Off Topic Mafia game: The island

Going for Gerrez at the moment is pointless as he wont be on until later, at which point he better start getting involved or my suspicion will continue to grow!

I'm happy with ACS and Style as the initial votes today, both have fairly good reasons to be targeted. Wouldn't be surprised if Tobes got votes and I think if the pursuit of the others is fruitless it's worth considering him.

 

I like this thinking and it makes a lot of sense, I think it may well be the case.

 

Good thinking, I've watched the series and read the books so will be on the lookout for links.

 

Anyone got some spare dragon glass?

 

di you bold it? I was not sure.

i'll take it as a vote now

 

haha, I'd completely missed that, just skim read after the outage at lunch time.

 

Escape table:
neville: 1 vote by: ACS
ACS: 2 vote by: tennis, AFCFTW
style: 1 vote by: neville
yet to vote: RHC, Tobes, astro, Penfold, Bodanki, Mikey, G'inho, Nolberto,Style

Action table:
Follow the path
Follow the waterfall to the west: 2 vote by: astro, tennis
Follow the river to the east: 1 vote by: ACS
yet to vote: RHC, Tobes, Penfold, AFCFTW, Less Hope, Bodanki, Mikey, G'inho, Nolberto,Style

 

I was already suspicious of ACS on day 1 (and was the only one who voted for him on Day 1 but then changed to DPP when no one else suspected ACS) as I thought he was being much quieter than usual and yet still participating by voting for lynch etc. So I admitted that it wasn't much to go on but I thought he may have teammates keeping him on a leash so to speak. He didn't even react when I voted for him on Day 1 which I thought was very strange and not his normal style...

Then with the BobbyD link he went up to my #1 suspect, surprised not too many suspect him tbh. It worries me to be honest because I have a bit of a dodgy track record in reading certain players, and ACS is one of them that I tend to usually think is guilty, so when I'm one of the few ones suspecting him it concerns me!

 

Definatley think there is a 'BAD' choice (ie we will lose someone or something ..not pleasant at all ..will happen)

I was of a mind that the other 2 room options where just 'OK/safe' choices (still might be true). But also beginning to think there is some mileage in astros Good/neutral/bad concept to the room choice. ie there is the best choice that moves the story along towards a group escape ...neutral that is a holding pattern ..and bad, being..bad

totally agree that the route choice is vital...think the bad guys know which is the 'Bad' choice and ARE trying to lead us there (its one of the few ways we can get tells)

Edit: from a while ago ..am catchign up...not many pages due to site outage ...so thats good

 

It was bold in my first theory post, just normal in my second

 

Just to throw this out there..and following on from the 'bad' room choice

Did chaos (baddie) die because we made the 'Good' choice? (a way for us to kill bad guys?)

Edit..thinking about it...it might be a rolling mechanism every day ..like a few have suggested/no way of testing it..not even sure its a sensible concept

 

I'm a fan, but not a superfan, so I'll hand this theory over to you...

Two voices in the room when DPP was found. Big Booming voice and higher voice of unknown ethnic origin.

Possibly a killer and a white walker reanimating the dead? Also the body being cold to the touch (on a hot night).

 

If I was mafia I'd have known Bobby bought it, as I'd have been part of the decision to whack him mate.

Not even ACS's Mrs could read ACS, he's as random as random can get. I haven't got a clue about him in this game (or any other)

Style has barely been seen and when he has, he's not adding much.

Gerrez has been very quiet

Astro seems to be leading the direction choices.

I still can't fathom out the No.6 thing, it must be relevant and might be the key.

 

AFCFTW

Head East

What the ****ing hell's going on with this site?

 

What's your logic behind those calls mate?

 

The body is wrinkled and discoloured from its time in the water. You check for a pulse but there is none, you again get a smell, this time of an alcohol odour


Suddenly the lights go off…. A shot fires, echoing round the pool. The lights come on and you find 21 has been shot in the head….. what the hell!

You look round. Nobody came in or out of here, the door had been closed all the time. The killer must be right here! Quickly a search is organised but there is no gun


Anyone got any theories on this? The smell has to be significant due to the sweet smell on day 1?

the no gun found has to be significant too..otherwise why would Mito state what he did?

I haven't a clue though...

 

Logic?

I haven't got a ****ing clue what's going on. I got into this too late to ever catch up. My daughter comes first

PS No ****ing puns, please.

 

But it's too tempting.....