Off Topic Mafia VIII - Mafia vs Zombies

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
Sir Tennisball said:
I'd like some of the quieter posters put under pressure but maybe that's a tactic for tomorrow, it's a bit late now to add something like that into the mix.

It seems like there are several suspicious characters out there and many of us are thinking along the same lines.
Astro is on 4 votes so I'll vote Valley to tie it up. Not a fan of getting Gerrez in the mix today as I believe there was too little reaction yesterday for one of the three in the vote to be mafia, only if Valley is mafia would I look at the Valley/Gerrez link again.

I think we need to have a look at these two who seem to be viewed as the most suspicious by numerous people and see what happens. Tomorrow I'd like to put some new people under the microscope as they've been flying under the radar...
Click to expand...

Can't say I'm overly keen on that middle paragraph since it names me <laugh> I agree that Valley seems to be acting dodgy (although that's normal) and if that is proven then it seems I'm ****ed in your opinion. I think people will probably say the same if Astro is proven innocent since I've voted and argued with him now.

I don't think there is much to go on but again, and like I said earlier, the less active players are escaping again. There are sixteen players left, two are known innocents (Bobby and MITO) and seven bad guys; 4 Mafia, SK, SZ & the infected (assuming the infected and Mafia recruit can't be the same person:huh:) So, that is potentially 9 vs 7 if my calculations are correct? (although if we kill the SZ then the infected remains a townie) that presents a 50:50 chance of success/failure (we're not going to vote Bobby or MITO so its effectively 7vs7) so we'd be pretty ****ing unlucky not to get a bad guy in the coin toss today IMO so why not chuck some less actives in there to see what happens?
 
Gerrez said:
Can't say I'm overly keen on that middle paragraph since it names me <laugh> I agree that Valley seems to be acting dodgy (although that's normal) and if that is proven then it seems I'm ****ed in your opinion. I think people will probably say the same if Astro is proven innocent since I've voted and argued with him now.

I don't think there is much to go on but again, and like I said earlier, the less active players are escaping again. There are sixteen players left, two are known innocents (Bobby and MITO) and seven bad guys; 4 Mafia, SK, SZ & the infected (assuming the infected and Mafia recruit can't be the same person:huh:) So, that is potentially 9 vs 7 if my calculations are correct? (although if we kill the SZ then the infected remains a townie) got to be pretty ****ing unlucky not to get a bad guy in the coin toss today IMO so why not chuck some less actives in there to see what happens?
Click to expand...

Cant argue with that too much about non actives but at the moment it's 2 horse race. I think if we were to do that, Bobby would need to pick 1 name to throw into the mix and do it early enough that it gives us a chance to see if anyone reacts.

I kind of backed you yesterday given you didn't change your vote.. However I do know that's how you play, Even if you have a role so don't think can read into that too much.

Did anyone else try and save you is the main question...
 
InBiscanWeTrust said:
Cant argue with that too much about non actives but at the moment it's 2 horse race. I think if we were to do that, Bobby would need to pick 1 name to throw into the mix and do it early enough that it gives us a chance to see if anyone reacts.

I kind of backed you yesterday given you didn't change your vote.. However I do know that's how you play, Even if you have a role so don't think can read into that too much.

Did anyone else try and save you is the main question...
Click to expand...

Yep, suspected you would say that at some stage. I have a reputation for sitting tight afterall. But as you said, i could have blamed the confusion and saved myself without worry of a backlash. it would have been Bod's fault for his late wrong switch.
 
afcftw said:
RHC: 1 vote by Neville
Valley: 3 votes Astro, Obi, Tobes
Neville: 1 vote by RHC
Astro: 4 votes by gerrez, funky, RHC, Valley
Gerrez: 1 vote by mikey

I think that's correct. Since swarbs said he is off for a while I figured I'd post a table or two for him in the meantime.
Click to expand...

