Usually I only propose the 1 voe per person for the first day but with **** all happening and the way the votes are so far we are almost there already
Other than me being on two votes and several people getting away without suspicion for the second day running
Also are you suggesting we put it at one vote to see if anyone changes, or suggesting we make the lynching completely random?
I'm happy with it being random if no one changes. If someone does change we get information. And as far as I can tell no one is proposing a serious candidate to focus on yet anyway.
Hopefully other townies will listen to what I said and you wont get any more votes. I played an honest game before and have kind of played my hand just now. But due to me knowing you're not a threat I'm saving my vote so if worst comes to the worst I might be able to get you a coin flip. If RHC or Hash don't change there votes that is very suspicious, after the info I've just given. We'll see - I have a gut feeling that Swarbs is trying his hardest to stay in the game by making WILD accusations. But yet again we'll see on that one too.
It going to random is not in our best interests. We out number the KGB by some distance at the moment. Higher chance we just lynch one of our own without finding anything out. I'd rather we got a handful of people in real danger of going to see how people respond. I think we are giving the KGB an easy ride here. My suggestions to be in the running are four-five of these: RHC, lucaaas, Astro, danilo, hash, IBWT, billy, swarbs With RHC, lucaaas and hash the ones who have acted in a suspicious way and the others have stayed out of harms way.
Get a vote on the board then for now then, keep the 1 vote per person strategy viable so anyone not following it has to explain why rather than hide behind a multi-vote pile-on
No because I don't want to be seen suddenly changing my vote. I'm biding my time, I don't see the point of random voting. I need something to go vote for. I'd rather jump in and try and save someone that I know is innocent if I can at the last moment.
With a 1 vote each coinflip it does mean we will probably hit an innocent because we outnumber them, but it guarantees that the KGB recruiter is at risk and if we hit him we've almost won the game There is no one so important on our team who we will miss as much. The vigilante is only useful if he knows the bad guy and if we work that out we can vote anyway. The journalist is important too but him guessing to investigate the KGB is about as likely as us killing them with a coinflip anyway.
But right now the KGB are not in any danger and are clearly just sitting back, which they can continue all night
There is a 1 in 12 chance that we hit the KGB recruiter, there is a 8 in 12 chance we kill an innocent. At this point we have four roles to the kgbs two, so we are also twice as likely to damage ourselves with that tactic than to cause the kgb a problem. The maths says it's a bad idea to just put it to random. Not to mention us not learning anything from it and being in the same place tomorrow.
Unless we give them a situation where they have to do something... E.g. Actually put some people at risk.
1/12 is better than 0/5 or 0/4 or 0/3 if the the KGB are just sitting back and doing nothing because they don't have any votes yet Our roles are not as important as KGB roles
Exactly - which kind of goes against the point of the game, it just becomes repetative and boring. I wanna see people taking risks and livening the game up. Not ****ing about just giving everyone 1 vote. That should be day 1 only, the game should come alive by day 2. I guess the fact that 3 bad guys were hit last night, although good for the townies, kind of dampens the game slightly.
If we select 4 or 5 people the chances are that at least one of them will be KGB. If we go by what we think we know so far then there are probably KGB amongst the list of people I posted before. If everyone is on one vote the. The KGB just sit back and enjoy. We need to force there hand.
Yeah but we have people like you who want to wait until 7:55pm to vote and so **** all is happening If you want ****ing information do something to provoke it not just sit and see what other people do so they can all just say the exact same thing You are giving cover to the KGB - why the **** should they vote if you won't?
No change to table- just reposting it to keep in insight (and because I give it 5 mins before someone asks for it) Day 2 so far [table="width: 500, class: grid, align: left"] [tr] [td]Nominee[/td] [td]Votes[/td] [td]Vote(s) By[/td] [/tr] [tr] [td]Sky[/td] [td]1[/td] [td]Swarbs[/td] [/tr] [tr] [td]Magic[/td] [td]1[/td] [td]Astro[/td] [/tr] [tr] [td]Gerrez[/td] [td]1[/td] [td]Billy[/td] [/tr] [tr] [td]Astro[/td] [td]1[/td] [td]Danilo[/td] [/tr] [tr] [td]RHC[/td] [td]1[/td] [td]AFCFTW[/td] [/tr] [tr] [td]AFCFTW[/td] [td]2[/td] [td]RHC, Hash[/td] [/tr] [/table] Not Voted: Gerrez, IBWT, Magic,Sky,Lucaaas
