Off Topic Mafia XII - Game Thread

I believe Gerrez is town for what it is worth

 

Being an addition doesn't mean you will or won't have any role, the point is it says nothing about whether the initial set up had everyone with a role or not, which is what Mikey would have been told

 

I'm not convinced he's not. If mafia started strong there is nothing to suggest IBWT didn't create two townies.

 

Regardless of RHC's role I have reason to believe Gerrez is being truthful

 

But you are useless at figuring out roles

 

Are you drunk? (In the game)

 

I've already put my cards on the table in regards to who I think are prime candidates for being mafia are.

When Tobes went ahead in the lynch vote you, astro & acs jumped in and decided to get rid of Obi Wan, a guy who was a convenient scapegoat considering he was acting dodgy, moving Tobes (confirmed mafia) out of the way in the process. ACS was the least suspicious out of the 3 voters because he genuinely seems to just like voting for Obi Wan.

After the vote the first thing you do after nightfall after people made the link was to vote astro "for the time being" to distance yourself from him, but I thought to myself I'd be very surprised if your vote was still on astro at the end of the night.

 

Can you explain why? Because that's just made Gerrez dodgy in my eyes.

 

That post pretty much confirms to me that you are town. Because one bit in particular matches up with the PM I got, and I'm sure the rest of the people who got the same PM will see the bit that gives it away

 

Because of how he explained his role

 

Check back. Tobes wasn't ahead when I switched. Neville was and had been most of the day. If I recall correctly, my vote made Neville and Obi tied.

Shortly afterwards the tide turned and everyone piled on Obi.

I made a comment that that was odd not enough people left to all be Mafia. Only person I could have switched to was Tobes (wouldn't have helped anyway) and at that point to me Tobes had done nothing suspicious.

 

Based on the bites I have had to my post (which is why I posted it and worded it the way I did) I am pretty convinced Gerrez and Lucaas are town.

Getting this in now as there is still a good chance I could go tonight.

 

Reading dodgy motivations into people voting for Obi when he was even deliberately trying to make people vote for him either makes you stupid or someone acting stupid for the sake of an argument

 

Yes and Obi also WASN'T town. He looked guilty for a reason. Albeit the reason was, he wanted to.

 

Is that a vote?

 

What is playing silly buggers? Those items were definitely seem by me in his house

 

You're half right, so am I. Its somewhere in the middle. It was actually 3 votes each between Neville & Tobes with 10 minutes to go. Then 3 late votes from ACS, Astro & yourself within 3 minutes of each other put Tobes out of danger, who was coincidentally (?) mafia. You could've been saving Neville, as well, but from his previous posts I don't believe him to be mafia.

 

VALLEY

 

Valley's post had Gerrez in bold so counting it as a vote... table below

No.	Lynchee	Lynchers
3	Gerrez	Magic, Milk, Gerrez
1	Astro	RHC
1	RHC	Astro,
3	ACS	Style, Nev, Lucaas
1	Magic	Gerrez,
2	Nev	ACS, Bobby

Yet to vote - AFC

 

Any reason why ACS has three votes?