Mafia XI - An Unknown Evil -GAMEOVER Town/Anarchist Victory!

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think that might be unwise....

I'd love someone up here with me but not bod.

I am in because the BLOODS team are working my case. (mikey knows the bird code)

however certain info in my mind says hmmmm.. maybe don't put someone up with me as it will only allow bad things to happen to the town.
 
  • Like
Reactions: J. J. McClure
I think I have a very good read on quite a few townies. I also have lots of clues to base quite a few evil roles on too (not my own work - so can't claim the credit).

My thoughts on people so far. Where I think I know someone is innocent I am just putting innocent and not putting any reasons:

(pasted from front page, so no meaning in the order)

RHC - Not sure. Very little to go on but have niggling doubts
Mito - Team Skull
Gerrez - Innocent
JPF - High Priest of the Occult Brotherhood of the Skull
astro - Keep getting guilty reads. Had him down as having a connection with JPF but don't think that can be the case now. Possibly some role connected to Shaman.
Neville - Innocent
Tobes - Mad Scientist Town
Bod - Think innocent. Don;t think he would have been so obviously quiet if evil
Style - Team Skull
AFC - Innocent
Lucaas - Body guard for Occult Brotherhood of Blood.
Obi Wan - Team Blood
IBWT - Igor, Mad Scientist's sidekick Town.
Valley - Innocent
ACS - Was Shaman of Baphomet. Resurrected. as follower of Baphomet (now dead again)
Tennisball - Team Blood
Magic - not sure - very quiet and I don't know if this is typical
Mikey - Innocent

Those bold bits aren't a vote for everyone before I get asked <laugh>
 
  • Like
Reactions: moreinjuredthanowen, afcftw, Super G Ted'inho and 1 other person
Right, I think we need to get a tie together, as supposedly in whatever way they are worked out multiple players can be lynched so we could hit two birds with one stone.

MITO, Style and Tennis should be the three I think. MITO is the best player to die because it gives us the most answers but might as well shoot for the dream of getting multiple as Style and Tennis wouldn't be much worse.

I vote forStyle.
 
  • Like
Reactions: afcftw, Super G Ted'inho and J. J. McClure
Mikey said:
Trust me I've given a lot of thought to the dude virus, until I found the 'on the prowl' stuff my active theory was that Gerrez and AFC actually were mafia and had just bluffed out their arses the whole way and that the Medium is actually planning to align against town and thus wasn't nailing them, but that's the only way they can be mafia - if the Medium is actually on their side. That's a posibility I'm concerned about but I don't want us to trip over our own toes entertaining that idea too strongly and then shoot ourselves in the foot. So I have to go with what's in front of me, that being;

1. There's evidence that scum and town teams alike entered the game not knowing their teammates
2. There's evidence that teams were given keyword or phrases to be able to identify each other
3. Gerrez and AFC have used the same keywords multiple times
4. Lucaaas, Tennis and Obi Wan have used the same keywords multiple times and interacted with each other whilst using them
5. Lucaaas is dead mafia
6. You and Style have used the same phrase multiple times and Style liked one of your posts including that word
7. Gerrez and AFC have given reasons for using their keywords (And booooy have they stuck to it <laugh> )
8. Neither other group have provided a reason for using them and just mark it as coincidence
9. We've already identified one (Two kind of I suppose) town team and there is unlikely to be another

As such, hard to look past that and try and find a way for Gerrez and AFC to be mafia with what we have to go on.
Click to expand...


I will say a few things so not to blow the whole thing.. thanks for actually asking me BTW.

1. I do agree there is evidence of this. have you thought where did that evidence first come from?

2. I believe the whole Gerrez AFC stuff broke the keyword stuff. I have given you my views on this. first I used DUDE first, nobody esle. Obi claimed to use mondo by total error. what I am saying is that Gerrez was brazen about it replying to me. He also used the term back to me in post 88 and then as i was posting he replied back with gnarly the first time see posts 97 and 98.

As a result of both of these i sat back. I got worried it was all too obvious.

3. AFC game on even later and used DUDE in his first post. That really attracted attention and i had to go run... the circumstance is these two have been caught in it since and have gone with it and i decided to stay in the back ground protecting them secretly by my votes and digging at them publically.

4. you have said i've used a phrase with style.. actually its one word... you know you've pulled stuff days apart don't you? however fine I say put style up here and get him lynched instead of me then

5. I want to give you HELP.... you are limiting your search to three... mistake. OBI, lucaaas and Tennis is a great catch... this bird thing is something I didn't spot and you've allowed me to fill up my table of roles as a result. the brother hood of the blood is pretty clear isn't it and you are missing one!!!!! think about it... I figured this out very simply.... look to the roles...

6. Gerrez and AFC have played brilliantly but..... think about it... if i'd not switched day one who was going to die? Who hung off ACS half the day yesterday and only voted as i had to....and was trying to ask them some reasonable questions.....

7. I have one more thing for you... how do you think gerrez survived the night? Gerrez can tell you.



In short you've not got the fully picture yet.... I've told you in regular games the bad hide in the good. in this game the good are hiding in the bad. think about it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: J. J. McClure
Looking at both the tread and the voting wouldn't be surprised to see the two named mafia teams try and take each other out tonight. Is this a tactic knowing something we don't or is it all about survival? We could be left having to deal with the team we seem to know least about - a team that I still think there is a reason has a different name. Have been looking for clues if there is anything in this but can't see any yet. Would welcome thoughts from others. Some of the end game stuff and hidden stuff with the dead is going over my head and I can't make sense of it tbh.
 
