Off Topic Mafia VIII - Mafia vs Zombies

Obviously you didn't play when I was Mafia, hence why I'm always a suspect now.

 

Bobby didnt pick 3. Based on day 1's activity many posters found valley and astro to be suspicious, hence them being in the vote. We also wanted to target some of the quieter posters but as there were so many it was a scattergun approach, so bobby as the cop picked one; nolberto. That's how the three got picked essentially.

 

50 mins to go.

All please look at the votes on this tomorrow.

I've no clue really.

Nothing really occurred here and it looks like two guys have continued an arguementioned from day one and it's got them to the top of the pile and the bad guys are distributed nicely to avoid suspicion and don't have to do anything.


If either have a role you've a choice ride the vote like acs or make a play. It's entirely up to you.

 

"Activity"

Nice general word

But ignores the actual nature of the activity

Frankly if you can't see Valley's plan with his voting pattern you deserve to die

 

If bobby picked me to make up the 3 from the quiet ones, fair do's ...wasting a lot of votes tho ..confused and bewildered that i am...you all kinda know Swarbs wouldn't throw me in the deep end ( maybe he is a complete and utter bastard and would, mind)

Me a innocent townie.

 

With so many playing there is always, early doors, too much space to hide.

Hopefully we get info tomorrow by investigator (?) journalist (?) and with initial suspicions from first 2 days should begin to show a direction to follow.

First 2 days are speculation and guesswork save for any rank bad play.

 

Everyone is in "justify the current situation because I am not at risk" mode

No one is actually looking at what happened last night any more

Valley is by far the stand out suspect but who cares we have a coinflip let's protect it!

 

I've really wound you up haven't I

 

Must say judging by the comments tonight i dont think we should keep the 3 way, i think it should be either astro getting lynched or astro and valley tied in a 2 way. If nolberto gets lynched it doesnt resolve the doubts about those two, regardless of what nolberto ends up being.

A tied vote is meant to generate debate or movement, and we've seen plenty from astro and a fair bit from valley. I dont know what you guys think but a coin toss is a cop out when you dont want to make a decision, if we think one or two out of the three look more guilty than the others then they should be lynched. There's no reason to keep the three way just because that's what we decided earlier.

My first choice would be to lynch astro, second choice would be a tie between astro & valley. I know we could have it wrong and they could both be town, but we need to make a call and not just rely on cointosses to make our decisions for us. Basically my thoughts are astro looks more guilty than valley, and nolberto is a long way behind those two. Thoughts?

 

Tomorrow should see at least 2 killed and another bite plus I hope Bobby will have info to share as in Bobby will knoe if he has a bad guy or a good guy and steer a bit more.

You cannot trust me the same way if I live as I might get bit

 

No you haven't done anything but play a very poor game with obvious last minute attempts to change the voting

The annoying people are all the others who haven't paid a single ****ing second of attention to it

 

All remember someone out there can be instructed to vote by sz. There might be a late switch and remember it's hard to say if it's to save one or just get the person lynched.

The person can align with town or go with zombie.

 

Meltdown

 

Question

Does this mean Tennisball is the Super Zombie and wants to increase the chances of Valley or Astro being lynched so that they can be converted into full zombies?

 

Feel should keep 3 way.

1. Too late to try and orchestrate 2 way.

2. Position between Astro and Valley may be resolved anyway.

3. Last minute changes can hide voting patterns if it's agreed to change.

 

This isn't sitting right with me, think the mafia are sitting comfortably out of the crosshairs with the way things are going, but probably too late to really change now so we'll see.

 

4 votes still outstanding though (according to last vote table pg 51 ish) ..including mine..so I'm gonna mess the stalemate up

 

I'm not the SZ lucaaas. What I'm saying is logical, just about every person on here suspects either valley or astro or both of them, i havent seen a single person say they suspect nolberto.

I just don't see the point in keeping the 3 way, what if nolberto is killed... Does that make astro & valley innocent, or guilty? We're back to today's situation again.

How about being constructive rather than just throwing out accusations the minute someone tries to be constructive?

Edit: the only way SZ wins is by staying under the radar for ages, I've hardly done that have i? SZ would get his infected person to vote to mess up the tie, and then get lynched as a result & turn into a zombie. No SZ with any sense would make such an obvious play to get a potentially infected person lynched. Detective or journo are welcome to investigate me tonight.

 

Sorry. It's just my default mafia setting.

 

Damn you, that's not very British of you or sporting. One for the team and all that.