Off Topic Coyote Canyon Game Thread

I actually think

Bandits
Gcb trying to save rhc
Astro too quiet
Acs this guy loves to chat. Trying to stay under the radar

No other reads really

 

Oh and tash turning up last minute is a big red flag

 

You're dead asshat

 

Really?
Are you sure?

 

Townsfolk, today could be critical. From tonight the bandits can start to recruit.
We have the following left:

Sheriff and Deputy - who can communicate

Bank Manager - now alone

Tavern - team of 4 who can communicate

2 tradesmen - individuals who can't communicate

Doc - alone so can't communicate

Priest - alone so can't communicate

Vigilante - alone so can't communicate

That team of four could be the key. That's a strong group who know eho each other are. The problem for everybody else is if those four work together, it might be percrived as bandit gang behaviour, because we don't know you from the Donaldsons who also have 4 players.

We can't reveal roles, but no reason why we can't all follow Biscans lead and list who we each trust. I think that could help Town massively as we start to see some consistency/patternd. Bandits will have to either need to blend in, or they potentially give away their gang members.Whereas Town can simply be honest.

What does everyond think? Any readon for TOWN to not do this? There will be a few clueless individuals - like me, but those eho are aligned can help form a stronger groul by sharing their views.

Another point, Gerrez, GCB and Priest know of each other but cannot communicate privately. Also cannot reveal publicly. Also, Gerrez and GCB cannot vote today, which weakens our position short term. But watch for their pattern and what they say. Personally, I think they are only likely yo have gone to sanctuary if the were Town.

Also, we don't know about Sebb and Musty and whether they have been assigned new Town roles, or non Town roles. But gor mow, I sm steering away from them as I think priorit has yo be the 4 established Donaldsons posing the greater threat.

Any other suggestions?

 

@Graham Carr's Binoculars, I think I have a fairly decent read on you being town, but I'd like to know your reason for jailing Brb on day 1 please?
Was it purely for your own benefit and he was essentially a +1, or did you suspect he was either town or a bad guy and you jailed him for that reason?

 

Right now I am looking at the people who voted for Tash, or the people who jumped on the Chaos bandwagon late on

 

Voting for me and Gerrez is a mistake tonight.

As town we still out number the bandits by quite a bit when it comes to the lynch vote, in fact we could lose 3 or 4 people and still outnumber them tomorrow.

It makes sense for town to keep us to then get a read on our voting tomorrow. If we lead you down a river with our voting you'd have the numbers to remove us the following night knowing 100% we'd played you. However, when we take out a bandit, you'd know at least three people voting for said bandit are town and we'd be close to wiping them out.

Given ACS has voted me I'd urge everyone to vote him tonight. If I'm wrong, then all lynch me tomorrow but either way at worst you'd lose one town member and one bandit and still be in a position of strength. If you take out ACS tonight and he's a bandit you then know 100% im town. It's a no lose game plan.

 

In all honesty I shouldn't have gone to prison, but I barely understood the game at that point so thought it was the best option. Brb was a random selection,personally I'm not so sure he's town.

 

Not really.
You could easily both be bandits from opposing teams

 

Gerrez and gcp don't know each other's roles though do they?

and I do think listing everyone and you're thoughts, even if it's no thought at all is useful. As you say it makes the bad guys do something rather than sit in and watch.

 

I'll post my long post soon, finally caught up. Thanks for replying GCB.

Same question to you Obi Wan:

@Obi Wanaldum , I have a Town read on you, but I'd like to know your reason for jailing ACS on day 1 please because I'm suspicious of him...
Was it purely for your own benefit and he was essentially a +1, or did you suspect he was either town or a bad guy and you jailed him for that reason?

 

They might not know each other's roles, but they can have a greater degree kof trust of a Town read in my opinion.

But yes, my main point was how do we rally everyone together? That Saloon Bar/Brothrl team need to help lead the way. Otherwise it will look like bandit activity if they switch votes late on, etc.

 

If the bank manager dies ..do we lose the ability to pay the sheriff/doc etc or can they be paid from business accounts

We can do an investigation today ..vis deputy (60% chance if done alone by him)

Think the sheriff can declare themselves today?? (Might be wrong about that couldn't find it again in the rules)

 

I'm fairly certain someone dies every night

 

I can't get on much today, actually have some work to do since I've done pretty much nothing since Friday because of this game! Cheers Nev!

I'm suspicious of ACS, Brb and Bodanki. I know of one other town member for certain and I'm happy to say I'm of the opinion that Gerrez is almost definitely town too.

As I've said, vote ACS, if I'm wrong you'll know I'm a bandit and can kill me tomorrow. If I'm right it all but proves I'm definitely town.

 

Agree ish ..There is still a chance you and gerrez ..could ..be opposing bandits ...but unlikely

 

How surprising! Just after I found the obvious hole in your logic.

GCB

 

Similar to GCB in that it seemed an easy way to buy 1 day to survive and assess. Do yes, purely selfish and cowardly. Happy to admit thay. If I had been part of a sub team, with immediate support, I might not have done.

Onto ACS. No, I had no read on him at all and syill no idea which team he is on. So why choose him? Well it had to be somebody. But I selected ACS because:
1. When he has a role with a gun/kill ability he is random and has ben known to shoot fellow townsfolk (whilst town himself) purely on a hunch
2. He usually wades in with a vote for me first just for laughs, but i have been killed off twice on day 1 before as a consequence of jis 'fun' evdn ehrn on the same team.
3. I thought if I 'saved' him for 1 night he might calm it down on slways acvusing md snd constantly posting 'Obi is dodgy' etc. I was wrong

So in short, no real motive other than self preservation. I admit it.

 

There's a very small chance me and ACS are both bandits. It's hardly a hole in my logic.

If I die it's not the end of the world, it'll still resort in a town win because all eyes will move straight to you, ACS and anyone else voting me and I'm pretty convinced ACS is a bandit.