Mafia XI - An Unknown Evil -GAMEOVER Town/Anarchist Victory!

I've said Gerrez specifically, because look at his behaviour. We pointed towards his suspicious use of quite weird words and he basically threw the towel in as mito said and hasn't even bothered putting a reasonable defence in. If he did maybe I would change my vote but at the moment it seems like we've nailed him?

 

Least some other dude spotted it

 

AFC

 

So what does this challenge consist of? And what happens to the winners & losers of the challenge?

 

Hang on... Why wouldn't the medium reveal himself? Can't be lynched and the evil team/s can apparently use him to win? Why would they kill him? Seems more likely we should expend his usefulness then tactically push him off a cliff

 

Anyone that defends themselves just digs a bigger hole.

What would you like me to say? Already said I have a townie role, already given you the info I have AND given you a known player/role.

#mondo

 

Because when I done it, I ****ed everything up

 

Four words to say (mondo, bodacious, dude & gnarly) to say in every comment. Failure to do so (allowed two withput per day) results in death. The one with more comments gets rewarded (not giving that bit away just yet)

Ignore those words and you'll see I've been as normal as I normally am

 

Hmmm. I looked at the posts. This checks out. We must decide quickly lads, and by quick I mean within the next hour, whether we take this at face-value or not!

It makes Obi's role suspicious.

 

I can buy that bit and it fits in with past games of having tasks and rewards. Certainly given us something to think about. However, I don't understand why you would be given an evil name for a start, and then why you would not vote for that person at any point to at least see if anybody else voted for them. I voted for AFC this morning to try and get a reaction from a quiet player and nobody joined me.

Also, why has AFC not at least tried to post more as presumably he would have been told the same information (from the opposite point of view) if this was the case. The one saving grace is that AFC did vote for you, so that bit ties in - but also means that you must have been allowed to vote for each other.

One last point, if you are at the stage of throwing in the towel, why not share more about your role - or are you prohibited from doing that?

 

the medium should not reveal at all.... no way!

JPF you are making a huge assumption that he cannot be lynched. we only know that milk has set this up and if he wanted it hidden why would it be the case that if the medium he just came out and told us all the roles that the town would win.

There has to be something else at play with the medium and the evil. It does say he can be used but we don't know how he can be used

the very best way to deny the evil team the use of the medium is for them not to know who he is.

therefore i say medium do not reveal yourself.

 

none of this adds up. my vote stands.

 

1. It strikes me as suspicious that Milk would reveal the role of an opposing player to Gerrez before the start of the game.
2. Why would milk put one of the least active mafia posters against one of the most active posters in a battle of # of posts (on a bank holiday) which seems incredibly unfair and weighted in your (Gerrez's) favour. That's not normally how Milk makes his rules.
3. Why would there be an exception for 2 posts, seems like a silly number? Or is that the amount of posts you had made without those words in before you made the excuse up?

 

Both surfers need to be alive to get the reward. The losing surfer dude gets nothing.

 

I think we need to see AFC's opinion before we make a final group decision at least?

 

JPF has behaved suspicious with his posts today.

 

AFC least active...? Give your head a shake dude

 

At the start of this i thought we'd have to roll the dice on the two but gerrez is far more dodgy than Obi as of now.. obi has not even had to speak up which says to me gerrez has really got caught out. I can't believe the tale sorry.. I said ham fisted earlier but it must be just that.

 

Said earlier that obviously some mission they're on and if they were guilty would it be that obvious? Im not so sure...

 

He's made one comment all day. The way you've been pushing me as been suspicious as hell so I'm sure you'll be giving him nudge now anyway dude