Mafia XI - An Unknown Evil -GAMEOVER Town/Anarchist Victory!

Thank you dude. It told me what I wanted to know.

 

Yep because naturally when you have a town role and you get asked to public ally reveal everything you just spill your beans for everyone to see to make sure the bad guys have as much info as possible... Ffs dude...

We are so obviously not bad guys... What kind of **** bad guy role has to immediately draw attention to themself?

 

So did everyone else several times dude. We're not going to spend an eternity repeating things!

 

Stop? So afc should just accept death and I should allow a known innocent to die? Seriously dude?

 

Makes me even more sure obi is innocent

Dude.

 

Pretty sure bodanki (?) had a role where he had to collect as many votes as possible for himself as he could only kill people that voted for him? Can't remember whether he was good, bad or neutral but its the same concept. I actually think it was your game

And the first sentence would make sense, had Gerrez not revealed almost everything about your roles and labelled you as evil on the first day of the game...

 

Well, it tells us JPF and Obi weren't on the same team. Not what I was thinking though dude

 

At the minute I agree that the four in the frame are AFC, Gerrez, Lucaas and ACS.

Of those ACS should be the most likely to be still evil. I would be very surprised if he came back as good. However, it's not impossible. The downside of voting for ACS is that he says he can't be lynched and if so that would be a wasted lynching that would teach us nothing. However, unlike what some others have claimed, this inability to be lynched hasn't been confirmed. It could be a ruse. Milk has bot confirmed that he can't be lynched. ACS should at least be on the list of those to be investigated though.

Lucaas having a bodyguard and/or being protected is another reason to be suspicious of someone. Why would he have been chosen for protection based on yesterday's play? I see only three feasible possibilities. He is part of a team and it was a pre-arranged protection as he seemed the most likely to be targeted. He has a role that comes with protection automatically (could be good or bad). He is the doctor role and chose to protect himself. He is an obvious target for suspicion and also definitely worth investigating. Game play doesn't particularly give away one side or the other though to me.

AFC/Gerrez - we have spoken ad infinitum about these. Nothing has really changed. Have looked suspicious from the start and have had inconsistent stories. However, that may be down to their role. They are the most obvious choice but I don't think we should kill both under any circumstances. If the role is true then is it perhaps an important role? High risk for high reward?

We need to decide if we want a single lynch candidate or a combination. Spreading votes increases the risk of vote changes. Not spreading reduces the potential to learn - though in a headfuck game you can't always read into confused actions.

 

Gerrez has revealed most of the stuff about our role, not 100% everything, but most of it has ended up having to be spelt out rather than people recognising how ridiculous it would be if we were bad guys lol. And we have already explained the going for each other bit ovr and over again.... Your just repeating points that have been answered! Mondo!

 

ok so i am going to just do what i should have done yesterday

I probably pussied out by going no lynch truthfully

AFC

we are losing a day because of it but you lot could have ****ing fixed it last night! I think there's enough other info we could have probed tonight that is only getting half looked at and we are going to slide into the half way point of the game by milks timetable with too many dangers on the prowl now.

 

I think I see what you're seeing. It sort of helps. IF you were telling the truth then it narrows something down a lot.

 

And none of that would have happened had people not jumped to a instant guilty conclusion once the surfer words had been picked up on. By you I believe but you only got three of them, I think you missed gnarly?

 

It was the word "mondo", because I thought you were just taking the piss out of Obi Wan

 

Why is IBWT so quiet? Getting a bad guy read from him in this game tbh.

Dude.

 

AFC 7 Tennis, ACS, Tobes, Neville, IBWT, lucaaas, mito
LUCAAAS 3 RHC, AFC, Valley
Tobes 1 Mikey
ACS 2 Obi, Astro

4 to vote

 

Well if you're seeing it then the town are ****ed with you being a dodgy shubie

 

I think it makes zero sense to bring a guy back in to another team.

I think that gives volumes of info on the nature of this game. There are a few teams.

I think ACS is just spinning a line. I don't see any reason to add a second unlynchable person. why?

simply this. if someone says "- One individual in the game is immune to lynching. If he is picked to be lynched, he will be lynched as normal but will not die." at the outset this means to me ONE not one plus another and not only unlynchable but btw indestrucable meaning no-one else can kill him too.

I think he's just thrown that out there as a defence.... is that an issue in itself? nope. I don't think so.

There is one issue. Milk cannot predict who will be FIRST to die..... remember the ORDER OF NIGHT. the lynch was told to us FIRST. therefore how could milk say ok the person we wildly pick to die in a lynch will them over to another team and bascially reveal all to that team.

 

The hell is a shubie But I'm not going to reveal what it is because ultimately I am town and I don't want to make things easy for the others in the game

 

Credit to Milk this game is mind boggling. It's like trying to work out a couple of mad scientists doing an experiment

 

Ok so mito has jumped on the bandwagon.

Final reveal: I've tried to hint at it without actually saying it as it makes us obvious targets for the bad guys, but your going to kill me anyway. The wording of our PM suggested there is an important reason for our role existing, it sounds to me like later in the game there is a reason to have us around. Our role is clearly more than just being obvious cannon fodder ffs dudes.

If you kill me, the bad guys whack gerrez and that could be a major town **** up.

I don't expect to be saved now as clearly there are bad guys voting for me who won't move and the townies will be to indecisive to move away to another target. But your doing the bad guys work for the,.

well it's been good fun in this role! hopefully some of you see some sense but I'm not holding my breathe haha