Off Topic Mafia game: The island

As far as the lynch goes then RHC does seem like a sensible choice as he has offered very little - but he never does!!!

My three strongest town reads had been Astro, AFC and Tennis. I now think at least one of these must be on a bad team just due to numbers. I don't know which one though.

 

after Chaos and ACS deaths though wouldn't the dead know already who are bad guys and who are good guys? Unless they are somehow stopped from revealing that info to the other dead guys?

 

I am totally stumped (due to being an idiot) ..luckily I have to go for a wee bit...and leave

I know its just a thought/grist for the mill

Wouldnt Chaos (guard 1st kill) know who the other guards are? and hence that tobes wasnt?

 

Not if the Warden is the one person acting alone who has info on some of the living. It would make sense for the warden to have that info. Him being alone wouldn't necessarily mean that the guards weren't on his team either. We;ve seen teams split up before in how they can communicate in other games. ACS wouldn't have known who the warden was as an acolyte. Chaos might have, but not if the warden is separated out from other players.

 

Sorry don't know why I mentioned ACS, think I read your post as the dead trying to kill bad guys instead of trying to kill the warden.

Not sure I'm following you RE chaos not knowing the warden?

Edit: are you saying the warden is the solo team? Don't we already know he is working with the guards?

 

Somebody is acting alone with knowledge about the living. It's in the game set up. It makes sense for that person to be the warden.

If he is acting alone then even his guards won't know who he is.

 

Lol see my edit

 

We don't know anything about him he might be working with the other guards - but if he is then we need to work out who is acting alone and why they have info on the living.

 

I was heavily involved in early discussions about directions. I suggested that bad choices in directions meant bad consequences, this now seems to be a shared view. I shared my opinion on what those choices meant and whether escaping was a possibility. I said early on that I didn't think escape wasn't an option, escape meant death, think I've been proved right there.

I commented on Valley's Warden and guards claim, how did he know they existing (he said it before Chaos was klilled). I've looked at the wardens claim of recruitment but this keeps getting swept under the carpet for some reason (I know there is much we can actually do about it, especially since we don't even know if a recruitment happened). I've look at game numbers/percentages in an attempt to work out how many bad guys / teams we're looking for.

I had links between players, albeit bad ones that i was observing. Most players do this in every game!

I listed all players and my views on them (you responded!) and I've given a reason for returning to the hotel too, seems my thoughts are in line with a couple of others.

Interesting that when I was hardly online yesterday, there were two or three pushed the agenda that I wasn't being helpful. You were one of them. Yet as soon as I responded nobody mentioned it again until now.

Bit harsh to cast the unhelpful tag at me when I simply wasn't available for one day. Same could be said for AFC, RHC and a few others too! I think I've contributed a lot to say I wasn't around most of yesterday and some of Monday since I was off (still online on and off throughout the day but its hard with three kids and jobs to do!)

The fact is, this game seems to be based on a book or film that I've never even heard of, never mind watched. I read and passed opinion and what I saw.

I think it's fair to say that Nev is now considered a innocent with his revelations. AFC seems innocent to me too (despite me jokingly voting for him which he;s since used against me ).

As I said before, put me and RHC in a split vote if you want. Not convinced RHC is guilty, he normally tells us if he is but he may have learnt his lesson. If I die we lose a innocent but at least I join the dead board who've probably got a better chance at winning this game than we have atm

 

Or was someone not on at all on Monday so wasn't able to make a kill?

 

Hadn't considered that! Who was inactive day one?

 

Indeed I had...


HOTEL

 

RHC, Darren Peacocks Ponytail, Nolberto

Those three didn't vote on either vote on day one.

 

Bar RHC, I don't know without checking (yep, that looks like I'm pointing the finger towards RHC )

 

Might be worth checking if any of them also didn't post anything.

 

DDP died so the killing wouldn't have increased if he had that ability. Nolberto and RHC are still alive

RHC wasn't at work so didn't post on the site at all

 

On night one we had no killings by the dead because there were no dead players.
We had no acolyte killings on day one or day two.

We know that ACS was acolyte and he was on. DPP was also acolyte and was killed on day 1. Either the other/one of the other acolytes was the one with the killing role or that team had other factors that needed to be fulfilled before they were killed. The problem with looking for a player that wasn't on is that we have two deaths. Would one player be able to kill two people (unlikely) or were two people inactive (also unlikely). It is more likely to be that the game situation resulted in two deaths rather than anything else.

A lot also depends on the night actions order. If ACS acted before being killed then he could have made one of the kills. Usually though the lynching is top of the night order. Perhaps each acolyte has a limited number of kills or restrictions on how many nights they can act. If this was the case they may have both acted (making a team of four which fits the usual percentages) and they both acted knowing ACS had been lynched and making sure that no more opportunities to kill were lost due to lynchings/deaths.

 

Nolberto didn't vote but did post on the thread quite a few times.

 

Having checked Nolberto did make a handful of posts on Monday, so only RHC was completely inactive.

 

You keep writing the same thing as me just before I write it! Get out of my head!