Off Topic Mafia 6 thread
- Thread starter moreinjuredthanowen
- Start date
-
Please bear with us on the new site integration and fixing any known bugs over the coming days. If you can not log in please try resetting your password and check your spam box. If you have tried these steps and are still struggling email [email protected] with your username/registered email address
-
S
Super G Ted'inho
Guest
How can the town win though when everyone is suggesting I'm bloody Mafia?
Because you're Mafia
- May 22, 2011
- 73,774
- 25,704
- 113
And there was me recruiting you to join our victory last game
Favours are quickly forgotten in Mafia pal!
Seriously though, for the third or fourth time, if you're town you should actually be trying to show you're innocent and help town - offer opinions, ideas, things we can try... And not just repeatedly post single sentences exclaiming you're not mafia and vote for and accuse those that have voted for you purely on the justification that they voted for you. Your complete lack of coherent defence and flippancy actually makes me think you're not mafia as I just can't wrap my head around why a mafia would be digging their own grave and holding up a big sign saying 'lynch me', but at this stage you're making yourself look guilty which if you're a town is ****ing us.
A town is as strong as their weakest member. The most important thing for mafia to do is to blend into town and make themselves look like a town. To do that, the benchmark is the least helpful town, or the 2 or 3 least helpful. To avoid lynching, the mafia just have to be less suspicious or more useful than those players. Last game with the inactivity of Magic and a couple of others, and the complete meltown of RHC, you, Trev and Obi Wan were able to skirt through just above the level required by doing bugger all because they set such low benchmarks. This game you and Billy have played such mind-bendingly odd games that despite there being plenty of logical reasoning for you being towns, we almost have to lynch you, if you are towns we will have wasted two days lynches, lost two players and allowed the mafia to glide through having the easiest times of their lives. If every town is active, posting opinions, giving direction to town then the mafia have to do the same to not stand out and in doing so are more visible so are more liable to slip-up, and we can garner information from their reads that can help us figure out who is aligned with and against each other.
So in summary to fellow towns, the requirement for us to win is not just to chill, hope we vote correctly and wait for investigations, it is to set a level of activity and/or good town play that the mafia have to match and since they will be lying or withholding information they can incriminate themselves from.
Last edited:
Favours are quickly forgotten in Mafia pal!
Seriously though, for the third or fourth time, if you're town you should actually be trying to show your innocent and help town - offer opinions, ideas, things we can try... And not just repeatedly post single sentences exclaiming you're not mafia and vote for and accuse those that have voted for you purely on the justification that they voted for you. You're complete lack of coherent defence and flippancy actually makes me think you're not mafia as I just can't wrap my head around why a mafia would be digging their own grave and holding up a big sign saying 'lynch me', but at this stage you're making yourself look guilty which if you're a town is ****ing us.
A town is as strong as their weakest member. The most important thing for mafia to do is to blend into town and make themselves look like a town. To do that, the benchmark is the least helpful town, or the 2 or 3 least helpful. To avoid lynching, the mafia just have to be less suspicious or more useful than those players. Last game with the inactivity of Magic and a couple of others, and the complete meltown of RHC, you, Trev and Obi Wan were able to skirt through just above the level required by doing bugger all because they set such low benchmarks. This game you and Billy have played such mind-bendingly odd games that despite there being plenty of logical reasoning for you being towns, we almost have to lynch you, if you are towns we will have wasted two days lynches, lost two players and allowed the mafia to glide through having the easiest times of their lives. If every town is active, posting opinions, giving direction to town then the mafia have to do the same to not stand out and in doing so are more visible so are more liable to slip-up, and we can garner information from their reads that can help us figure out who is aligned with and against each other.
So in summary to fellow towns, the requirement for us to win is not just to chill, hope we vote correctly and wait for investigations, it is to set a level of activity and/or good town play that the mafia have to match and since they will be lying or withholding information they can incriminate themselves from.
Sounds like an excellent Mafia speech to me
No sooner than my suggesting Bobby as Mafia and he's on suggesting me as Mafia because "dunno why but something doesnt seem quite right". even when he claimed at same time that for Billy " very odd voting first night. Last night mafia didnt save him but it would be stupid for mafia to save him as that would mean we would know billy AND whoever saves him to be a mafia".
Don't know about others but that would seem a bigger reading on Billy (if you accept Bobby's logic) and would result in a vote for Billy rather than me...
unless my reading of Bobby is right or unless I'm the townie I was suggesting on the 3 way vote. Care to clarify Bobby? Don't think he is saying I am as other 2 Mafia guesses for Bobby were IBWT and Billy which would then suggest that Valley would be the Townie.
But Mikey has Valley down for lynching as Mafia and Valley has claimed me to be Mafia but Bobby claims to be following Mikey's lead.
My vote
BOBBY
who is playing lip service to Mikey's suggestion to townies giving reasons as he didn't actually give any reasons for his "alleged" suspicions and voting for me, a townie, based on absolutely nothing.
Haha nice revenge voting there morgan. I gave who i thought with other unknowns. I liked mikeys reasoning for valley. I still think between the no reads (of which i have 3) and you ibwt and billy there are 2 other mafias hiding in there.
Anyway i know I'm innocent so lets hope we root out these mafia
Anyway i know I'm innocent so lets hope we root out these mafia
S
Super G Ted'inho
Guest
That sounds like Mafia talk to me... Morgan
OK well at this point I can only imagine that Valley picked up on me mentioning a couple times that his refusal to actually act like a town or be helpful is actually making me think he's playing too dumb to be mafia and is now pushing that to try and double bluff his way to safety. Either that or he just doesn't care and isn't trying in which case he is no loss.
So yeah, vote for Valley guys.
So yeah, vote for Valley guys.
After today I vote to lynch Rodgers, Allen, Sakho, Can, Sterling, Moreno...the whole ****ing lot of them....and Arsenal fans as well
S
Super G Ted'inho
Guest
Just when you want Ghostbusters 3 to be filmed one of the stars is on here.
Have you even been reading the thread? I'm a tree stump, not a ghost
S
Super G Ted'inho
Guest
After today I vote to lynch Rodgers, Allen, Sakho, Can, Sterling, Moreno...the whole ****ing lot of them....and Arsenal fans as well
Sounds like Mafia talk to me... Billy
Last night in Tunisia .... I'm very pissed & love you all ( esp Obi ) 