Off Topic Mafia VIII - Mafia vs Zombies

Worth pointing out that I saw Bobby's suggestion straight away and made comment pointing out that I was already voting for one of the three (albeit, for myself)

 

Only been one vote from what I gather which is less hope voting for RHC...

Bobby post seems to suggest he doesn't want to lead the town today which is fair enough, means we need to look for some info from last round.

I think Astro mentioned valley for being suspicious and RHC / gerrez for their wording... Not much to go on for them 3 other than that but then do we have any more on anyone else?

be good to hear some ideas from others like mikey, tennis who usually have some thoughts.

Also so still a quieter couple that have gone by without adding much, be good to hear from them today

 

Lucas, Sebb, nolberto have been quiet I think... Not saying that's bad or suspicious, especially as Lucas tends to be quieter thought games anyway, but be good to hear thoughts from you guys?

 

Also anyone jumping immediately on bonus ideas is suspicious to me, it's to easy to get on board the known innocent and then go back and say 'well I did exactly what the innocent told me to do'

nothing wrong with questioning it in my opinion, that's potentially less suspicious than just blindly following, especially if the 3 he selected were all innocents or some were sz or sk as the mafia would be happy with it.

 

Yep, It's the army's first action tonight as they didn't know there was a zombie problem night one.

 

Yes

 

Maybe put all the quiet ones into a coinflip and see what comes of it

 

Can i ask about the newpaper.

there are 3 lines

army comes to twon makes sense i suppose

Is any of the rest sensible?

death follows like a shadow... does it mean anything to anyone?

save us from ourselves.. could refer to day 1 town kills.

 

early votes after full read back

RHC: 1 vote by: Neville
Valley 1 vote by: astro

only acs voted last night and he was dead so as far as i can tell thats where we are.

 

Like I posted earlier, I might be being too literal but we lynched one of the army who is now dead.

agree about the last line

 

I agree with bobby.

There are several not venturing their ideas who were on before the vote yesterday, during the day yesterday and after the results.

Lets hear their theories.

 

dunno we lynch him which doesn't suggest shadow. shadow seems to be a word chosen.

Again I've said it as gamemaster to people i set up as journos... don't be cryptic with paper. it might be obvious to you after you did it but yuo'll be lucky to get any real info over. that is if the journo actually wrote it and its not just prepped stuff. the journo can see if someone is mafia or not. they should be really saying X is mafia or x is not mafia in the paper.

I am seriously hoping the string of symbols is some code to prove the info.

death follows like a shadow could refer to the hitman! I dunno. have to park it.

 

We seem to have 3 names being mentioned namely

Gerrez

Valley

RHC.

No real info out at present save strange voting late last night.

An option is to go for another 3 up and see how it develops during the day. Peoples thoughts.

 

I vote Neville

 

Can't say I have much to say to be honest, few people have been suspicious but seems plenty of people leave their brains at the door when they play mafia especially when town so I don't know exactly what to make of it. Didn't get to make any notes yesterday as didn't have time so going back and doing them at the moment, currently on page 8... Be back in a few hours.

 

Could mean the killers still have bullets and are still at large which we already know.

 

I tried to ask when the paper was written rather than published.

If it was written before nightfall and before they had their investigation, then the journo wouldn't have had any info so we can just ignore... If it was after nightfall and was a really quick turnaround then they may have got some info and therefor it might mean something

 

Death follows in the shadows.

could it mean there is a killer in the shadows... Ie, someone who is being quiet and not saying much?

 

Still reading through and updating my notes as I only make notes at work (benefit of having my own office, bad luck to you open plan guys)!

I'll happily give my thoughts later but like mito I'm wary of putting my suspicions out there too early.

If we suspect scum then we end up getting killed, and scum are wary of incriminating themselves. If we get it wrong and suspect innocents then scum just keep quiet and go along with it, and few other people give their opinions so we learn very little.

I'd like to hear some other players' views so it's not just the same people with strategies every day.

 

I agree, I've tried to work out the Greek symbols but I reckon it's to prove his identity in case he's up for lynch or someone else claims the role.

It's probably a letter replacement code where Alpha is one letter, Beta another letter etc.