Mafia XI - An Unknown Evil -GAMEOVER Town/Anarchist Victory!

A point well made. Obi must die whatever happens!

 

They don't both die if there's a tie though, so I'm not sure what you're saying here

 

They might both die. Or it might just be one. There is a procedure I follow for determining who dies in a tie. It could result in one person or everyone in the tie dying.

 

So you are not the medium...

The rules state only a "non-random" decision will be made in the event of a tie which can result in multiple lynch victims.

 

Ok.... so it seems this is coming to a head rapidly now. there's enough stuff out of gerrez to lynch him here. yeah there could be some mission but i've always said in other games go for what is in front of you.

Gerrez.

 

IBWT 1 Magic
TENNIS 1 Style
MIKEY 1 Tennis
No Lynch 1 Tobes
GERREZ 4 AFC, Neville, Lucaaas, MITO
RHC 1 Astro
OBI 3 JPF, ACS, Gerrez

Not Voted 6 RHC, bodanki, Obi, IBWT, valley, Mikey

 

No I doubt Milk would trust me with such an important role anyway

Especially when I don't even read the rules.

 

Sure, if you want to be a ******ed dude lol

Can't believe how stupid you guys are. How many times you seen me play now?

 

Less hope, I believe you are certainly the medium. Please confirm, as that means lucaaas is evil.

 

Bodacious voting

Gerrez

 

you've acted strange in this one... dunno whats going on but hey at least i can say i got the teflon don once eh?

 

Are you voting for yourself?

 

I think there is a lot of sense in this idea. Another benefit would be they have the option of saving one of them with late vote switches but not both. However, playing devil's advocate, they could choose to go either way and we wouldn't know which of them they would save. IF we have a killing role in our team - which is a possibility given that the game is set to end within 5 days - if one was out on their own then the other could be targeted. The flip side of that coin is that we don't know if they would have a protection role.

I would lean towards your suggestion of putting them in a tie, but what do others think?

 

he has in last 3 games.......

I've counted it.

 

I think it would be a mistake to confirm or deny that at this point. That DOES NOT mean that I am claiming to be the medium. Personally, I think the best tactic would have been for the medium to lie low until they saw a point in the game that was advantageous to become more visible (having all of the rules in front of them). The medium is the most important role for us in this game. The medium MUST NOT be known yet. If 3 or 4 people might be suspected of being the medium then so bit it - I think that helps.

 

I agree. If we choose Gerrez, as looks inevitable, then obi must be killed if we have the power to amongst us. If they are proved innocent, no idea where we go after :/

 

I don't know what to make of Gerrez and Obi Wan with their strange surfer talk.

At first I thought they must need to say certain words to gain an ability, say investigations or something, so thought they might be town roles like the masons or cop/detective (especially after Milk's post that some people have teammates but can't chat on QT boards until a later stage. I guessed it would be masons as I suspect the evil teams would communicate from day 1 but town teams like masons or cop/detective only later).

But they haven't really given much of a defense of themselves, I doubted they would act that obviously if they were an evil team so was leaning towards a town team, but now their lack of a credible defense makes it seem like they're non-town.

I stand by what I said earlier and I don't think a tied vote is a good idea, I'd rather lynch just one and if he is guilty we lynch the other tomorrow. Tying the lynch could kill 2 innocents, so I vote Gerrez. I understand why some people are saying lets put both up and maybe kill both, but unless we know they're evil I don't want to risk it, we can't afford to kill 2 town roles if we get this wrong. Gerrez and Obi Wan you need to talk up if you have town roles, if you're looking guilty close to the deadline then a tied vote may be a decent idea.

 

The medium seems immortal, at least in lynching. I do not want to risk them being killed randomly without knowing what they know, as what they know gives us the edge. I agree that it would be best if they announced themselves later, however, on balance of probability it is likely 2 of mito, lucaaas and yourself are evil and the other is the medium, with it being between yourself and lucaaas mainly as mito only really noticed after it has been mentioned.

 

How does it?

 

There are two people in this game that know who I am; the medium and AFC!

Already accepted death dudes