Mafia XI - An Unknown Evil -GAMEOVER Town/Anarchist Victory!

Ok, open question to everyone. Has there ever been a town condition like this in a game before? I'm trying to be open minded, but that includes questioning bits that seem strange - and that seems like an unusual requirement.

 

No dude

 

I can't answer any of those questions dude

 

Read you post and you certainly had it available quick enough - though maybe you foresaw the need.

A bit I'm not sure of, and this isn't about you - does that mean that for the town to win one of you needs to be dead? Or is it only for yourselves? I think the wording is ambiguous.

 

There is a dead bodyguard but another still alive.

There are 3 assassins, so probably a minimum 2 will succeed. But only 2 assassins night 1, so maybe one (a town one?) can only act after 1 night, or on alternate nights.

There was a holy arrow night 1, holy water thrown night 2, the pattern could be holy arrow again tonight.

So 3-4 people can die tonight, plus whoever is lynched.

 

Milk answered question 5 yesterday. All phone lines and electricity have been cut off so there is no hot water (tho apparently there is a tv that JPF was hooked up to )

 

No, the town can win if we both live, neither AFC or I are considered winners though. I'm happy to take a hollow victory though dude.

 

So we have 13 players and I think the following roles:

(Obviously there could be more)

1 Medium
2 Surfers
1 Shaman (same person by chance was resurrected, then killed again)
2 cult leaders
2 cult assassins
2 cult bodyguards
1 good killer
2 mad scientists

The shaman, the resurrect, both scientists, 1 bodyguard and 1 cult leader have been killed.

So I think at least 8 of 13 have roles.

Dude.

 

Yeah but why again? 2 baths in a row? After he was nearly killed the first time? #askingfortrouble

 

See my posts above. I think there are 3 assassins plus the holy man who kills with the holy arrow.

 

Couldn't they be the same person using different weapons?

 

but you suggested one was a townie dude right? Wouldn't that be the 'good killer'

 

Probably 1 town and 2 cult, but they all come up as "assassins" in Milk's reports

2 cult assassins, 1 town assassin, 1 holy man = 4 killers total not 3 afcftw says

 

Looking at that list, only five of the thirteen are town. Is that realistic?

#cawabunga

 

Do we know that all town have roles though?

 

They are just the roles we are assuming are in play - there could also be an investigator etc.... Just trying to get all the info out in the open so things are as clear as possible dude!

 

I'm gonna have to go back and re-check the nightfall reports! Rad!

 

Milk said before the game started that most people will have some sort of role so there won't be many none roles. Maybe that is why he created these surfer roles too, to fill it up?

dude

 

Yeah, I'd say there are more which is why I was questioning there only being five town roles listed. As you've just said, there is no investigator in that list and I'd be surprised if we didn't have one if not two.

cawabunga

 

I think there is a strong chance that some roles could be task based though, so not like normal roles. As in we may not see what role people are performing until a specific event happens, unlike the traditional killer, investigator, doctor roles.