Mafia XI - An Unknown Evil -GAMEOVER Town/Anarchist Victory!

oh so now you know who the medium is... how? don't tell me who but you've just dropped another big one in here.

I read what you just said is the medium knows you due to your actions.. i asked you this yesterday i heard you yesterday.

but have you just said you KNOW who he is or you THINK you KNOW from a process of elimination.

And please be vague if you have to be as if there is an obvious clue you don't need to blow his cover

 

Nearly, the medium knows who we are. There is no reason behind the words other than attracting attention (I think we can agree that ones worked ) and possibly killing the other surfer in the side game should one of us fail to include the word in three posts in one day (we've basically agreed to work together rather than try to kill each other anyway) #dude

The suicide was 100% real. Milk was asking that the suicide happen early enough for him to prepare a report but there was no way we were going to allow time for votes to swing away from ACS had AFC committed suicide. Milk countered it by writing report the way he did (which I thought was great). Would be a bit **** for the game host to wum everyone wouldn't it...? Would you do that...?

dude

 

OK... Conspiracy coming together... No (Or almost none of them) teams know their teammates, we've seen two clear uses of keywords, 'Scientist' and the surfer stuff. there was also this post from Milk:

This clearly shows that there was at least 1 team or possibly more who didn't know who each other were but were able to find out and then communicate via PM, 'Quick Topic Boards will be set-up' shows either there were criteria to be met (LIke using the keywords a certain number of times) or at a fixed point they would be able to come together.

I'll get onto the surfers in a minute, but first just from browsing the first few pages I've seen this:

I included the last two to show it wasn't cherry-picked, as they used the word too, though to me it seems more natural and less shoe-horned in like the others, where it seems so off-topic and they keep going back to it.

Got more thoughts and doing more digging but will just post this for now so I don't end up with War and Peace on my hands.

 

tennis

On the investigators:

PM message is a good catch. the thought i had was these if there was any they had to be finging good guys. there was only one death on day 1 so either they hit ACS and his role was revealed or they hit others. I would presume on hight two there are more deaths so...

Is there an investigator with an evil name out there or not.. if they've good names then a good team can be formed later

On the holy assassin. I just don't know. what we could have seen is the holy water being the investigator and the arrow being the assassin. your numbers alow this.



....................................

finaly point... You are wondering about lucaaaas and protection. The order of posts i think is still key. I think we can glean some info form this. gerrez was attacked or followed before lucas dies. Lets keep an open mind. what you have said is possible but your team structures say 2 bodyguard roles....

 

I know he knows who we are so throughout the game I've been looking for clues. I'm not going to say what those clues or actions are and let others know who he is though. In theory, its a 'think' rather than'know' but I actually know via a process of elimination. I am 100% confident on who it is and I think AFC probably knows too (remember we're not allowed to talk privately so everything we do is right in front of your eyes).

dude

 

Then you'd be wrong. The holy water thing is important

 

oh it certainly has attracted that.

So I was thinking back to my own game where i put a suicide bomber in and tennis was sat there waiting at 8:59 to react and the suicide bomber let it off at 8:59 to prevent anyone changing.

however AFC was pretty clear that 8:50 was when he would do it so you have offered a pluasible explanation as to why it might be the case.

I would personally not do that at all as i've found it leads to at least a couple of peopel getting really annoyed. When immade an error on you swarbs went nuts actually. remember?

 

wow

 

@Gerrez

Are you sure you are a good guy...

 

The facts are that someone wants these two dead. For me their roles are to obvious to be evil as it makes them easy targets.

 

I like it

I will say though (and I have said this already), AFC and I were sent a joint PM but we weren't told we weren't allowed to communicate so it was definietly aimed at us. However, Milk sent us this at the same time as posting that warning...

...so perhaps there were others too

#dude

 

@Mikey

You have point out something huge. IBWT was first on and his first post is easy to find.

he was a good guy.

he said.

"last time I take my wife away on a dirty weekend away to a hotel!"

the good guy did not say bird but all the others did.

 

I'm still looking.

I voted last night but i want to look at the tables next.

 

He didn't just have to allow Milk time to do the report (I wouldn't have ), he also needed me to report his comment for the suicide to work #dude

 

Exactly, and they kept coming back to it even though I can't really see IBWT replying anywhere, it's not like they were having back-and-forth banter.

 

Hand on heart 100% and as you know there are two people in this game that can confirm it. I can't do any more than I have to convince people, I've told you everything repeatedly since the start of day two and I've posted C&P of my PM as well. What else would you like me to do? The only option I have left is killing myself by providing a screenshot

#dude

 

the problem as i see it mikey is this;

you've got lucaaas (known bad) Obi wan, tennis, style and neville all saying bird.

that is 5 man team... all talking...

the math says 3 x5 = 15. that would be 5 bad guys and only 3 good guys so that doesn't add up. we know the medium and holy guys and the surfer claim and the mad scientists

Which ones are most likely to have been communicating?

 

Thing is, it could also be passed off as normal banter between those guys. Worth keeping an eye on it but doubt anything else will happen now you've pointed it out (not that I'd seen it, doubt many did)

#dude

 

ok.......

 

Read the PM I posted dude (#1640), our side game is in there