Mafia 4

Sorry o worded that badly. All I meant was in terms of you 3 reacted to my post the most and re reding your comment fair enough, you didn't actually say you think I'm Mafia (although none of you did in this words)

What I means was it caused suspicion and put doubt in your 3 minds by the fact you replied to it.

No idea of that makes any sense or not

All I see it doing is casting doubt on someone.

All I'd say is in theast 3 games the quiet ones in early rounds gt forgotten and they're often the Mafia. Sitting back waiting and watching. If I was Mafia again I'd def not be putting my name as a controversial person by making some risky comment like that!

In early rounds there are so many people you can easily hide away and get say with it (like apprentice early rounds) for example.

 

Can we include people with no votes? People often forget about them all together, especially the early rounds!

 

As a general rule in all mafia games, information is important so it you are not allowed to do things like post screenshots of PMs, post all or part of a PM in the "reply as quote" style, let people log into your account to see your PMs, use mod abilities to see PMs, share links to boards such as the freemason board, PM each other or communicate privately in real life, etc. etc. etc., things that should be obvious as cheating.

Beyond this is:

 

Basically we have to protect Sky at all costs unless we find out anything else about the rules

Bisc you may well be innocent but in a way we might as well threaten to kill you too If you're under threat from both town and mafia you might as well just ignore the threats from them and vote for who you want (if Sky is under threat as well as you).

 

Absolutely. If sky is any where near danger then I will change my vote to save him (unless my vote changes nothing but cant see us letting it get to that stage surely?)

I said I'm happy to change and take one for the team id it means sky staying. He's one of most important players so happy to do that.

 

I'd like to know why Bodanki voted for me. It's victimisation (again) and A ****ING CONSPIRACY. I'll keep my powder dry for now, before voting (probably for Bodanki)

 

Not true.

If you are Mafia and this is a Mafia bluff then the heavy will obviously not nominate someone, as if that person came forwards it would make you look guilty.

Tbh I did think of that scenario at first, then immediately realised it would not happen. So your post casts a bit more suspicion on you imo - if you know the Mafia aren't going to nominate anyone you would make that claim to try and convince people you are innocent.

 

It was discussed in the previous thread and I think its one of the things yet to be revealed

 

I was actually taking the piss with my first comment because I thought it was an oversight on your part, it was only after your response that I really questioned it.

 

If you mean in the table, I agree. always sit working out who's not had a vote

 

In fairness I want an even spread of a few (probably 4) without Sky tied by end of the day. As we know from early games the 1 vote each strategy can be a good way to start the first round but it's no good now with the "lean" and "known detective" elements. Best bet surely (as Mito said) is to have a few tied on a highish vote (enough to stop mafia fixing it to Sky).

If you're mafia the most Sky can get is 3, if you're not then the most he can get is 3 as well (if you can change yours late on).

 

Erm...I voted for you because you said you were going to kill me......Thats pretty much all I have to go on at the moment.
Since I know I am innocent, I have accept that you are either a) Mafia, so want to kill me for being a townie or b) Are being a giant douche

Either way until I get more info.....my vote is for you. I dont knwo whether you are mafia or not at this point, it was just a starting point bud.

In terms of IBWT, If he is mafia then voting for Sky is suicide. Quite possible its a plot of his, but at the end of the day the heavy has made us doubt him one way or another so voting for him might just be playing right in to their hands.......Gah I forgot how frustrating this was when you know jack ****.....

 

Insider knowledge???

 

Good point

Didn't think that if I was Mafia and bluffing that they obv wouldn't nominate someone else (unless Mafia team is really dumb)

In just trying to brain storm as many reasons as can think of, hard to think from their point of view though as I don't know what they're thinking.

My theory on that role is to put doubt in our mind. What better way than make someone vote for someone we know is obviously innocent?

Would any of you been suspicious of me if is have voted for anyone else? Probably not, so on that can it's worked perfectly for them, putting doubt about me (an innocent) into your minds.

 

Good point

Didn't think that if I was Mafia and bluffing that they obv wouldn't nominate someone else (unless Mafia team is really dumb)

In just trying to brain storm as many reasons as can think of, hard to think from their point of view though as I don't know what they're thinking.

My theory on that role is to put doubt in our mind. What better way than make someone vote for someone we know is obviously innocent?

Would any of you been suspicious of me if is have voted for anyone else? Probably not, so on that can it's worked perfectly for them, putting doubt about me (an innocent) into your minds.

 

Possibly

Good job UIR isn't playing #itk

 

A bit tired but otherwise good ta. And definitely innocent

 

Don't Mafia guys always say things twice...?

 

I have thought of that in prior games as well it'd be easy to do. If astro is ok with it cos it does affect them game then i can do it..

astro?

 

I can change late on but at a sacrifice to myself but I will take the risk of it means we save sky.

I can't see 3 other people voting for sky, it just means that they are definitely Mafia surely ?!

And if that happens, we all switch to one of them, kill them and then who ever else voted for sky!