According to that, I've voted for two <yikes> I changed from Neville to Astro <ok>
 
so my understanding right now is this:

the town on its town as the active players are discussing targets off what happened yesterday. Valley and astro so far are up for lynch.

There is an infected player out there. this person will be directed who to vote for via pm. they might already have voted or pop up late but the penalty for not doing so is their head explodes. I THINK this means they activate as a known rambling zombie who bites. If we lynch him he rambles too.

he could be anyone. it might be resisted as mafia it might not

There is a super zombie. he will bite again

There are 4 mafia, again they may be recruiting badly and have sk or zombie in their side now but probably not. thats 4 votes to direct things here when only one is needed to swing a tie. why did they kill afc???

Mafia can kill tonight. then we must figure out if they get another bullet they have one now.

Mafia can hack, steal cash or steal bullets tonight. we won't know which happens

The serial killer will kill again tonight, last night they killed bod... WHY?


There is a detective. we don't know if they are good or bad and bobby should now be talking to him. I hope so but we've not seen bobby. this person will be investigating. DO NOT TELL US WHO. Bobby can tell us the results. these should be taken with a pinch of salt but only the mafia recruited so its a hopefully town role still

there is a journalist not sure when paper is out, not sure if paper came from journalist. make it more clear he can be hacked but not on consecutive nights. tonight is at risk

virologist can find zombies. there is NO MORE ARMY RECRUIT. its unlikely he will get info yet. only 2 targets

The hunter still has 3 bullets. he can kill for the town or steal bullets. he should shoot someone

The COP. the cop can lock up. he cannot zombie hunt yet. bobby needs to decide who to lock up and not tell anyone.

Masons: did not recruit. do not recruit me. I am totally obvious target to die or be bitten. you need to get on with it. tomorrow the changes of recruiting a bad guy will be higher than a good guy.

......................................

I would hope that tomorrow bobby will have a lead. something from the detective. The journalist can be hacked but that could have more info. We will see i think 2 kills tonight... remember the role table. please for the love of god those who ignored me last time take it on and fill it out.

there should be 13 left tomorrow with 2 infecteds, 3 or 4 mafia
 
@moreinjuredthanowen

this was a response to you from Swarbs...

Swarbs said:
This is true, and I did have a long think about this last night. Ultimately I know I said I would try to make all the rules open, but this is one area I believe there has to be some grey areas, else the hacking power will be pretty useless.

I have changed it so the town will be notified if the police station is broken into, as this would be an important change. But yes, you will not know exactly how much money is stolen at first, although you will be able to work this out based on finding when the newspaper was hacked.

I think this is the most balanced way to do it.
Click to expand...
 
ValleyGraduate12 said:
Tobes is very quiet today. Other than posting his vote on me.
Click to expand...
I said last night I'd be out until after lunch. I came back read umpteen pages of muddled mess, gave my opinion and then voted for you.

There's not been anything to add since, as nothing I've seen has altered my initial opinion.
 
  • Like
Reactions: astro
RHC: 1 vote by Neville
Valley: 4 votes Astro, Obi, tobes, tennis
Astro: 4 vote by gerrez, funky, RHC, valley
Gerrez: 1 vote by mikey

yet to vote: IBWT, MITO, Lucaaas, Sebb, Bobby, Nolberto

thats my count.

still this i think
 
Astro and Valley. its coming up to home time so i suggest you make some effort of defending yourselves shortly please.
 
moreinjuredthanowen said:
RHC: 1 vote by Neville
Valley: 4 votes Astro, Obi, tobes, tennis
Astro: 4 vote by gerrez, funky, RHC, valley
Gerrez: 1 vote by mikey

yet to vote: IBWT, MITO, Lucaaas, Sebb, Bobby, Nolberto

thats my count.

still this i think
Click to expand...

I said couple pages back happy to vote on one of Astro or valley but someone needs to counter that if we're sticking with them in a coin toss.

Youge he not voted either it seems to happy to split with me? Or are you keeping yours up your sleeve for something?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom
Back