  • Like
Reactions: J. J. McClure
Mikey said:
Right, I think we need to get a tie together, as supposedly in whatever way they are worked out multiple players can be lynched so we could hit two birds with one stone.

MITO, Style and Tennis should be the three I think. MITO is the best player to die because it gives us the most answers but might as well shoot for the dream of getting multiple as Style and Tennis wouldn't be much worse.

I vote forStyle.
Click to expand...

I'll follow your lead and vote

Style
 
  • Like
Reactions: moreinjuredthanowen and J. J. McClure
Less Hope Than Neville said:
I think I have a very good read on quite a few townies. I also have lots of clues to base quite a few evil roles on too (not my own work - so can't claim the credit).

My thoughts on people so far. Where I think I know someone is innocent I am just putting innocent and not putting any reasons:

(pasted from front page, so no meaning in the order)

RHC - Not sure. Very little to go on but have niggling doubts
Mito - Team Skull
Gerrez - Innocent
JPF - High Priest of the Occult Brotherhood of the Skull
astro - Keep getting guilty reads. Had him down as having a connection with JPF but don't think that can be the case now. Possibly some role connected to Shaman.
Neville - Innocent
Tobes - Mad Scientist Town
Bod - Think innocent. Don;t think he would have been so obviously quiet if evil
Style - Team Skull
AFC - Innocent
Lucaas - Body guard for Occult Brotherhood of Blood.
Obi Wan - Team Blood
IBWT - Igor, Mad Scientist's sidekick Town.
Valley - Innocent
ACS - Was Shaman of Baphomet. Resurrected. as follower of Baphomet (now dead again)
Tennisball - Team Blood
Magic - not sure - very quiet and I don't know if this is typical
Mikey - Innocent

Those bold bits aren't a vote for everyone before I get asked <laugh>
Click to expand...

pretty close but not quite.

I have something similar but form the other perspective.

what you've just said is the following

RHC, Gerrez,Neville (you) Bod, AFC, Valley, magic, mikey are all good.... or not known... so you've given the evil a list to compare to their to find the medium.

I am trying my best to not out this medium but i know now who it is from whats been done today (and its not you)

you are missing a vital fact

RHC was in the cheese on bank holiday monday... (or where were you RHC) he never posted once... now those of us who know him and you know in games.... He was never the holy arrow. he was the holy water..

there are two actors for good right there...

there are THREE bad guy teams. bloods, skulls and team bapo. I know it sounds odd but everything points to the fact that theres a LOT more bad than good and so the thought that there are actually many good guys working for the town is in fact wrong and all these guys hiding right now.... well...... it tells a lot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: J. J. McClure
Less Hope Than Neville said:
I think I have a very good read on quite a few townies. I also have lots of clues to base quite a few evil roles on too (not my own work - so can't claim the credit).

My thoughts on people so far. Where I think I know someone is innocent I am just putting innocent and not putting any reasons:

(pasted from front page, so no meaning in the order)

RHC - Not sure. Very little to go on but have niggling doubts
Mito - Team Skull
Gerrez - Innocent
JPF - High Priest of the Occult Brotherhood of the Skull
astro - Keep getting guilty reads. Had him down as having a connection with JPF but don't think that can be the case now. Possibly some role connected to Shaman.
Neville - Innocent
Tobes - Mad Scientist Town
Bod - Think innocent. Don;t think he would have been so obviously quiet if evil
Style - Team Skull
AFC - Innocent
Lucaas - Body guard for Occult Brotherhood of Blood.
Obi Wan - Team Blood
IBWT - Igor, Mad Scientist's sidekick Town.
Valley - Innocent
ACS - Was Shaman of Baphomet. Resurrected. as follower of Baphomet (now dead again)
Tennisball - Team Blood
Magic - not sure - very quiet and I don't know if this is typical
Mikey - Innocent

Those bold bits aren't a vote for everyone before I get asked <laugh>
Click to expand...

Couldn't be more wrong, my son.
 
  • Like
Reactions: J. J. McClure
moreinjuredthanowen said:
pretty close but not quite.

I have something similar but form the other perspective.

what you've just said is the following

RHC, Gerrez,Neville (you) Bod, AFC, Valley, magic, mikey are all good.... or not known... so you've given the evil a list to compare to their to find the medium.

I am trying my best to not out this medium but i know now who it is from whats been done today (and its not you)

you are missing a vital fact

RHC was in the cheese on bank holiday monday... (or where were you RHC) he never posted once... now those of us who know him and you know in games.... He was never the holy arrow. he was the holy water..

there are two actors for good right there...

there are THREE bad guy teams. bloods, skulls and team bapo. I know it sounds odd but everything points to the fact that theres a LOT more bad than good and so the thought that there are actually many good guys working for the town is in fact wrong and all these guys hiding right now.... well...... it tells a lot.
Click to expand...

Rhetorical question <laugh>
 
  • Like
Reactions: J. J. McClure
should be fun... lets get one form each team up

Tennis is on team blood.
style is on team skull

stand by.... drum roll

NEW INFO

Bodanki is on team BAPHO (look back guys at bods post... the first thing he did was shout a word that was totally out of character and my ACS replied to it... look for the word LARGE. please not the tagging going on where people are desperately seeding this as the medium is large as they know MIKEY is looking for words and phrases.
 
  • Like
Reactions: afcftw and J. J. McClure
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom
Back