Off Topic Mafia game: The island

Always a solid option

 

I'm not changing mine because I was the first to vote for it and had logical suggestions for it.
I don't believe there's a right or wrong answer, we'll get clues from MITO no matter where we go, it's how we interpret them that's important.
I'm not saying all three places will give the same clues, I'm saying that I don't think one is better than the other. We'll probably end up going to all three places eventually.

 

I think one will definitely be better than the other and I think some of the people going for upstairs are trying to influence the decision. Your all on my watch list!

 

Just a thought. I know I missed this, so not sure if others have too. Will the body still be in the garden? And if so, will examining the body further give us extra clues?

To me, as far as the choice of where to go is concerned we have two basic choices.

1. We look for further clues to build on what we know
2. We look for brand new clues to give us more information about the game as a whole.

Within option one, there are two clear choices - upstairs (crime scene) or garden (where the body was discovered). Arguments have been put for each of those, and there are elements of both that make sense.

Within option two we have a choice of all three locations at random.

Based on that I think the choice should be between upstairs or garden as this gives the option of covering both bases.

 

looks like it's different this time.
We need to get as many town as possible off the island?
If this is the case, knowing Neville is a bastards I'm going to change to Tennis so no damage can be done.

 

Im going for someone quiet having ran the last one i now know that much if nothing at all

Afc

 

That's bad guy coersion there.

I'm plain old town lads.

I'm ALWAYS right to vote me off please.

 

We need you in the game mate to help the post count.

 

I quite like that logic.... But I'm currently voting downstairs lol

I've said I won't vote upstairs as I think we are being played like a fiddle but I'll go with garden if others think it's a viable option. For now I'm sticking with Gerrez and the beer in the cellar

 

Don't worry I've got the post count covered

 

Ill be dead soon they all want me upstairs mate

 

Now there's a shock!!!!

The only shocking bit about it is that you managed to get in there before Tobes and Astro voted for each other

 

I bet you have mate!

Im onto you like jessica parker

 

OK but that's not what the pre-game discussions suggested:

 

Actually

Tobes

 

You've definitely chosen the quietest poster, I've barely said two words so far!

 

Too many people not getting involved so far.... I may attempt to stop spamming this thread while others have some input.....maybe....

 

Mate ive moved on for everyone elses sake

Tobes

Not usually quiet

 

I post a lot more when at work. Got **** to do at home; sorting house out ready for selling and got three kids that are off school!

I said cellar, not downstairs! However, downstairs as good as any so...

 

Ah, I never saw those quotes in the sign up thread, did not read it to the end.

I guessed that we would get all 3 clues eventually, but in light of that comment about the 30/40 possible outcomes I'll change my vote to Explore the garden.
I don't think we can go wrong by exploring any of the three places, but given that there has been a lot of talk about the poison linking to the garden I think it's a good place to start as there has been a decent amount of speculation about the possible garden link to 23's death already.

As for the escapee vote, I don't think we should come up with a plan too early on (i.e. a tied vote or whatever). Again it just gives guys the option to coast along and not give any real opinions, the reasoning is always "I vote X to make it a tied vote".

I'll vote for one of the quiet ones to see if they'll appear. I vote DPP.