Personally I think the ****er is a pancake boy if ever I've seen one and useless at that. What do others make of him? Is he worth keeping on? Do his good displays outweigh his bad displays?
4 centre backs needed this summer to replace him, Brown, Coates and Vergini. How the feck we gona manage that .
None of the options. He was diabolical today and made school boy error after school boy error. We are too thin on the ground to let him go unfortunately. My hope is we bring in 1 or 2 new center backs in the summer and phase him out and he leaves at the end of next year
I disagree with that, at times he's looked very good but I think what he's cost us far outweighs what he's given us. He costs us matches far too often. Seems to have a trick of making it look like he's throwing them away all by himself.
He had a ****ing stormer against us. All your below par rabble did . Apart from the obvious, but why raise your game against us but be **** against everyone else?
[ Until he got his new contract then he has returned to type, f*cking gash. Get the c*nt out NOW. Preferably pay his contract up this morning, clear his locker and tell him to f*ck right off out of our club.
Depends where you are playing. Remember plenty of ****ty defenders over the years go down a division and end up looking the real deal. O'Shea was never good for whole seasons, he was prone to a wobble. If you're still playing PL football I'd imagine he'll still be there but you'll fetch in a new boss at the back.
Only looked good because there was no pace in your team. He was like a carthorse and completely at fault for goals 1,3 and 4 yesterday
he has to be replaced, obviously. he doesn't get much support fromthe rest of the back four but he's far too prone to **** ups for my liking
He may have made a few **** ups yesterday but where we're the rest of the that's in the back four. He was left exposed for the 3rd goal and was beaten in a flat race by a quicker player (shock). The 4th goal I haven't seen the replay but at the time thought he was unlucky not to get a free kick. Whether it was a foil or not you would usually get a free kick as a defender in that situation considering everything else Dean gave as a free kick yesterday. Anyway back to the original point he is still better than Vergini and Coates so we can't really afford to let him go. Oshea and Brown is still our best centre back pairing and considering both of there ages that really worries me.
He is too slow, and Palace exposed that time after time yesterday. He marshals the defence well but was yesterday too often left as the last man against a striker who had an extra yard on O'Sheas pace and yet was given no cover by the others. Catts was awful and didn't protect the back four. Im worried now although Id be cacking me keys if I were a hull supporter
The Real captain and leader is Catts! We're a better side with him In it simple as that. Captains of any sporting sides don't **** up nearly as much as John O'shea. Some fellas on here will have the odd whinge about catts ill discipline and too many cards. At least he wears his heart on his sleeve, can't say that for most of the team sadly..
O'****e was culpable for three of those goals yesterday. He has the turning circle of an oil tanker ship & is as quick as a ****ing traction engine. And he's a **** captain as well. Furthermore, he has far too much sway at the club. Getting people sacked because of his influence over Ellis & big tits. The sooner he's gone the better. We need three centre halves in during the window & please Mr Congerton. Ones with pace if you can manage that.
JOS is our achilles heel, attack him and we are goosed, even TV pundits are pointing this out now. He clearly hides behind Wes, without him he is exposed for what he is, painfully slow, useless at man marking and cant jump for a header , its an absolute joke when he goes forward for corners, all he is doing is making sure he is not left to defend a counter attack.
