etc... might just be me though

 

And just my opinion, don't think the dead should have a part to play afterwards. I know it sucks when your killed off early and can't take part but sometimes defeats the point if you do all the hard work killing off people and then they can influence the game still... I don't think we (the dead) took it that seriously in the choices we had to make etc

 

It's just you, I know exactly how the game was won

 

I do agree with this and I said it when Swarbs (?) did it before. It is **** if you're dead but that's part of the game.

 

Wow, Holy ****!

Time to spark up and see if I can work out what the hell happened via ...osmosis

read all the posts ..still dont know what was happenening

very cool game

(dammit I knew I should have taken out astro earlier)

 

My first comment on dead board....

"Haven't kept up with thread a lot today, but seems like Astro has got them all following him as to where to go, what to do etc..

Wouldn't surprise me if he's bad guy and leading everyone in the wrong direction "

 

Chaos was pissed off as it killed him... I mentioned it a couple times as thought mito had missed it