Off Topic Mafia game: The island

Nah the recievers toes would be clenched

 

ffs two columbo's...not only am i seeing dead ppl but now their all turning into ****ing detectives

 

Valley might not have died in the pool but died/drowned (filled with liquid) elsewhere and was dragged (Muddy trail) to the pool ..leg missing? ..who knows

was the manner of Valleys death related to where we chose to go...ie lake =water=drowned (cant see how this fits with DPP/Garden/puncture)

I should stay away from here till I have had more coffee mind

 

In simplistic terms we have had a 2 vs 1 room choice every day

day 1: outside(garden) vs 2 x indoors (up and downstairs)
day2: dry (desert) vs 2x Wet (sea and lake)


day 3 dry (path) vs 2x Wet (river and waterfall)

ie one bad ...2 'ok' choices.

Beginning to think that there is an ACTUAL route to the escape point that we have to negotiate

Assuming that garden was the 'wrong' choice...not sure how that has had an influence on us though ...IBWT died?
day 2 (assuming we made the 'right' choice ) BobbyD died????

Are IBWT and BobbyD deaths (both clubbed) related to our room choice?

So, not at all sure the significance of the room choices...unless its purely getting us closer or farther away from escape point

That in Mind ..I am happy to go river or waterfall...avoiding the path

 

I agree.

 

Im still here in spirit mate

 

Are we back now then???

At least there isn't much catching up to do!!

 

**** knows!

 

Site's been down this morning

#protip print the first page of the thread so you can still check the clues when it's down

 

Based on the description the jungle path seems the "hard" route, like the hills yesterday

Aside from that my preference would be the waterfall since that's more interesting and likely to lead to magic stuff

Also, the river leads to the sea, but the sea was one of the "wrong" options yesterday (assuming South was the correct one as it seems from before)

 

Woo back online!

Some good posts by mikey, Nev and nolberto.

 

****ing typical that I've been available all morning but I've got a board meeting at 2pm and football later so won't be getting online again until about 7pm at the earliest

Since I've not got time to read back now and I don't want to make random votes fr a third day running, I hold my votes until later

 

I'm convinced it makes a difference which route we go for and on the first two days it seemed to me like two of the choices each time had people trying to go for them, though I could be reading more into that and it only being one place per day, I'm not sure yet, but I'm certain there are people trying to influence where we go so it must have a bearing on how we escape.

I quite like the look of your theory re two good choices and one bad choice, so do we have to work out the odd choice out each time and avoid it? Or do we have to choose a specific option? I feel like having to get a specific option isn't great odds for the town so you may be right that we have to go with one of two options.

Are we able to link any of the actions that have happened during the nightfall summary to the choices we have made?

 

Good point about the blood smear. It could even be that we're meant to think things are supernatural to hide the killers (bit like Scooby Doo - more my level there).

As for the lynch, I don't have a lot to go on. In some ways Chaos was the worst bad guy to find as he is so random. He's like Albert on Steroids. My head started hurting looking for links! I don't see any strong links in posts. All we have is voting patterns and location choices. We didn't learn much last night as we don't know if we saved townie/mafia by killing Valley. On the first night there seemed to be a switch from Chaos to DPP. Although DPP was (likely) a bad guy, nobody would have known this. The two who switched late to DPP were Tobes and Chaos. This would appear to be a link. However, I haven't seen any other link in general posting. Others might have. There was also the possibility that they were saving Bodanki who I posted (my only) vote for. I posted a vote for Bod to see if the tie brought us any info. The only possible info on that was Tobes if people think that is suspicious.

On the location front, it looks like North would have been a bad choice yesterday. The person pushing very strongly for that yesterday was Style, who was then joined in doing so by Valley. We know Valley was innocent, so is it possible it was an innocent mistake from Style too? I honestly don't know.

Others who have attracted some suspicion to me are Gerrez for not adding value in the same way as usual. He seems to be sitting back and watching, though he has said that is because of half term. Albert is his usual random self. Bodanki is very quiet - but he has been for the last few games.

Others I have no reads on at all.

Astro seems to be looking at the clues in the same way as me, and to a slightly lesser extent, so does AFC. That makes me lean towards keeping them safe for now as I think we need to be solving clues. This could also be the best way to appear town though if people have extra info already (just as it could for me).

 

I wonder who is going to die tonight ha ha

 

Chaos being a confirmed bad guy makes the voting patterns of interest.

BobbyD stands out for me as he lumped on me following Chaos with the limpest of excuses.

I'm still convinced that the No.6 (as per the Prisoner series) has a role in this game, however, I'm now not convinced that it's as per the allotted numbers i.e. AFC.

Chaos was patently killed by the SK role, could this be tied to the No.6 character?

Only Tennis opted to not join the pack in voting South, but that might have been due to the time difference, and Bod opted out of the vote. Clues? Maybe, maybe nothing.

There seemed a real push to gain a complete consensus on the direction, was this a task for someone, or just trying to second guess a possible task that matched the theme?

 

Exactly my thinking on Chaos, I can't see any obvious links to anyone other than the possible vote situation involving Tobes, chaos and bodanki. Chaos was far too random for me to see any patterns and tbh it's a pain re-reading all the **** he posted

Interesting point RE style, I was already fairly suspicious of him and if North was the bad choice he seemed to be pushing for it as if he knew something we didn't. He might be a good option to go for, but as you say valley was innocent and seemed linked with hi ...but style did vote for valley so maybe valley was just an innocent who backed the wrong guy? I think I'm going to vote style for now as I don't see any other obvious options. I may well change my mind as the day progresses lol

I also agree about Gerrez, has been really inactive compared to normal, not sure if the game has just come at an awkward time for him or if he is using that as a bad guy to go under the radar, or a bit of both? Not sure it's anything but worth keeping an eye on.

 

A few mistakes in there Tobes....

BobbyD is dead and has been shown to be the detective.

To me, Chaos death looks very much like the work of the dead - we know they still have a role.

BobbyD's death looks like the work of the mafia (possible misdirection getting hat one wrong?)

Tennis did vote south - MITO missed it though (I think)

The unanimous task seeme dto be more of a growing concensus. If there was something behind it then I think it was started by Nolberto, added to by astro and then joined by me, before others joined in.

 

BobbyD was the detective though! So if he went for you with no excuse doesn't that make you look suspicious?