Off Topic Mafia game: The island

In the throes of catching up but see my comment at 329.

 

But DPP had a role - an acolyte?

 

Wrong

Lets leave it i suppose youve worked everything out?

All you base anything on is how annoying people are

Sorry drop it please

 

Cheers im just trying to understand things

 

I reckon they both died mate

DDP escaped (was lynched) imo, that's what we voted for. If they actually escaped, there wouldn't be a need for a dead side of the game.

Biscan was a random killing but who by? Mafia or Town? I'd guess both sides will have kills. Probably a mafia killing at this stage since it make sense to wait if you're the town killer; more likely to hit one of your own in a random attack. Unless ACS is the town killer of course

That's assuming it is just two teams of course. But then, even if there is more than two teams, only the town team will be goodies.

 

Im thinking evil spirits because dpp was a man of the cloth, the voices but nobody seen and the fact we have extra numbers

 

Sorry, but what are you talking about here? Why would MITO swap kills and who are you claiming he's swapped? We clearly voted for DPP

 

The salient point was he was inactive though.

If MITO had a role set for the first stiff then him being absent might have ruined the game play, so he switched it?

Just a theory, nothing more.

 

Problem is, townies have no idea who is who so DPP being innocent doesn't automatically mean it was a mafia kill. We don't even know if the acolyte role was town aligned or not do we?

 

We already know there are more than two teams - it says in the OP.

I am guessing that the acolyte (a ceremonial role) was part of a third team - possibly one that could use the dead in some way?

 

I'm off to re-read the rules then...

 

What's this switch theory? I don't get it at all.

 

While you're there read the nightfall report for Day 1 - DPP was murdered, not caught trying to escape......makes no sense.

 

Agreed. Tobes coming out with nonsense that mito would change the rules because he thinks dpp was inactive.

We can see each day the person who escapes is murdered and mito has also mentioned this in the op.

He thinks ifwt was escaping cause he wasnt in his room but he was murdered by a bat.

Anyway enough of this nonsense we need to come to a consensus of which way to go and too many people are hiding. I say we head north and get a better view of our surroundings or if there is a secret camp at top that is overlooking everyone.

 

Read the devils acolyte

I think we are in tavistock

A man was blugeoned to death in tavistick in the devils acolyte

 

IFWT was murdered, 22 was bubbled, and DPP was chimneyed

 

DDP was voted for escape...

Lynch: It is not a classic lynch It is an escape, however if you try and ecape on your own you will die so its a death sentence

...escaping is effectively being lynched. We can only vote for one person to escape so they will always be attempting to do it alone. If you try to escape on your own, you will die. DPP was caught trying to escape and was therefore killed. that's how I read it.

No way MITO is going to swap roles around mid-game either imo

 

DPP was voted for the 'escape', he was murdered in the house though, not caught trying to escape?

Why?

Instead Biscan was seemingly caught trying to escape;

Across the path, barely visible in the shadows cast by a willow tree, lay what appeared to be a baseball bat used to end the life of this unfortunate Prisoner number 5. He's been murdered after wandering off for a minute.

Why the switch between the planned murder by the mafia or SK and the voted for 'escapee'?

 

There is no 22 though?

 

23 was also murdered at the hotel for "escaping"