Off Topic Mafia VIII - Mafia vs Zombies

  • Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
  • Log in now to remove adverts - no adverts at all to registered members!
Status
Not open for further replies.
Obi Wan said:
Why are Valley and AFC voting on Astro when Bobby said Gerrez, Mikey and ACS. Gerrez I can msy e understand. But those two should shift if they are following Town tactics.
This looks dodgy as.

of course IF Astro is a bad guy then well played boys. <laugh>
Click to expand...

I was on acs, moved over to Astro so that he would use his vote on someone other than himself as people were complaining that it could lead to a late change, I'm quite happy to go for any of the three mentioned by BobbyD :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: J. J. McClure
Obi Wan said:
Why are Valley and AFC voting on Astro when Bobby said Gerrez, Mikey and ACS. Gerrez I can msy e understand. But those two should shift if they are following Town tactics.
This looks dodgy as.

of course IF Astro is a bad guy then well played boys. <laugh>
Click to expand...

I've voted for him to see if he would appear, and he did like magic. If Astro moves onto Mikey then it's problem solved, but im concerned that he hasn't done so. The question is why?
 
astroturfnaut said:
And Gerrez (who had just immediately before said he would not change his vote) decided to jump on that opportunity

and afcftw immediately backed him up

I am not questioning you
Click to expand...

To be fair people told Gerrez to change his vote so that he couldn't late save himself..
 
ValleyGraduate12 said:
It's looking increasingly likely to me at least, that he wants someone else to move onto Mikey so that he has the power with a last second switch tonight.
Click to expand...

Makes zero sense

If I made a last minute switch and killed an innocent I am dead next round and the other people in the coinflip are suspected
 
ValleyGraduate12 said:
My reason is clear enough. I voted for you as you hadn't voted. All of a sudden, you appear and cast a vote yourself.
Click to expand...
Funny hiw you, Gerrez and AFC all did this together. Either 3 random acts coincidentally all on the same player, or the biggest epic fail by a mafia team ever.
 
  • Like
Reactions: afcftw
God trying to catch up is hard sometimes lol.

So might have missed some info, but valley, gerrez and afc's votes (along with Astro on himself) have removed mikey from the tie and put Astro in?

interesting to see that, we're some trying to make it a 4 way to potentially shorten their odds of losing someone, or wanted to get mikey out totally?

cant imagine 2 of valley, afc and valley are mafia as all voting together at this stage in that kind of move would look very suspicious.
 
  • Like
Reactions: afcftw
afcftw said:
To be fair people told Gerrez to change his vote so that he couldn't late save himself..
Click to expand...

Yes but he could vote for anyone else but chose the only person he could drag into the coinflip, a deliberate decision to go against the cop
 
I dont trust the guys in the tie with their votes on themselves, its too easy to move off at the last second and claim you had a town role so had to save yourself, very mafia like to avoid your mafia mates incriminating themselves if that happens.

I say it should be a tie excluding own votes, so i would ignore ACS and Astro's votes. Its up to them to move their votes off themselves nice and early, we dont want last minute scrambles pls guys... Anyone agree?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Obi Wan
Why won't one of you put Mikey back in the mix instead as per Bobby's list?
 
So right now

1. Is valley exposing himself or not.

2. why is mikey safer now? Coincidence or not.

3. Are any of the others looking bad? If it had been a 3 way would we have any confidence any are mafia or other baddies.

So.... if someone up has a role... are you riding your luck and hoping here.

I'm basically just watching on. Don't think we've found anything out in last couple hours but you never know. Vally might be
 
There are really obvious explanations for why each of us has gone with Astro tbh, I wouldn't read much into it. Gerrez was told to change off himself and went Astro when he wasn't in trouble, valley claims to have voted for him to get a reaction and I voted for him purely to make him change his vote off himself, happy to switch back to one of BobbyDs three.
 
Sir Tennisball said:
I dont trust the guys in the tie with their votes on themselves, its too easy to move off at the last second and claim you had a town role so had to save yourself, very mafia like to avoid your mafia mates incriminating themselves if that happens.

I say it should be a tie excluding own votes, so i would ignore ACS and Astro's votes. Its up to them to move their votes off themselves nice and early, we dont want last minute scrambles pls guys... Anyone agree?
Click to expand...
AGREE! You 2 Move those votes now, or I vote for whichever survives tomorrow. Simple.
 
Gerrez's move makes a bit of sense given he was asked to move off himself. Not sure if when he moved the tables were even so his vote was on someone else to not disturb the tie..

afc and valley any reason for putting Astro in the tie?

ive no qualms with Astro being in there, as as likely to be mafia or sk or zombie as mikey, but if we agreed to follow Bobby, seems strange for a couple to go against it?
 
For the purpose of taking my vote off myself I will vote for someone else. I will vote Tobes until asked to change to anyone else
 
astroturfnaut said:
No I pointed out that the people voting for themselves could change their vote.

I never suggested the coinflip should be changed or the votes shouldn't be balanced.
Click to expand...

And the coin flip / lynch was never altered, the same three remained under threat once Tobes reinstated my four votes, something you clearly passed on doing about four times (I kept pointing it out)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom
Back