Mafia XI - An Unknown Evil -GAMEOVER Town/Anarchist Victory!

Was anything I said in that comment wrong?

Dude

 

ALIVE AT THE BEGINNING OF DAY 1: (listed in the order that they signed up - mondo)

RHC - has actually been more active than normal but his posts seem the same as always, don't think he is a bad guy, but that's a hunch
Mito - has pushed the afc/gerrez thing but has also posted some very useful posts and highlighted key game events, we need people like this in the town. Not sure but I wouldn't kill him, keep him around.
Gerrez - 100% known innocent! he has the same role as me, we are important for the town, don't kill us both ffs.
JudeanPF High Priest of the Occult Brotherhood of the Skull - dead, but interesting the wording of his death, I think his teammates know there own roles but don't know who there teammates are.
astro - hasn't actually contributed much of use but has posted fairly often, this is usually how suspicious people play, be noticed but don't help or draw attention. One to watch.
LHTNeville - along with lucaas suggested early on that acs would be on a third team, could be distancing themselves, BT nothing concrete, I keep changing my mind on him but am suspicious.
Tobes - towns who thinks he is being clever but has it wrong? Or bad guy working with IBWT? Both took the same stance to me and gerrez story at the start, saying we weren't bad guys but have since gone for us. Tobes also suggesting a plan to kill two townies instead of a way to test our roles.
Bod - too quiet, would normally be more involved, investigate target maybe.
Style - early activity, has since gone quiet, did seem to be siding with some of the newkie people early, suspicious!
AFC - innocent. Town role.
Lucaas - had been involved in leading the group onto easy targets, think he might be guilty but I always do even when he isn't so... Lol
Obi Wan - initially I thought he was a bad guy jumping on me and gerrez surfer words but his posts since have given me a strong townie read. Leaning towards innocent.
IBWT - see Tobes. Also voted for me when I'm already way out in front, possibly trying to make sure there isn't room for town to change there minds today.
Valley Grad - early on I was pretty sure he was a bad guy but as the game goes on I'm actually leaning towards him being innocent.
A chip shop Was Shaman of Baphomet. Resurrected. - I like Tobes idea that the golden arrow made him a good guy on the team of the good assassin. Before he said that I was thinking maybe we should kill acs, but now I'm thinking investigate him.
Tennisball - leaning towards innocent, but I want to hear more from him.
Magic- has he even posted?
Mikey - got a suspicious read on him, not sure why but he's coming across as a bad guy trying to go under the radar.

 

AFC 5 Tennis, ACS, Tobes, Neville, IBWT
LUCAAAS 1 RHC
Tobes 3 AFC, Valley, Mikey
ACS 1 Obi

7 to vote

 

a.k.a. I asked you why not kill you tonight if you'll still be suspicious tomorrow, and you completely swerved the question

#onetowatch

 

I haven't swerved a question, look how long my post is, you clearly posted the question while I was typing you tit

When the medium or an investigator comes out I expect myself and gerrez will become two known innocents and the town will have a decent size block of people. We are important to the town in a way that will be revealed at some unknown time, it wasn't revealed even to us. As far as our side task goes when one of us dies it'll be over, the only effect on the town at that point will be less innocent people and less innocent people who 100% know about another innocent person.

#rad

 

agree with most of that which means its total bollox

Thing with Tobes is, when he's been guilty in the past he is aggressive when accused like he has been yesterday and today BUT he also tends to disappear when not being questioned or poked etc, he's not really done the latter bit.

Magic has made one comment so far I believe. If it is more than one then it is certainly not more the two or three. He is regularly quiet in these games and I know from previously being on a mafia team with him that he prefers to stay in the background as its the perfect cover for him, he has a reputation for not commenting.

#mondo

 

So how come @Gerrez said you are evil? #sortyourstoryout

 

So I am looking at Lucaaaas posts:

One think i will say is he touched on a few things but none over suspect. The first thing i want to point out is he picked up on Obi asking about the surfer talk and me using it first and he asked me about it. I want to make sure i'm open with all and point that out.

Items:

1. IBWT vote and discussion. Don't see much there

2. He was first to count the number of gerrez surfer terms.

3. He was questioning why a tie vote.

4. look at about 5pm yesterday. page 16, 301 onwards. Valley called on him for being on to obi and gerrez. Lucaaas replied to Valley then tagged JPF saying i see what you did there.... post 313.

5. around 6pm he question afc about gerrez claims and at post 380 he votes for AFC.

6. he questions me about my first use of the word dud on page 3 at 6:53pm

7. he continued to question both gerrez and afc


....

then look at final vote table. lucaaas is the one who started the vote for AFC and he was still on him at end.

from all that who would hit him and who would defend him... The defense side is hardest to narrow down as someone had to see something else that suggested lucaaas was in danger.

 

Yeh tbh Tobes style of aggressive play makes me suspicious of him all the time and I went for him in a previous game and killed him when he was innocent lol.

A couple of his posts since going mental at us have actually made me reconsider my position on him and think he is just a townie who got it wrong. #notsure #mondo

 

Because we are rival surfers and whilst both knowing the other is innocent we can't both win, only one of us can win the game. Early on we both made plays to get the other killed as we would then become the towns known innocent and have a chance to win #selfish

We then started to play for the town, I.e. Try and show we are actually both innocent townies.

#rad

 

You need to read back astro, I've explained it several times over (I was being selfish on my death bed) and its pretty much destroyed day two. Most have more or less agreed to move on so we can discuss other things rather than wasting another day.

#mondo

 

Yes, this is what I was referring to.
Twice now he has acted overly aggressive and defensive, which has tweaked my suspicion, and both times when we lynched him, he turned out to be innocent.

Not saying he is innocent in this case, just that it is true to his normal style.
But he had a go at me for defending him, so you can kill the **** for all i care

 

Valley as been defending AFC and I since we revealed our roles. He did similar in the last game; cling to a known (or probably known) innocent in order to make himself look innocent. There is a possibility that Valley knows we are innocent of course but if that is the case then the town is ****ed

#mondo

 

Summary of theories:

1. Derek is alive
2. Surf nazis must die and afcftw seems the dodgiest of the two
3. Lucaaas is a don with a bodyguard
4. ACS is part of a vampire army

 

He did the same in the geordie game and turned out to be a bad guy. difference being, he stayed in the background in that game and only posted when questioned.

#cawabunga

 

So you fingered a known innocent as evil in an unknown evil game

 

Milk confirmed you can vote and can be lynched, if I remember correctly #busted

 

I'm thinking your a bad guy! #feelings
#mondo

 

huh huh, you said "fingered"