You and I had both got Magic on the first or second day after he appeared within five minutes of me pointing his activity out (air enough, it may have been a coincidence as Magic and co claim). I'm guessing you was thinking the same as me; when it was the three of us on the same team, he was very quiet in that game but was posting elsewhere. It felt very similar.
In regards to actually saving someone, yes. In using the role to its best effect, did he ****. Plus I help the town to victory when I was doctor
Yup. As you say, may be coincidence but the fact he appeared and did the same as when he was on our team with the whole "not been reading not caught up" etc etc, just stunk of him having a read of the mafia board and them telling him what to do
Well he claimed the role undisputed meaning we had a relatively known innocent, and not only managed to save himself that night.. but managed to actually save a townie from getting killed the following night! In terms of being a dr, he was pretty impressive. Unfortuantely, in terms of a generic townie, he was a ****ing nightmare
I will say though, Mikey appears to be a very good player. Reading his comments whilst knowing he was Mafia and watching the reactions was very impressive. Got you clocked now though @Mikey
I started thinking magic was innocent and might even be the vigilante because on the second day when I said we should just kill him you were so adamant we shouldn't and assertively told me to stop. When you died and we found out you were the detective I thought you must have investigated magic on night one and found him innocent!
I'm annoyed at myself because I think I said it 3 or 4 times that he is probably mafia... He doesn't post often, but posts long informative info which is always useful to the town which to be fair is how he's played last few games. But piggyback voting was suspicious. I think his "random/accidental" save of me might have clouded my judgement slightly when it came to the choice of him or Funky to be honest.. I said a few times I think he's bluffing this and if he is, fair play, played a good game.
I was considered a known innocent when I had the role too. I bluffed that I was saving certain people for about four nights and whoever I said didn't get attacked and nor did I so I must have been doing something right. You did well yesterday though, there was a third post I record but for some reason the links not working. You posted a theory and it was spot on
Billy I thought at one point was the vampire hunter as on the first day he had liked comments suggesting lucaaas was guilty and throughout day one and two was going at Bodanki, so his actions and the investigation choices seemed to fit.
When I told you not to, Magic hadn't been active at all so I told you to stop because I thought MITO would deal with it. Magic posted on the transfer thread shortly after that conversation. I was investigating him on the second night but I got killed. Valley was biting me although he also got killed that night too.
I think yesterday it became quite obvious. I had a hunch Tobes was townie although I did think he had a role from one of his posts which I was wrong about. Billy was 100% mafia from how he was being very quiet and unhelpful and as pointed out, Magic was the magic from our mafia game sow as likely to be guilty. Should have gone with my gut on Mikey though and hinted for Angel to kill him and it would have been a clean sweep of mafia in 1 night.
Look lads you all enjoyed it I think. The amount of dead talking and arguments and tags etc shows that. Just stop killing off poor RHC. He's never got a real go at it. Need to actually try mind to read though but hey... still stop snuffing him. Afc I can tell you is not as bad as me playing the game. You all need to chill cos if I ever get a game you'll kill me in a day as I'll be that bad. I'm on phone as someone is occupying the TV room getting their bloody hair done so I cant post observations. However 1. Lucaaas might have got investigations wrong but his headlines must have had you thinking. He missed due to deaths first night but cleared himself. The cleared bod but only said ibwt is not mafia last. Not sure if any mafia thought he was hunter. He then voted against ibwt to see who'd bute . That was good stuff. 2. You all chose similar folks early so kills and investigates and protects all bounced off each other 3. You all missed 3 obvious tells that were given..... the 4th Gerrez saw himself and outed magic. 4. Last thing is looking at votes. You all wanted final table but two of you created chaos in last hours and the patterns of reactions were in there not the final votes . Good thoughts but the reasons why people ended up in a place told another story.
I thought it was obvious although by that point MITO had confirm my predictions and its always hard to judge when you know. The Mafia left the suicide bombing too long IMO but it worked out for them in the end.
I don't know how you all didn't think funky was innocent by the way, had a strong townie read on him as he clearly thought he was taking a logical approach even when he was accusing me when I was known as the doctor. He explained his thinking every time and there was a clear thought process. Even when he was totally off the mark. Plus his vote on day two was clearly not a mafia move, surprised others didn't make more of that. There was a moment towards the end of the last day were funky made me think twice to be fair when he started to be asked to be killed by the angel lol but in general I thought more would accept him as a townie.
He last about three days in the third / fourth game (two mafia teams and he killed Swarbs for being a manc). He made it bloody obvious what role he had (vigilante) though which got him killed
When Funky was going at my for the tag / screenshot thing I started to wonder if he were Mafia looking to create a reason to doubt me. He seem to give up once he realise no one else was going for it
No idea who was who. Make sure I'm not directing things in the town team If you think afc is bad mito goes on and on in a game Thanks again mito for setting this all up
