Mevlut Erdinc

I am impressed with his higlights and what i've seen on youtube. However, i've not seen many full games with him, and can't make a full judgement on him, but the stats look decent. Have any of you lads seen many PSG games?

I've been sending messages to as many PSG fans as i can over youtube, trying to get some answers and opinions, but so far i've only gotten one and it was in French -

This was translated from French to English - Google translate doesn't make things that clear...

Erdinc was good forward in 2009/10, he was ok in 2010/11. He is good, but i think PSG should sell Erdinc and buy Champions Cup quality player. He is good for Newcastle and could play with Cabaye and Ben Arfa, but is not top quality for PSG.

So basically Erdinc is good striker, but obviously since PSG have these new owners, this particular fan has ambition of champions league football. He must call it champions cup instead. According to this fan, Erdinc is good, but not top quality.

I think Erdinc would be a good signing, but i think we should be another striker also.

15 goals in 31 games in the 09/10 season, 8 goals 22 apps last season.

That's alreet.

Here's one of his goals -

[video=youtube;FRXlxciTVxk]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FRXlxciTVxk[/video]

 

http://www.not606.com/showthread.php/61638-Mevlut-Erdinc

 

Couldnt you just have commented on the existing article? You do this all the time and this is why people say you are an attention seeker.

 

That other thread was about a news paper article and his possible transfer fee, this is a more in depth perspective of the player and thoughts about him. Same subject, different type of article.

 

You should become a scout for Newcastle.

 

It's not "in depth" you've just asked one person on youtube.

 

I've also looked at stats, comments about him, i've asked more than one person, but i've only got one answer back. I've also tried to look at as many clips of him as i can, to try and make a judgement, but as i said, i haven't seen many PSG games including him, so i can't make a full judgement on him. I'd like to hear if anyone else has watched many PSG games, and if so, can give their views on him and fill us with knowledge on the player.

 

I hope you get more replies on youtube, it'd be interesting to hear more opinions from people who've seen his full game. Hopefully he can score goals like that for us (if we even get him), i'd imagine being Turkish he'd manage to be a fairly decent prem player (most Turkish players aren't bad in the Prem, or in general for that matter!)

 

Hopefully i will, i've literally messaged like 40 people, mostly i think are PSG fans, quite a few may not be, but are French and seem to know alot about Ligue 1, and i found them all from comments on Erdinc or PSG related videos.

I'll post more if i get them.

 

okay if a mod merges this we must delete our messages having a go at this thread. Agreed

 

Can you delete your own comments on here?

 

yeah click edit post then delete post

 

Seems like google translate is pretty clear. Good a couple of seasons ago, alright last season but not good enough to trouble CL teams. Would link up well with our Frenchies. At the level we're at (a good season would be pushing for a EUROPA place) he'd do a job.

 

Here's some attention, Tash

 

please log in to view this image

 

Good article, not seen anything apart of the man apart from this video but he looks speedy and like he has good control and technique. I think him and Ba would link up well

 

yeah, it would have been impossible to put this on the other thread since there's no common ground between the two.

 

You typed that much just to say "He looks good, here's a video."

If I'm wrong, before you say "Did you read the article " No I didn't I'd rather pull my eyes out..

 

Welcome to 'Scout Report' with Heavy Metal Toon. Listen to Alex's wise and in depth analysis on current toon transfer targets from what he has gleaned both from his own sightings on the player and from his ever reliable sources, including Wikipedia, Cwarr07 and a random French Youtube user.

 

I've followed Ligue 1 since I arrived here.
Erdinc is alright. An interesting prospect.
But not worth all the hype, he does miss quite a few chances and can be quite frustrating at times.
We need another striker though, i don't think he will settle quickly in the prem. Hopefull y I'm wrong but from what he's played this season he hasn't been brilliant.