OT: Mafia game thread starts Sunday 8pm 14/9/14

If everyone stuck it out but we've with the last three votes, people don't! I switched in the last one despite insisting I wasn't voting until the final hour. I made the same claim for this vote but went for Minxy about two hours ago.

The votes for you make sense to me atm. I'm suspicious of Minxy and her voting for you (who I believe is innocent) would suggest I'm right. Nozzer as voted for you because you voted for him. However, his refusal to change could suggest there is more to it, not convinced at this stage though.

 

Which at the moment is me or AFC unfortunately Take me out and see I'm innocent then you know AFC is mafia (guard dog not Don I suspect) and Bod is more than likely still involved with Nozzer becoming another prime candidate. Take AFC out (and remote chance he IS innocent) then you'll be having a Billy lynching which I really won't be arsed arguing against as I'll look dodgy as ****

 

Wow, took a long time to read all of that.

I still think Billy is guilty, it's a case of "he doth protest too much".
Also I am pretty sure IBWT is voting for him to clear his own name, since I believe he is mafia too.
I have the Don nailed down to Milk, Nozzer or IBWT........Don't think its Minxy, and Gerrez, if he is mafia, was only converted last night.

AFC could be mafia, and stitching me up like a kipper! But I still aint decided who I am voting for....gimme a little more time...

 

You don't know I'm innocent (unless you're Mafia) - but you know statistically I'm most likely to have been innocent before last night unless I was the don (only reason snitch would cover me and I've been too active to be the don even if I were Mafia).

You also know by sheer dumb logic that there is a 50% chance IBWT was guilty before last night. And you're sticking on a needle in haystack conversion on me rather than a 50/50 on IBWT.

What are we supposed to read into that?

 

the point of the snitch is to create a way to balance the cops. last game we say one cop basically end the game in round 2. i myself fought hard to get it to round 3 but it was all over. you guys have exactly the scenario i intended right now.... i will not comment on the game specifically as it is running.

in future as long as there is balance the game runs well. i put in the vigilante due to numbers and thought about one or two cops so the snitch allows two cops.

you could:

a)limit snitch to one successful time

b) force rotation like the doctor.

c) convert the role to make it less targetted, as in have the snitch as a role that could be sent out and give false info no matter which cop sees him. i could randomly select which cop and the result on the night they are sent out if flipped..... then the power is lost.



anyway i thought you love snitches?

 

Exactly. So putting two or three at risk from the six we knew were innocent gives us a chance to watch for any reactions. It will be hard to judge be we've been a erratic bunch when its come to final hour voting

 

Could also limit the number of investigations a cop can make!

 

Danilo's claimed clear's me from your theory then

 

The lack of activity from the Don cause the short game last time. Same could be said of this time as the mafia shouldn't have any actions left now and it should be 6:4

 

Do innocent men not protest their innocence?

 

Yeah... Gerrez is safe... because if Danilo were Mafia then Gerrez couldn't be.
If Danilo is still town then his investigation would have said doctor... unless snitch was on him and then it would have said Mafia.

Under no scenario could Gerrez be Mafia. (unless he was never the doctor to begin with... and the real doctor stayed quiet all this time which is highly unlikely).



Gerrez is a known innocent again.

 

Usually but with a little more dignity and less finger pointing, you seem to be deflecting rather than reasoning.
And bringing up the "My fellow reds"
Dude, Mafia dont care which team you support, they are all AC Milan fans anyway

 

Sigh...what's the voting table like again?

 

What we know.

We know that Gerrez is innocent.
We know that (3 out of 4 of) Sky, Danilo, Milk, Bod are almost certainly innocent. (one of this list probably guilty but hard to tell which)

We know that at least 3 out of AFC, Billy, Minxy, Astro, IBWT and Nozzer are guilty.

 

It hasn't changed in a long time... seems the mafia is quite happy with myself, Billy, and Minxy having a threesome tonight. Most likely an innocent dies tonight.

It will be 4 vs 5 tomorrow... almost certainly game over because no one will use logic.

 

Surely more likely to be Napoli fans

In fairness I've done little but provide reasons all through the game As for finger pointing...pot, kettle etc

Obviously bringing up "my fellow Reds" was a joke as the only mafia caught so far was a Red however it also gives me full licence once my innocence is proven to have a regular pop at "my fellow Reds" for being a bunch of disloyal ****s

 

Is this still up-to-date?

 

If its 5:4 tomorrow, I suggest we all agree now to vote for Billy tomorrow (if he's still alive). Reason being, we need to vote in unison to outnumber the mafia and Bod/AFC will not change from Billy #allornothing

Sorry Billy


We need a alternative should billy be killed though. Since I'm now 100% innocent thanks to Danilo's input. If people are happy with it, I'll choose who that is tomorrow

 

I dunno...you seem quite energetic in trying to get us to change our votes.

 

Maybe thats why they're not changing?