Well tonight could go very badly. If if tobes is mafia then fair play as I thought from a few of his posts he was a townie
Can anyone give me a reason why funky would be mafia? As far as I'm concerned one of acs or funky are the other vamp, thre votes acted to save valley, or so it seemed, if they where mafia why would they both late switch to try to save someone who as far as mafia was aware was not mafia? It just doesn't make sense. Going "oh they late voted" isn't a reason for them to be mafia... It just doesn't make sense...
**** it, lets go all in. Tobes If this is wrong, on your head be it. (though I think you are right). Gonna play Witcher 3 now, will be back on around 8ish
7pm table: table: AFCFTW;1 votes by ACS tobes; 5 vote by: AFC, mikey, magic, billy, bod Funky; 3 votes by: ibwt, tobes, ACS yet to vote: Lucaaas
To protect myself or the person I think is the vamp hunter.... Probably better going for myself since they may not have figured out who the vamp hunter is...
As I said earlier but I'm guessing you missed as it was just as you were going off, can you properly lay out why Tobes and IBWT are mafia? I've seen you saying they voted together and that I think Tobes agreed with IBWT that Magic should be targeted but haven't seen exactly why in detail. I'm fine with the plan, and if I have to die for the sake of process of elimination then so be it but we have to nail one mafia tonight and since I'm not convinced IBWT is one then it's all on Tobes so would like to be really sure rather than just let myself die without questioning it.
my recheck is tobes; 6 vote by: AFC, mikey, magic, billy, bod, funky Funky; 3 votes by: ibwt, tobes, ACS yet to vote: Lucaaas thansk for keeping me straight.
The first thing I did was to look at the day one and two voting again but now knowing about the dead people's innocence or guilt. And then come up with every theory possible I could based purely on the vote tables. The vast majority of combinations I could make fit with the votes involved was a Tobes/IBWT team. I then looked at acs and funky and thre voting, particularly last night, I cannot come up with a mafia reason for there votes. It just makes no sense for them to be mafia. I then went back and re-read the first 20 or 30 pages for clues about people's roles and believe I figured out the vampire hunter. At this point I had it narrowed down to a likely group of suspects. I now went back to the voting tables to see if my ideas still fit. While this was going on both IBWT and Tobes made posts that suggested magic was "very dodgey" with little or no reasons, just dropped into there posts, not made a big deal of. I left it a while to watch if further links developed and IBWT and Tobes began supporting each other, suggesting each other's innocence and also stepping in to defend each other. I then asked for there top 3 targets, which match up with each other and fit my theory and once again drew magic in as a new target. They've also been the most vocal in the attempt to lynch acs or funky but I cannot find a reasonable explanation of how they could be mafia. And no-one has given one. Upon posting my theory Tobes turned on me straight away with IBWT backing him up. I didn't track specific post numbers which tipped me off sorry, I can try and find a couple of examples if you really wanted me too
What a crock of ****. You voted for RHC day 1 you blimp Don't follow this clown ffs, he's about to ensure that you lose an innocent. There's more holes in his 'logic' than a Swiss cheese, over the course of this game you've turned on every ****er with your half arsed baseless assumptions. You're about to lead the town to failure, well done
Yes I did vote for RHC day one, it was either him or IBWT I was going for. But that has nothing to do with any of my logic on why your mafia. I shall bring popcorn to the hanging!
Alrighty. Agreed that Funky and ACS's probably weren't mafia motivated with their votes, at this point I think ACS has to be the remaining vampire so he has to be killed at some stage, just a matter of when. Funky I'm not as sure about, I've had him marked down as town at times because some of the angles he's taken are town oriented but at other times he's stubbornly and persistently gone after things totally not in town's interest. I'm still not happy with him but can at least believe he is just a misguided town. The thing with both of them though, as someone who has played a fair amount of mafia in the past, I just can't wrap my head around how hard they've pressured and even suggested killing an unchallenged medic claim. I try and write it off to inexperience of game mechanics but it's just hard to ignore haha. Anyway, I've a bit more insight into your IBWT/Tobes call but can't say you've totally convinced me, but to be honest at this stage I don't feel my reads are rock solid enough to try and impose a different plan on town, and you seem so certain I'm on board with the plan even if I'm getting done. Hope you know what you're doing.
