Off Topic Afcftw Mafia Game

[Joelinton's Right Foot]

Finally the two or three here from game 1 know full well I'd tie the lot of you in much better knots than this as mafia.

You know it's true Gerrez!

Idk, I think the knots I'm in seem pretty good!

Straight after the lynching result I was fairly sure that both Rolando (who really went after Biscan for some reason) and ACS (who screwed it for Billy) were looking very mafia-like. Then Valley's announcement had me convinced about you and Tobes, and then your explanation had me confused about everyone. At this rate I think there's about 8 mafia!!

 

[moreinjuredthanowen]

I'm not claiming a hidden power there, its what's been done in previous games. You should know since you've run most of them

I'd say run the numbers

If this is all just a huge ruse to get me my last kill then you decide 12 v 4 right now. With 1 serial kill to activate.

My one kill is not going to hurt town hugely of I have it even. You can't even be sure mafia can kill tomorrow..

But you've a chance to end cartel if Tobes is cartel.

Risk and reward

 

[moreinjuredthanowen]

Idk, I think the knots I'm in seem pretty good!

Straight after the lynching result I was fairly sure that both Rolando (who really went after Biscan for some reason) and ACS (who screwed it for Billy) were looking very mafia-like. Then Valley's announcement had me convinced about you and Tobes, and then your explanation had me confused about everyone. At this rate I think there's about 8 mafia!!

I've not even gotten started

 

[Joelinton's Right Foot]

I've not even gotten started

Errr, is that a half asleep mistake?? We're talking about how the mafia are tying me in knots and you say you haven't even got started?

 

[Super G Ted'inho]

I'd say run the numbers

If this is all just a huge ruse to get me my last kill then you decide 12 v 4 right now. With 1 serial kill to activate.

My one kill is not going to hurt town hugely of I have it even. You can't even be sure mafia can kill tomorrow..

But you've a chance to end cartel if Tobes is cartel.

Risk and reward

Which is why I agreed with Tobes being number one in your list.

 

[Joelinton's Right Foot]

I'd say run the numbers

If this is all just a huge ruse to get me my last kill then you decide 12 v 4 right now. With 1 serial kill to activate.

My one kill is not going to hurt town hugely of I have it even. You can't even be sure mafia can kill tomorrow..

But you've a chance to end cartel if Tobes is cartel.

Risk and reward

Quick question - just for clarity. Do you recommend that we lynch Tobes and then you investigate Valley tomorrow night? I think that's what you said?

 

[Super G Ted'inho]

"Serial Killer - one of the townies will be assigned to become the serial killer. When certain criteria are met the town member will receive a PM activating there role. Until this point they will not know they are the serial killer."

Anyone got any thoughts on what the "certain criteria" will be...?

It can't be when they get lynched as it would be bloody obvious who they are and how would he have survived anyway?

It could be once they receive so many lynch votes. However, I'm thinking it is activated if they are attacked/approached, whether it be Mafia, Cartel or a Townie.

Edit: although that would make it obvious to the person who attacked them too.

 

[Super G Ted'inho]

Quick question - just for clarity. Do you recommend that we lynch Tobes and then you investigate Valley tomorrow night? I think that's what you said?

We'd have a similar situation tomorrow since I'm pretty certain Valley will be investigating MITO too. However, lynching Tobes will tell us something about Valley. Plus if Valley has been compromised he'll be able to tell us tomorrow.

 

[Joelinton's Right Foot]

"Serial Killer - one of the townies will be assigned to become the serial killer. When certain criteria are met the town member will receive a PM activating there role. Until this point they will not know they are the serial killer."

Anyone got any thoughts on what the "certain criteria" will be...?

It can't be when they get lynched as it would be bloody obvious who they are and how would he have survived anyway?

It could be once they receive so many lynch votes. However, I'm thinking it is activated if they are attacked/approached, whether it be Mafia, Cartel or a Townie.

Could it be based on numbers left? Or when/if any particular role is discovered?

 

[Super G Ted'inho]

Could it be based on numbers left? Or when/if any particular role is discovered?

If we kill them first then the role never materialises. Of course finding them is difficult since they don't even know themselves. Could be any one of seventeen players atm

 

[Super G Ted'inho]

Have either of Tash or Nobbertos salsa inferno made a comment yet...?

 

[Joelinton's Right Foot]

We'd have a similar situation tomorrow since I'm pretty certain Valley will be investigating MITO too. However, lynching Tobes will tell us something about Valley. Plus if Valley has been compromised he'll be able to tell us tomorrow.

Whatever happens we need to be organised about it and have a plan. I'd like confirmation about who I can trust. Thinking you can trust someone seems worse than assuming you can't trust people. I'd like more clarity about the names we've had thrown at us tonight. There are too many ifs, buts and maybes.

 

[Joelinton's Right Foot]

If we kill them first then the role never materialises. Of course finding them is difficult since they don't even know themselves. Could be any one of seventeen players atm

I meant the sniper could be activated /if/when the doc was discovered, or when the first mafia was discovered, or something like that.

 

[Super G Ted'inho]

Whatever happens we need to be organised about it and have a plan. I'd like confirmation about who I can trust. Thinking you can trust someone seems worse than assuming you can't trust people. I'd like more clarity about the names we've had thrown at us tonight. There are too many ifs, buts and maybes.

I think Obi is the most trust worthy person atm but that's in no means 100%. Beyond that, I only trust myself

 

[Super G Ted'inho]

I meant the sniper could be activated /if/when the doc was discovered, or when the first mafia was discovered, or something like that.

Well its not the Doctor or Detective since they're both already discovered and dead

I was thinking it would be something that would tip someone over the edge and turn them into a killer. Maybe if someone attempts to kill the SK they die instead and the SK is activated that way; ie he gets a taste for it.

 

[Joelinton's Right Foot]

I think Obi is the most trust worthy person atm but that's in no means 100%. Beyond that, I only trust myself

I hope not

If that is true then he has all but confirmed that Nobby is the town drunk. If that is the case we have a silent drunk and mafia telling us who to lynch!!

 

[Joelinton's Right Foot]

Well its not the Doctor or Detective since they're both already discovered and dead

I was thinking it would be something that would tip someone over the edge and turn them into a killer. Maybe if someone attempts to kill the SK they die instead and the SK is activated that way; ie he gets a taste for it.

Now that would be interesting - and helpful!! Well, assuming it was the mafia who tried to kill him!

 

[Super G Ted'inho]

I hope not

If that is true then he has all but confirmed that Nobby is the town drunk. If that is the case we have a silent drunk and mafia telling us who to lynch!!

I'm not convinced someone would reveal their role at this stage. Valley and MITO obvious have though so who knows.

 

[Joelinton's Right Foot]

I'm not convinced someone would reveal their role at this stage. Valley and MITO obvious have though so who knows.

This is what concerns me. If MITO is the PI then I'd have preferred him to keep it quiet longer until he saw how the voting was going. The voting already looks like its going for lynching Tobes and I don't think there was any way the mafia would have targeted him if they thought he was just a normal one of us. Now he has set himself up as a target to be shot by the mafia when he already knows there is no doc to save him. Instead this comes across as more desperate and more about a panicked attempt to cover his tracks than any teamwork.

Maybe the meth head should kill tennis so that way we only lose a regular townie if mito is lying but kill mafia if he is telling the truth. I know there is a chance that both meth and tennis are telling the truth, but when you add in him admitting killing biscan then how far does a story have to stretch before it reaches breaking point?

 

[Brian Storm]

What the **** is going on?

You must log in or register to see images