OT: Mafia game thread starts Sunday 8pm 14/9/14

No, they switched to Lucaaas when it was obvious he was guilty... I hope common sense prevails.

 

Reasons for Nozzer and IBWT? I'd suggest (as I'm being sacrificed) I'd prefer to choose AFC to be in there (either in place of one of the other two or as well as). His pursuit of me has been nothing short of reckless and blatant Hardly fair for me to agree to go for the chop if one of my biggest suspects is ignored....**** that

#nowitspersonal

 

Ahhh point taken... yes... and Bod has the added benefit of already having one disciple, AFC, who is unwavering in his support!

 

So just number 2 then Magic = the worst vigilante ever

 

They tried to protect a known guilty player. Even more suspicious is IBWT who once he saw Lucaaas was doomed switched over... obviously knew Lucaaas was guilty and didn't want to be associated.

I change my vote to IBWT - I guess he's more likely to be Mafia of the two...

 

Magic was right saving his special ability... he had more chance of hitting an innocent than a guilty person in first few days as no one had a clue. His only downfall was not logging in on the day the Mafia failed to use their ability- making him look guilty- and then coming out saying he had a role!

 

The voting did change when Billy was threatened but the conspiracy theory that Danilo, Billy and Lucaas were all in on it is a bit too far fetched for me. However, ATM Billy, Bod and Minxy are at threat so lets see what happens.

 

So just ignoring the fact that Gerrez suggested it and a couple jumped on board (me and him) but then once no one else did I changed back to Lucaaas who was obviously going anyway. I could have changed to anyone it wouldn't have mattered. Wasn't trying to save Lucaaas if you think that then you think Gerrez is mafia as it was his suggestion.

 

I have to say though I might have done the same in IBWT's position. Even as an innocent we look to protect ourselves from suspicion surely It's worth considering it, however it's as flimsy evidence as AFC and Bod are trying to hang me on.

 

Doesn't matter about coin toss, we're not going to get one if mafia is at threat anyway. We're better off picking the person we'd suspect but also get the most answers from their hanging.

I still think the mafia would convert one of sky or Danilo. Why would they leave us with two cops? Although, the chances of us believing we still had two cops would be minimal too. Only way around it is if both cops were honest and they happened to investigate the same person. But now I've said that...

I'd have saved it too. Well, maybe I'd have killed AFC #joke

 

Lets look at this another way. Before last night we were fairly certain the following were innocent:
Gerrez, Sky, Danilo, Milk, Bod (any one of which could have been converted since)

Therefore we know (or strongly suspect) that three were guilty out of:
AFC, Billy, IBWT, Nozzer, Astro, Minxy



Three of those people:
IBWT, Nozzer and Astro all tried initially to defend Lucaaas (now of those three - Astro's actions WERE consistent with his day 1 and day 2 actions so that relieves some pressure on him).

Minxy was late to change vote to Lucaaas, but wasn't on much anyway.



Draw your own conclusions.



Ignoring conversions (which was most likely Sky, or Danilo... then Gerrez, Myself and Bod... but could be anyone) This is my guess at who is most likely Mafia BEFORE conversion last night- in order of suspicion:

IBWT
Nozzer
Astro/Minxy
AFC/Billy
Bod

--- totally unlikely---
Sky
Gerrez
Danilo
(and of course I know it's not me)

 

I do things for a reason and would never change to protect myself as that adds to the potential suspicion. I stand by my actions. I switched from Lucaas to Danilo because no one was trying to save Lucaas, seemed like a setup to me at the time.

 

No, in fairness mate the voting only changed when Danilo came out I was still at least joint top at the time.

Maybe Danilo was mafia and was trying to save me eh As of yet though no-one has come out to suggest he wasn't the real investigator then, even if he might not be anymore.

 

Minxy withdrew her vote completely last night.

 

I made a post a while back where you were in the lead until I changed my vote from you to Nozzer to even things up a little

 

Hmmm... interesting... not sure what to make of that... if she removed her vote from Lucaaas because she wasn't sure... or because she hoped it would save him...

... I suspect that lessens suspicion on her.

 

"Lets look at this another way. Before last night we were fairly certain the following were innocent:
Gerrez, Sky, Danilo, Milk, Bod (any one of which could have been converted since)

Therefore we know (or strongly suspect) that three were guilty out of:
AFC, Billy, IBWT, Nozzer, Astro, Minxy"


With that, I'd like a table update please

 

Her reason was she didn't have a clue what was happening and was far too confused to vote.

 

Thank you. I feel bad I've voted for you now
I'll prob change tonight anyway depending on what's happening but milk will prob see that as me protecting you like he thought I was protecting Lucaaas though

 

Anyhow... I'm going to be off for a while (will defo be back before vote)... but please use logic. Don't just vote for someone out of retaliation. Town has to hit Mafia again tonight.


Draw up a list of who has to be innocent and who is likely guilty... make an informed vote- don't vote on gut, revenge, or just because... make your vote logical. If Town misses tonight it's almost certainly game over... One more Mafia dead and we still have the advantage of numbers.