hehe I was about to say this. I bet 20 minutes before 8pm one of the people who are up for lynching will suddenly claim to be the doctor. I am afraid I am resigned to believing AFC now. Anyone claiming otherwise now will almost certainly be mafia
Despite your gameplay I'm going to have to concede that the failure of anyone to come forward and dispute your claim makes you un-lynchable. So you'd be a wasted vote. I'm going to sit back and decide at the death.
Don't bite, not accusing, just thinking out loud. If you're the Doctor it stands to reason Mafia would step forward and claim it to cast doubt on an innocent and wipe the Doctor, they can afford to risk it with three players. If you're mafia it stands to reason the real doctor would stand forward. It's really strange nobody has stepped forward in either senario, very strange. I wonder if we're way of on the real doctor and he doesn't need to expose himself. Either that or the person who hasn't stepped forward doesn't fancy himself in a debate. That equate to lack of confidence, lack of intelligence or inactivity imo. Or maybe the real doctor knows if you're not dead after the next two hits you're outing yourself as the fake doctor and you expose yourself. Without him having to come forward as the real doctor. So many possibilities but I would have thought somebody else would have claimed to be a doctor by now. Maybe he's leaving it to the last couple of hours to reduce thinking time.
I'm a crazy guy. I think outside the box, often too far. I pick up on tiny things. Probably over thinking the detail.
The mafia haven't tried it because they know there are people who are on the verge who will assume they are guilty when they countr claim. It's difficult to actually pull off being a certain role if your not that role. Why do you think I was so confident on the first day that my actions wouldn't result in me being lynched? I think the problem here is what your assumptions are around the doctor and how they would act are different to how the doctors have acted so far in the mafia games on this board. Which is why I'm thinking your not guilty. Despite being off the mark I can see how your coming to your conclusions.
There isnt time for that. If we lose more than one townie tonight then we have lost, UNLESS, we take out atleast one mafia, preferably two.
It entirely depends if any of them fancy themselves under scrutiny. If it happens it's a 50/50 battle of who can convince the masses, very risky and could only be taken on by smart cat. I'll learn game by game as I get to see how people play it. I've always been a walk into lions den kind of bloke, throw myself in the deep and a learn from there. Every line of investigation i've taken has had logic to it, and often investigations hit dead end's. I'm not afraid to follow a line of inquiry. Surprised at how little investigation has been done to be honest.
Very true. But surely he'd see how today progress' at least. I'm expecting lots of movement in the last half hour today.
Just wondering, but are you keeping notes on the game MITO, like we had last time. I very much enjoyed, after the game, reading the hosts notes and his thoughts on all the action as it took place.
I personally wouldn't. If I were the doctor, for example, I would have publicly aired my disbelief of AFC's claim immediately. But by now, after seeing AFC influence much of the voting, knowing him to be mafia, I would have definitely come forward by now. Doing it too late does not help us, all it does is give AFC more time to influence people against townies, and give us less time to repair whatever damage he has done before the 8pm deadline.
So, Bod is a confirmed townie, AFC is assumed the Dr unless anyone can prove otherwise, so that's 2 out of the running. I'm an innocent without a special power, so there's 3. So that leaves Billy, IBWT, ACS, Magic, Mikey, funky and Lucas - 3 of whom are mafia and 1 of whom is the remaing vamp. So only 3 are townies, who's the most likely to be innocent? For me (cue it's teamwork shouts ) one is IBWT, which only leaves 2 more innocent to choose, investigate the next most likely innocent and pick 2 to put up for the lynch.
Actually yeah. So how do we explain why nobody has stepped forward? Maybe the mafia have left it too late to make their play?
Well yes, if AFC is the doctor, the mafia HAVE left it too late to cast doubt with a fake counter claim. Far too late. I can only conclude, in that case, that AFC is telling the truth.
So according to claims myself, ibwt and you are three of the 4 possible straight townie roles. I know I am so I'd hedge my bets one of you is lying. Is Luccas confirmed straight townie or unspecified townie like Bod? Anybody?
There are three townies left, they are Bodanki, lucaaas and one other. My guess is funky is that third normal townie.
