Not a massively useful investigation for me, definitely would've preferred it on like Funky or Billy but at least we're all on the same page. This is pretty straight forward now I reckon.
Still not sure about you... You've been helpful but because of that could be a good bluffer. Fact youve always been 2nd or 3rd vote makes me think you're potentially just piggybacking once someone else's votes which is classic mafia.
I haven't pushed votes because I have a more passive style of observing and deciding with all the information at hand, I'm not really a guy to just plow in and throw an early vote out to stir **** up, look back at the last two games and you'll see I played the same way, usually just gathering info, voting when I've weighed up the decision and then usually making big waffley posts. We've had proven or near proven innocents so I've let them direct votes whilst still giving my opinions on players and what we should be doing, plus there's been like 3 days of voting haha. The biggest problem town has in the games I've played so far is that it is an absolute mess and there is a struggle for cooperation and coordination, for me another person just trying to throw votes around and trying to lead town pushing and pulling in opposite directions is not going to help that so I try and keep things organised... Try and fail for the most part I guess. To be honest I think if you're still seriously doubting me at this stage it's just paranoia, I've played a town game, gone for town's best interests the whole way. The two people I've probably supported most are you and afc, even when you were under threat of lynch, you've had Magic pegged for ages and believe have been mentioning Billy for a while too and yet I outright saved you late from a lynch vs. another non-mafia. Why is a mafia going to stick his neck out to save a town up against for all they'd know would just be another town in Valley haha? A mafia is just going to sit back and let that happen. I defended you from a lynch when if I were mafia you'd be the biggest threat to my teammates, and then along with IIRC you and Bod was one of those defending afc both before and after his claim, and I comprehensively explained and defended why afc had to be medic when it was being doubted and pressure. Again, why would a mafia not try and let the medic get lynched if there's doubt, that's pretty much the dream for the mafia there. Funky has been dodgy all game, trying to bury people for little things and continually pushing the blatant medic and Billy and Magic have to be mafia or I just have no clue what they've been doing all game. Billy was my top mafia at one stage especially from the way he was active and arguing early but then as soon as he was pressured he just disappeared and has hardly been around since and the way Magic came back and since has still barely been around hiding behind not having all the info etc. they just have to be mafia. I even was outright suggesting lynching Magic early when he was inactive, so again if I was mafia with him I just don't understand that haha. I understand you being worried that somehow I've just bluffed the whole way and you don't want to risk me being mafia and that having happened, sometimes as town you just want to play risk-aversion and not stick your foot in it (I.e. the anti-AFC), but just logically there is no sense in being mafia here.
noon table IBWT; 1votes by: Lucaaas Billy; 2 vote by: IBWT, funky yet to vote: billy, magic, AFCFTW, Mikey
@Mikey agree you've played a good game and posts have been thought out and informative. Agree you played same way before but doesn't mean not just bluffing. I I don't think you're mafia... If I had to pick three t would be be magic billy and probably funky. I certainly think that magic and billy are dodgy and should be near the top of those votes. Id be worried if I still have 2 votes anywhere near 8pm though!
Ok, I pushed the blatant medic for a few hours. I've pushed him so continuously that I haven't voted for him once Jesus pay attention. Suspicious blame shifting if you ask me. You're not even aware of the details of the game. Watching you like a hawk now. Possible you've got another engender if you're not aware what's going on in the main game.
Innocent Funky Lucaas IWBT AFC Mafia Mikey Magic Billy Unless Afc has pulled of the mother of all hustles then that is our roles right there. Knowing I'm straight town tells me the mafia beyond any doubt.
I'm going to skate over how daft some of that is because otherwise it'd probably just dissolve into another argument which was more personal than game related. One question for now, if I've not been paying attention and am not aware of the the details of the game, can you explain the motive behind when you on day 2 after first questioning afc's claim, once you accepted the theory of it, you still pushed and suggested that we should lynch him anyway 'because he was a dead man'? I've rolled that one around in my head a few times and cannot ever see someone wanting to lynch someone they think is the medic is not a mafia motive? You claimed to be playing the odds all game, trying to lynch IBWT just because he claimed vanilla town and that was a 2/9 or whatever, but then wanted to lynch someone who was 99% town and a role rather than the odds of like 6/13 I think it may have been or I suppose even 6/11 if you discounted afc and lucaaaas of getting a mafia/vamp/SK in the lynch? I don't see how you can justify that as a town.
Can I suggest we lynch one of Mikey, Magic or Billy tonight. To help prove I'm not Mafia I'll vote where I'm told. They don't know who can investigate so if they suicide bomb they've got a 1 in 3 chance of getting the investigator, i should be investigated tonight.
What ever fella, do what you have to do. It's blatant I've been playing the odds, had nothing to go on till now. I know you're mafia. better get your suicide bomber out and take a punt. You suicide bomb will be either you, Billy or Magic as will be seen when you use him, you have to use him to get the investigatior or you simply can not win the game.
