Off Topic Mafia game: The island

I suspect it was more likely to be cyanide, based purely on the fact that it is a more widely known poison and I'm not sure MITO would be wanting us to need too much scientific knowledge to solve anything. I also suspect that it's just as likely that the chemical was stored to be used as a poison rather than for it's practical uses, based only on the need to have a poison in the game. I think there is more to this death than meets the eye, and finding out the details could give us more clues. We will get clues wherever we go, but to me it makes sense to get clues that build on what we already know.

 

screw you buddy!

 

Afc

 

BTW in case my blatant #genius gets me targetted by an assassin or something, then make sure tomorrow to follow my strategy.

MITO says this game is about figuring out things. So look for the most obvious clues. Today it was the shoe (possible red herring) and the smell. Googling the "sweet smell" leads to HCN and ETO poisons. Putting these into wikipedia brings up the pesticide and tobacco plant links.

Also, why is it "gardens"? Surely a random 3rd option on an island would be beach or something rather than gardens?

 

Lets kill him

 

So.....has chaos worn everyone down enough yet for us to lynch him regardless of info?

 

Sure it's possible I'm over-thinking things, but it's a game and IMO that's better than under-thinking

 

Quite a few people staying rather quiet so far... Wonder if there will be a flurry of activity closer to nightfall

 

Changed your arguement against me pretty quickly there... From me pushing everyone to go upstairs, to only one defending it and haven't actively told people to vote upstairs.... Despite me actually saying I have no preference ether way but out of the 3 having to pick one if go for that but no more logic than anything else.

 

I haven't changed any reason lol, let's not start an argument over the use of "pushing" or "defending". Either way you appear to me to be the most in favour of going upstairs.

 

Ok, so the two things we have to decide today:

Who do we lynch? What is our strategy? Random person? Kill chaos to keep him quiet? Go for a tie of a few people? Target the quiet ones? What's the plan?

The other choice is obviously which route we take. My opinion is that we are being played like fools and convinced to go upstairs but I may be paranoid! I'm happy to go with either of the other two options but don't want to stick with upstairs given it was the first thing to be suggested and everyone jumped straight in board with it. Again, we have to decide if we all vote for one place, or if we go for a coin flip?

 

MITO's discussion of the game has made it clear he's put a lot of effort into it, and that there are things we are supposed to work out.

I agree that there are no "dead ends" but I also think that some options are better than others. Because of the chain of evidence I have created I think the gardens are the best bet, but in any case I think going upstairs is so blatantly obvious that there's no chance it's going to be the best option.

The whole island theme is very "Lost". It's also like the show "The Prisoner" though I don't know that one so much (except the main guy was Number 6 too).

Downstairs and upstairs sound boring as ****, but I'm imagining stuff like tobacco plants/pesticide leaving a trail that leads to a secret passage and a control room etc.

 

So I'm the main character of this game?

#allaboutafcftw

 

I kind of hope mito has put that level of effort into this game, could get really interesting trying to figure things out and coming up with theories!

 

Listen stop using everybody your not with your school ground rabble now sunshine.

I have simply said i dont fancy upstairs or garden so sorry i have an opinion

Also im simply trying to contribute in any way i can im not a serious person im hopefully misunderstood

Sorry

 

Afc

 

- you seem really sorry!

 

Escape table:
Chaos: 2 Vote by: Tobes, Bodank
RHC: 1 vote by: Valley
IFWT: 1 vote by: AFCFTW
AFCFTW: 1 vote by: Chaos
Less hope: 1 vote by: G'inho
BobbyD: 1 vote by: Astro
RHC; 1 vote by: style
yet to vote: RHC, Penfold, IFWT, Darren Peacocks Ponytail, Less Hope, Mikey, Nolberto, ACS, Sir Tennisball, BobbyD

Action table:
Explore upstairs: 7 votes by: Sir tennis, BobbyD, IFWT, tobes, Less Hope, bodanki, Penfold
Explore downstairs: 2 vote by: AFCFTW, G'ihno
Explore the gardens: 3 vote by: Astro, Chaos, Style
yet to vote: RHC, Penfold, Darren Peacocks Ponytail, Mikey, Nolberto, ACS, Valley

 

I am sorry, however i have no reason to vote for anyone else.

 

I vote to kill Neville