Off Topic Mafia VIII - Mafia vs Zombies

I've no bother voting to split this. Who is on?

 

I know any attempt at influencing now is going to be automatically suspected but so be it, needs to be done, I don't think Nolberto should be in the vote. If he's innocent (and we have no real reason to suspect he's not other than inactivity) and loses the coinflip we will learn almost nothing, at least if Astro or Valley are town, which I'm starting to fear they are, then we will be able to garner information from what they have done this game and who has aligned with/against them.

 

Doesn't look good when the the only other known innocent is going against the town cop. Kind of makes it open season for him to lose his influence round upon round. This I why I suggested sorting it with him when we actually had time.

 

I know, i was expecting it from a few people to be honest the minute you make any alteration to the plan no matter how logical people imediately assume you must be mafia or something! That's why i tried to explain my thinking, i realise not everyone will agree though...

 

Anyone got current vote table?

I've not voted but wondering if I pile onto Astro/Valley is there someone else to pile on the other to put them into a 2 way coin toss?

 

Late voting from Mafia?

 

I

I'll match the opposite

 

Or someone could just drop off nolberto...

 

This is the problem I have with it.

Its just the fact that Valley & Astro were both put up for not following Bobby's voting orders but now we've got another 2 people suggesting we do the same again. Does that mean that you & Mikey are 2 town people that are going to be viewed with suspicion for changing the vote at last minute if Astro or Valley are lynched and innocent? And we could be wasting ANOTHER day chasing after you and tennis who could potentially be innocents (only you know if you are, or not).

I'm all up for getting people who are more deserving and suspicious up for the lynch but if it costs us another day of pointless scapegoating then it isn't worth it for us as a town.

 

I always like to have a quite one in the vote just to see what happens... problem is 2 things can happen and could mean either.

No one chirps up in which case, they might be innocent...

Or someone chirps up like Tennis has done and could mean he's trying to get the quiet one out of the coin toss because they are team mates... or he sees no one is too concerned about him so thinks he must not be mafia and therefor thinks best tog et him out the vote..


#mindfuck

 

Good point

 

you are all sitting back then?

a) when did bobby say it 100% had to be a tie

b) when is it ok for everyone to sit back and let the mafia have it this easy

c) what will you really learn bar get the day over with and take a look when the real data comes in... nothing.

we might we well lucky of course but if valley or astro or even nobby are guilty theres a chance here

its 6 from 14 are bad to select 3 for whatever reason and not one are inncoent.. well the odds are 8/14*7/13*6/12 right? 15% that all 3 are innocent expect the selction was done with suspects

 

4 mins to go

 

Sod it I'm going early...totally random...

Valley

 

Valley: 5 votes Astro, Obi, tobes, tennis, Nolberto
Astro: 4 vote by gerrez, funky, RHC, mikey
Nolberto: 4 vote by bobby, neville, valley, lucaaaas

 

Lie.

My entire argument last night was to make sure Bobby's orders were followed.

Valley acted to undermine the coinflip as much as he could.

If don't see that you simply aren't paying attention to what happened last night.

 

I can see this getting ugly.

 

Two minute warning...

 

every post ive made is to try and get something to occur... nothing happening at lynch time = waste.... i'm sitting back to watch